Conspiracy 365 Mafia - End Game - Town Win

[MaD]

If I was mafia, why would I jailkeep Haarithan 2 nights in a row, when there's no role for me to block by doing so?

You know what's more overpowered than town having a doc, roleblocker, jailkeeper and jack of all trades? The mafia having a roleblocker and jailkeeper.

Why would I jailkeep Chewie last night? He's claimed vanilla and if I was mafia, I wouldn't bother with him, I'd go for Abhas since he'd have the ability to roleblock the godfather and root us out.

I find it hard to believe that you think I'm mafia provided there's no evidence against me besides the fact that you don't need a Jailkeeper.

I'd be sus of you if Chewie came up mafia, which I'm pretty sure he will unless you can somehow explain how there was no kill tonight, but you've claimed doc and I can't really.

 

[pcfan123]

switched spoobir and tom succesfully

 

[Abhas]

Mark, do you switch the persons being targeted, or the people they will target?

 

[pcfan123]

you have the ability to swap two people and everything about them will be swapped. They will target each other?s target and any role used on them will be directed to the other player. Use your role wisely though.

 

[Abhas]

Hmm.. Then I believe Tom might not have a role at all. Because when you switched me and Tom, I was unsuccessful in role blocking mad.
Not sure though. BD confuses the crap out of me.

Anyways, guys I might not be able to login to PC much today since my grandmother's in hospital, and I might be there most of the day.. Please don't hurry on the lynches.

FOS: chewie, bkb, spoobir

 

[barmyarmy]

@Mark - so it's both then. I need to go back and look at the night actions with that in mind.

 

[Haarithan]

While my prime suspect remains to be Chewie, there's something not quite fitting MaD's claim if he was 'town aligned' as the jailkeeper.

He knew what he was doing. He wasn?t going to make it easy for anyone. He completed his job and with that done, he decided to call it a night, not knowing what he had ended up preventing

This's from Night 0's write-up regarding the bus driver. Let's see how MaD interpreted it initially on Day 1:

Gotta be the bus driver or maybe Jailkeeper

Does he mean to say he might have done something here? Then here's his post that entirely contradicts it:

Ok, I'm the Jailkeeper and I think I might have stopped the kill last night since the writeup mentions that the mafia guys couldn't find his target, I jailkept Callum.

I've jailkept Haari the two nights before last since I didn't want to block any power roles and it allowed me to protect Haari as I expected the mafia to go for him since as DV he's pretty much confirmed town.

----------

Also I think that explains why barmyarmy was unsuccessful by targeting Haari.

Clearly he says he didn't use his role on Night 0?

Maybe, I'm a reading a bit too much, but hey I'd like to know what exactly you did on Night 0.

FOS: MaD, BKB1991

 

[MaD]

I didn't use my role.
I'm not sure why I said maybe Jailkeeper tbf, just did.

 

[Papa_Smurf]

If I was mafia, why would I jailkeep Haarithan 2 nights in a row, when there's no role for me to block by doing so?

We've only got your word that you jail-kept those two. Let's not forget - you can also jail-keep your fellow mafia mates as well. They would be protected from the vigilante, and be immune to night roles used on them. Yeah, they might get role-blocked, but that might explain why treva was delegating the killing role earlier. Especially as you guys already had a role-blocker in the beginning - so there was no need to use you in that sense.

You know what's more overpowered than town having a doc, roleblocker, jailkeeper and jack of all trades? The mafia having a roleblocker and jailkeeper.

Not really. The target you jailkeep is immune to all other night roles, which does hurt your cause somewhat. And like I said, the jailkeeper can target his fellow mafiasos for protection as well.

Why would I jailkeep Chewie last night? He's claimed vanilla and if I was mafia, I wouldn't bother with him, I'd go for Abhas since he'd have the ability to roleblock the godfather and root us out.

For your own protection more than anything. You knew you're going to get some stick today, as there are big holes in your story, and glaring flaws in your gameplay. This way, you can defend yourself, and hope that Ben backs you up as he may have tracked you.

I find it hard to believe that you think I'm mafia provided there's no evidence against me besides the fact that you don't need a Jailkeeper.

No. You've been jumping on bandwagons a lot in the first few days. Read back and you'll see. One minute you're lynching Aditya, the other you're going on about P_Squared. It's really suspicious. That and you still haven't answered that the write-up has more than twice mentioned you're looking for some information. And you're still to answer for it.

I'd be sus of you if Chewie came up mafia, which I'm pretty sure he will unless you can somehow explain how there was no kill tonight, but you've claimed doc and I can't really.

There was no kill last night because I protected myself and was successful. I wonder who the other guy was who also tried to protect me? I'm thinking it might be Colin, but I can't remember if he was male or female. Let me check.

----------

Colin's male. I'm sure it was him who was with me last night. Enjoying the blue skin and stroking the beard tenderly x

 

[Haarithan]

ne minute you're lynching Aditya, the other you're going on about P_Squared. It's really suspicious.

Nah, he didn't lynch PS. Only Aditya until now, and yeah, he has jumped on bandwagons.


RPHKR - Varun, Papa Smurf, barmyarmy, treva, Dr. Pepper, Themer, Highlander999, Chewie, AngryPixel, Mark

Dr. Pepper - Haarithan, BKB1991, Spoobir, barmyarmy, Papa Smurf, P Squared, Abhas, Mark, Treva

Aditya - (Before Claim) Highlander999, barmyarmy, MaD, CG123, AngryPixel, Spoobir (After Claim) Papa Smurf, Mark, MaD (again), Manly2k9

P Squared - (Before claim) Treva, Abhas, barmyarmy, Manly2k9, Aditya, AngryPixel, (After claim) Spoobir, Mark, Papa Smurf

treva - Papa Smurf, CG123, barmyarmy, BKB1991, Haarithan, Spoobir, AngryPixel


People who voted for two mafias only: Haarithan, BKB1991

People who voted for one mafia + one townie: Abhas, CG123

People who voted for all five: barmyarmy, Papa Smurf

People who voted for two townies + two mafias: Spoobir

People who voted for one townie only: MaD, Chewie, Aditya

People who voted for three townies + one mafia: Mark, AngryPixel

People who voted for two townies only: Highlander999, Manly2k9

 

[Papa_Smurf]

Not sure if voting pattern is a reliable way to analyze a person. Mafia's generally tend to play their natural way when it comes to that.

 

[Haarithan]

Not sure if voting pattern is a reliable way to analyze a person.

Yeah I know. Just pointing out that MaD didn't lynch PS.

 

[Papa_Smurf]

Fair enough. But he definitely jumped a lot.

 

[Haarithan]

Yeah. That's for sure.

Also, what's the worst case if we lynch off Chewie today? After all, he's only a vanilla as per his claim, so even if we mis-lynch him, the loss won't be huge enough, and if anything, we might get MaD tomorrow. On the other hand, MaD has an important role, so I'd suggest keeping him for atleast one more day.

Also, BKB's getting increasingly suspicious on my mind. Yeah, he might have lynched only 2 mafias, but his claim and its connection to the write-ups until now has been NULL. Also the fact that he was the godfather in my game, and the only lynch he managed throughout was that of his own pal in the mafia roleblocker.

 

[Papa_Smurf]

Unlike you other guys, I don't find Chewie, and for that matter AP, that suspicious. Here's my list of the most suspicious from most to least.

1) MaD - already explained.
2 ) BKB - already explained.

Pretty convinced they're both mafias.

3) Spoobir - if we don't win the game after lynching off the above 2, then I think there might be a cult/individual left. Cult leaders sometimes have vig-like killing roles. Could be SK as well, but I've never seen one who has %chances of hitting.

4) Chewie/AP - if we still don't win after Spoobir, then I think it will be time to go after the vanillas.