Conspiracy 365 Mafia - End Game - Town Win
- Thread starter hedger_14
- Start date
Dr. Pepper
Chairman of Selectors
Gonna give it til tomorrow morning before discussing the possibilities about the silencer. Should give them enough time to post something.
BKB1991
Panel of Selectors
I am not sure if we should wait for the silencer? I mean whats the point, now that the secrets out, mafia can silence one of their own mates, and we dont be able to tell the difference between them or when a townie has been silenced.
I think I have lynched Dr. Pepper but I am not 100% sure hes mafia or not. Atm I am inclined to go for Dr. Pepper or Aditya.
I think I have lynched Dr. Pepper but I am not 100% sure hes mafia or not. Atm I am inclined to go for Dr. Pepper or Aditya.
I agree that Aditya has been defending himself quite vigorously but sometimes you're in a no win situation when you get accused based on not much.
Dr Pepper always looks scummy to me when he plays; doesn't seem to matter if he is town or mafia. Happy to pressure him a bit to try and find out...
Dr Pepper always looks scummy to me when he plays; doesn't seem to matter if he is town or mafia. Happy to pressure him a bit to try and find out...
Dr. Pepper
Chairman of Selectors
I think it does matter as it's important to see who it is that's been "silenced". As people have said earlier, the mafia could easily get one of their team mates to pretend to be silenced. And even if we take the silencer out of the equation, I'd like to hear the thoughts of everyone in the game.
----------
That hurt.
----------
Aditya seems to bring it on himself every game by over-doing things. It's difficult to distinguish whether it's scummy or just his style of play.
----------
That hurt.
----------
Aditya seems to bring it on himself every game by over-doing things. It's difficult to distinguish whether it's scummy or just his style of play.
Chewie
BCCI President
There's nothing in the writeup about a silencer, and seeing how thorough it is, I don't think there is anyone silenced today.
@BKB I don't think it's a SK cos on the first night didn't the individual roleblock someone?
It could be Themer trying to get on the back of someone he knows is town so that in the event he goes down there is suspicion on that guy. Normally mafia try not to associate with each other at all. I would say Mani is the most suspicious at the moment though.
wrt Mark I don't think there's really anything suspicious about him. I think his lynch was an honest mistake by not reading the post before him.
----------
And also, to back up one of Abhas' points, it's possible that the silencer was the one who carried out the kill. Something about how he had done his job the previous night but had a bigger job tonight? There aren't many non-lethal mafia roles.
@BKB I don't think it's a SK cos on the first night didn't the individual roleblock someone?
It could be Themer trying to get on the back of someone he knows is town so that in the event he goes down there is suspicion on that guy. Normally mafia try not to associate with each other at all. I would say Mani is the most suspicious at the moment though.
wrt Mark I don't think there's really anything suspicious about him. I think his lynch was an honest mistake by not reading the post before him.
----------
And also, to back up one of Abhas' points, it's possible that the silencer was the one who carried out the kill. Something about how he had done his job the previous night but had a bigger job tonight? There aren't many non-lethal mafia roles.
MaD
Chairman of Selectors
- Joined
- Dec 19, 2008
- Location
- Sydney, Australia
Yeah so if nobody was silenced and Maney came on and didn't post, than he's probably pretending?
treva
ICC Chairman
I know Ben has his missus up at his this week, so his activity is likely to be minimal. From the write up I'd agree that there doesn't seem to be anyone silenced today.
P
pcfan123
Guest
you better be hammered
hedger_14
ICC Chairman
Vote Count
Dr. Pepper (2) - Haarithan, BKB1991
barmyarmy (1) - Papa Smurf
Mark (1) - Highlander999
Dr. Pepper (2) - Haarithan, BKB1991
barmyarmy (1) - Papa Smurf
Mark (1) - Highlander999
Papa_Smurf
International Cricketer
I don't think just because it wasn't in the write-up, there has been no-one silenced. There was no mention of it on the previous write-up either. But maybe, the silencer was the one who performed the kill, or tried to perform a kill, and failed. The write-up says he was successful last night. And we know that wasn't Themer.
Who's yet to post? Is it just Num? And following on from what BKB and the others mentioned, I agree it the mafia would have band-wagoned on the RPHKR lynch. Interestingly, Tom was the one who lynched immediately after Themer.
I'm going to re-read the thread later on today, and see if I can find something fishy. Right now, I don't have that many people I find suspicious. So my lynch on Colin stays.
Who's yet to post? Is it just Num? And following on from what BKB and the others mentioned, I agree it the mafia would have band-wagoned on the RPHKR lynch. Interestingly, Tom was the one who lynched immediately after Themer.
I'm going to re-read the thread later on today, and see if I can find something fishy. Right now, I don't have that many people I find suspicious. So my lynch on Colin stays.
Papa_Smurf
International Cricketer
I'm now tempted to go back through the old games, check out your hunches and prove you wrong
Haha, you might a find a few then
Still backing my intuition though.----------
There aren't many examples though. I've only been Town in 2 games, excluding this one
Chewie
BCCI President
Yea that's a good point about the silencer not being in the first writeup. Still I can't think of any other non-lethal mafia roles so I assume that the godfather used the silencer to kill someone.
Similar threads
