Lord of the Rings Mafia - Town wins

[barmyarmy]

unlynch: bevab
Lynch: maney2k9
Reason: still trying to lynch bevab even when claim (as long as it remains unchallenged) is obviously correct.

 

[Manly]

Claim is correct?

 

[barmyarmy]

Claim of being Frodo. It's def going to be in the game. Unless someone else says that they are Frodo he's clearly town.

 

[Manly]

Fair shout ha.

Got a bit riled at something else so had a momentary lapse of reason (Any Pink Floyd fans out there?)

Unlynch: Bevab - I've been put to rights.

I'm Boromir, by the way.

 

[Spoobir]

Boromir sounds like the perfect Miller to me...

----------

Also just gonna throw this one out there for you mafias.

If Sauron and Saruman are on the mafia team, it's almost guaranteed that Saruman is the Usurper, just something to think about. Obviously I don't want to cause any rifts or tension in the mafia camp...

 

[Aditya]

I'm surprised that some of the people here are still favoring Bevab. Alright, he's a townie, I agree but seriously role claiming so early in the game? Just in my last post I asked him not to role claim so early and provide a reason for lynching MaD on the basis of the previous games but he still role claimed without replying to my post. I guess I'm being a bit too aggressive here towards Bevab but very frankly, I expect something better from him. He has got a important role, fine, but he must know to use it wisely.

 

[AbhishekS]

A lot has happened in the last 48 hours or so. Was a long read.
I find Bevab's claim legit tbh, but I also agree that he shouldn't have claimed so early.

 

[Sachinfan98]

1)This Bevab situation seems to be going almost nowhere. People still lynching him? Roleclaimed although he had a power role(and early too)-Frodo should be that shouldn't he?I dont have much LOTR knowledge.Can someone provide insight on this?
2)Ah,ARay putting some pressure vote on me.ARay,do you need to know something about any person while playing mafia? According to me,nothing except for which side he is on( I may be wrong). But I clearly know that im town(you should know it too).
3)For some reason,my Mark hunch isnt just clicking.I guess I should go on without a lynch until we get a mafia lead.
4)Finally,what are we going to do for this day? We cant just waste it and give the mafia a free kill.We need somebody to lynch.Hopefully we will get the scum we are looking for.
Unlynch:Mark

 

[BKB1991]

That is soooo stupid Bevab... whether it's true or not.

How true.

Anyways, I will lay off him now, Frodo is too good to miss, and knowing the mafia might go for him anyways, we shouldnt.

Boromir sounds like the perfect Miller to me...

----------

Also just gonna throw this one out there for you mafias.

If Sauron and Saruman are on the mafia team, it's almost guaranteed that Saruman is the Usurper, just something to think about. Obviously I don't want to cause any rifts or tension in the mafia camp...

Sounds legit, and seems like pro-town move to boot as well

 

[pcfan123]

claiming Frodo is pretty ballsy, I think he's dead either way, if we lynch him today and he turns out to be Frodo we're in trouble. If we don't lynch him then the mafia will for sure. If we don't lynch him and the mafia don't then he was lying.

I don't think he is mafia and I think his roleclaim might be the truth. AngryPixel is shady though, he jumped on the Bevab bandwagon and jumped off as soon as some pressure fell on him.

unlynch Bevab

lynch AngryPixel

 

[treva]

MaD - 1 (User2010)
Spoobir -1 (Chewie)
Chewie -1 (Culli)
Bevab - 2 (Aditya, Hedger_14)
Varun - 1 (Highlander999)
AngryPixel - 4 (CG123, Bevab, Zohaib, Mark)
BarmyArmy - 1 (BKB1991)
SachinFan98 - 2 (MaD, ARay)
Maney2k9 - 1 (barmyarmy)

With 20 alive it takes 11 for a lynch.

 

[BKB1991]

Well what we should do Is look at the people who have activel pushed for a bevab roleclaim, I mean as mafia they knew a bit of pressure on him and he will fold. Maybe then we have a genuine contender

 

[barmyarmy]

Well what we should do Is look at the people who have activel pushed for a bevab roleclaim, I mean as mafia they knew a bit of pressure on him and he will fold. Maybe then we have a genuine contender

Can you explain that a bit?
If the people pushing were mafia they wouldn't know he was Frodo. As Aditya said we were looking for a defence without going straight to a RC.
People targeted bevab because of his poor gameplay previously. It was just unfortunate he had an important role.
I'll remove my lynch from maney2k9 although I reckon he also claimed way too quickly.

Unlynch: Maney2k9

 

[pcfan123]

Maney claimed? ..gotta go back and read now

----------

Fair shout ha.

Got a bit riled at something else so had a momentary lapse of reason (Any Pink Floyd fans out there?)

Unlynch: Bevab - I've been put to rights.

I'm Boromir, by the way.

lol this is fishy,

I don't see Ben just claiming like that with no pressure. Willing to let it slide for now because there could be some something we are not seeing yet.

 

[barmyarmy]

Also I'd like to hear more from Yudi. Haven't seen much from him so far.

----------

@Mark - I assume he claimed because he saw he'd made a mistake over bevab and was in danger of a quick lynching...