Lord of the Rings Mafia - Town wins

[Chewie]

Nothing wrong with my radar. I didn't say you hadn't posted anything, I said you hadn't posted anything worth reading. Completely different.
Convince me with some more analysis of other players and how you see the game.

----------

Amusingly in pretty much every mafia game I've seen on the site the day 1 lynch has been an inactive player or a townie who hasn't defended themselves properly.
I wonder if people know what to do if all players are active and role claiming to protect themselves...

The Patient 9 mafia was just that sort of game and there was a no lynch on the first day

I'm not suspicious of Bevab for the reasons outlined before - he wouldn't have role claimed as Frodo if he were not him because it would be suicidal for mafia to do so.

 

[Zohaib]

lol, the game changed so drastically in last few hours. Everyone on bevab bandwagon jumped on me just cuz I unlynched him. @colin, different timezones mate, I came home late then watched a few shows which were recorded on my satellite box. Only now I have some time.
I can understand why people have voted for me.

Bevab: cuz I lynched him first. Typical noob play.
Zohaib: he's still carrying the grudge from the last mafia game where he was killed cuz of me.
Mark: well he's mark .
Barmy: He suspected me cuz I was inactive during last few hours. Well, there are a lot of players who haven't voted yet and have posted a lot less. They have evaded your radar so far. Fix it colin.

Lol, I cant remember you killing me last game

I got killed because I was to aggressive

The Patient 9 mafia was just that sort of game and there was a no lynch on the first day

I'm not suspicious of Bevab for the reasons outlined before - he wouldn't have role claimed as Frodo if he were not him because it would be suicidal for mafia to do so.

Yeah but it will suicidal for someone to counter claim Frodo as they dont want to die because they got a power role

 

[Bevab]

Lol, my poor knowledge has really let me down.

 

[Zohaib]

How so?You couldn't role claim someone you're not?

 

[Bevab]

You mean to say that I'm not Frodo?

This automatically puts suspicion on you because most of the members have said that Frodo is an important character, and is a suicide claim for mafia. So why would I risk myself if I was mafia?

 

[Zohaib]

You mean to say that I'm not Frodo?

This automatically puts suspicion on you because most of the members have said that Frodo is an important character, and is a suicide claim for mafia. So why would I risk myself if I was mafia?

Lol, I didnt say I dont believe your role claim

And dont worry about members they can say what they want but if you read your PM correctly then you would see if you are a power role

 

[CG123]

Like I said before his roleclaim I didn't think Bevab would be mafia, and in terms of his roleclaim that seems to be true.

I'm not sure why Ben roleclaimed without much pressure on him, yes by doing so it definitely makes you look town at this early stage, but in some way or another it probably does strengthen the mafia's position a bit, because now they've already got two roleclaims on day one.

Unlynch: AngryPixel

Lynch: Culli

He's been rather quite so far, so this might just help to get him into the discussions.

----------

Are you happy to go with a day one no lynch again Yudi?

 

[hedger_14]

Well I really should read everything, now Ben's roleclaimed as well? Who did he roleclaim and why? I can't be bothered researching the past 6 pages to find out

And Unlynch: Bevab

As much as I would love to lynch him off, I don't think he's mafia due to his roleclaim so I'll unlynch him.

 

[Aditya]

Unlynch : Bevab

Seriously, I'm not happy with him role claiming so early. A better defense was required from him but what he did was, role claimed so early. I'd take note of this because I don't think that he's too bad a player to even not try and defend himself for some time.

For now, I'm really not suspicious of anyone else. I agree with Tom, Bevab and AP will always put themselves under pressure on day 1 as their gameplay isn't as good as others that are playing in this game. So, if there is a bangwagon on AP, I'd lynch him because as I've been saying in previous mafia games as well, I always prefer to lynch noob members rather than experienced players on day 1.

 

[Deleted member 13648]

Lynch: Culli

He's been rather quite so far, so this might just help to get him into the discussions.

That's fair.

Why can't we all just get along?

 

[MaD]

Frodo roleclaim on day!?!?
I do believe he is the main character of LOTR, that's like Harry Potter claiming on day 1...
Well he's got to be townie, unless he's trying to get Frodo to claim, which is doubhtful, because the game just started.

----------

Too much discussion to read, although I don't think we got any where since we're still talking about Bevab

 

[Aditya]

That last part of your post does make sense but if a experienced member has the role of Frodo he would know that Bevab is making him counter claim him. Maybe, that member can throw out some hints for us.

 

[CG123]

Well I really should read everything, now Ben's roleclaimed as well? Who did he roleclaim and why? I can't be bothered researching the past 6 pages to find out

barmyarmy lynched Ben, because Ben lynched Bevab, after Bevab had roleclaimed.

Ben then roleclaimed straight away, even though he only had one lynch on him.

This is what Ben said in response to Mark:

Maney claimed? ..gotta go back and read now

----------



lol this is fishy,

I don't see Ben just claiming like that with no pressure. Willing to let it slide for now because there could be some something we are not seeing yet.

^ That's exactly what it is haha. I've been lynched/night-killed early doors every game I've played, so I'm trying to avoid it again.

----------

That said, I can't remember ever being lynched, just picked off Night 1 or 2..

----------

That's fair.

Why can't we all just get along?

Care to enlighten us on your thoughts regarding the game so far?

 

[P Squared]

MaD - 1 (User2010)
Spoobir -1 (Chewie)
Chewie -1 (Culli)
AngryPixel - 4 (Bevab, Zohaib, Mark, BarmyArmy)
BarmyArmy - 2 (BKB1991, Highlander999)
SachinFan98 - 2 (MaD, ARay)
Culli - 1 (CG123)

With 20 alive it takes 11 for a lynch.

 

[Gaurav_7]

We're going no where. Same case with all day 1 phases of mafia games. I think we should go for the most inactive member of all. More dangerous than anyone at this stage.

Unlynch : MaD
Lynch : SachinFan98

And, if Frodo claim is sooo important then we're on the back foot already...