Conspiracy 365 Mafia - End Game - Town Win

[Chewie]

The writeup hasn't had references for everything so just because there was no mention of the mafia trying to kill someone doesn't mean they didn't attempt to but were stopped because of the doc or other means.

Personally I don't think MaD is mafia. I am more suspicious of BKB because of the poisoning thing, but as I said before, not everything is there in the writeup.

The voting pattern thing isn't really too useful. If anything all it's serving to do is show how you've only voted for mafia members, and reminding everyone of this fact.

----------

Also, PS makes a good point about Spoobir being potentially cult or individual.

 

[barmyarmy]

We've only got your word that you jail-kept those two.

The write-up would appear to suggest it too.

 

[Papa_Smurf]

Not really. He could be jail-keeping treva for all we know.

 

[barmyarmy]

But there was a kill on night 2 so he couldn't have jailkept Treva.

 

[Papa_Smurf]

Just read it again. You're right. Treva performed a kill that night.

But that write-up also mentions that he's looking for some info out of whoever he kept jailkeeping. He hasn't answered that yet.

 

[Haarithan]

Done with your revamped night role's chart, Colin? Definitely makes things further interesting now that the actual target's roles get swapped too regarding the BD.

 

[barmyarmy]

Ok, here is the updated night role list with some bus driver interpretation...

Night 0 (Themer and Highlander999 swapped)
I actually investigated Themer but was blocked
Themer blocked Highlander999's target. Failed so either Tom had no target or his target had no role.

Night 1 - blocked

Night 2 (PSquared and Smurf)
Smurf protected PSquared's target (no-one)
Manly tracked PSquared not Smurf (but was blocked anyway)

Night 3 (Abhas and Highlander999)
Abhas blocked Highlander999's target. Failed so either Tom had no target or his target had no role.

Night 4 (Highlander999 and Spoobir)
Spoobir tried to kill Highlander999's target. Failed so either Tom had no target or his target had no role.


I would say that the above (sadly) clears Tom.

 

[barmyarmy]

Night 4


She knew her target this night. He wasn?t hard to find and didn?t put up much of a fight as the women forced him into the car. The young lady was also looking to stop this guy but she seemed content that he was unable to do anything tonight.​

MaD jailkeeps Chewie. Abhas can't find him.

She thought she was the target tonight and locked herself in her room. ?Hey, what are you doing here?? she asked, suspiciously. ?I?m here to protect you,? the older boy replied. ?I don?t need your help with that!?

Smurf protects himself (wasn't sure if he could do that). I protect him too.

Off he went again, searching for his items as usual. This search wasn?t as successful as his last though as he walked home with nothing to show for his work.

Callum fails to find his item again.


Fairly straightforward write-up.​

 

[AngryPixel]

Well I've already role claimed and don't know what more i can do. But if i get lynched and we manage to hold off the night kill then you remaining townies know who to lynch. i.e: MaD and BKBB who started this bandwagon.

 

[Spoobir]

Lynch: MaD

I think he could by lying about jailkeeping Chewie to get him lynched. Still don't like that the town seem to have so many blocking power roles, but then there have been a load of kills stopped during the night throughout the game so hedger could have just screwed his balance up.

That said I still tried to kill Chewie last night. Since we're so far ahead I really see no downside to getting rid of a suspicious player without wasting a lynch.

Obviously I failed because Mark decided to switch me which is interesting considering the only person I've killed at night is a mafia, hopefully it was to try and save me from the mafia kill, eh Mark?

 

[barmyarmy]

Ok quick votecount to help me get my head round where we are:

Chewie 4 - Haari, MaD, Abhas
MaD 1 - Papa Smurf

Going back to my list I guess I'd have to FOS AngryPixel, BKB1991 and Chewie as mafia. MaD is quite possibly anti-town but I don't think he's mafia.

Looking at those three in a bit more detail:
AP has been under the radar. Early on we thought that Near was town because he was inactive but wasn't being prompted to post by mafia team-mates. Vanilla is always going to be a weak claim at this stage. Hard to tell AP's alignment from his play normally.
BKB1991 is an interesting one. He's either saved two people including me from poisoning (at very long odds) or made up the fact there's a poisoner. The fact that there have been no deaths from poison and no hint of it in the write-up obviously counts against him. Looking at it the other way round, if he was mafia healer would be a strong claim because if there is no poisoner he can't be counter claimed and the town can't be sure... If he is mafia it follows that he must have a role otherwise he wouldn't be able to explain what he was doing if tracked. We've already had silencer, godfather and role blocker. If he was poisoner he wouldn't have claimed healer so I'm wondering if he's some kind of role cop/thief. The mafia did pick off varun very quickly after all.
Finally Chewie. As I said earlier I almost can't remember a game I've played with him where he's not been mafia so my point of reference is a bit distorted. The strongest evidence against him is that there was no kill last night. Let's analyse that a bit more closely. There's no mention anywhere of the killer in the write-up which could imply that he was jailkept. Hedger could also be screwing with us in which case we would have to assume the the killer went for Smurf but failed as he was (twice) protected. Manly hasn't posted so I'd quite like to know who he tracked last night and what his result was.
For the reason that I don't think AP would have survived this long if he was mafia and because chewie is closer to the hammer than BKB is I'm going to lynch him.

Lynch: Chewie

That's 5 with 7 to hammer.

----------

That's now:

Chewie - 5
MaD - 2

with Spoobir's post.

 

[Spoobir]

This could all have been solved if Mark had just let me kill Chewie last night.

 

[barmyarmy]

Not entirely. If MaD is telling the truth about jailkeeping him then he wouldn't have been targetable anyway.

 

[Spoobir]

Well then if my kill failed I would know MaD was telling the truth and would could be almost certain Chewie was mafia.

 

[Manly]

I was unsuccessful in tracking Chewie last night.