Lord of the Rings Mafia - Town wins

[Manly]

^ That's exactly what it is haha. I've been lynched/night-killed early doors every game I've played, so I'm trying to avoid it again.

----------

That said, I can't remember ever being lynched, just picked off Night 1 or 2..

 

[barmyarmy]

The thing about bandwagons is that unless you use them you can't put pressure on and day 1 gets wasted

Lynch: AngryPixel
Reason: Hasn't really added anything to the discussion.

 

[pcfan123]

Reason: Hasn't really added anything to the discussion.

are we talking about this game or the forum in general?

 

[barmyarmy]

If we were looking forum-wide you'd have probably been mod-killed by now

 

[pcfan123]

ooooh snap

Colin when are you going to lemme have a peek at the mod forums

 

[barmyarmy]

When the large cheque I requested arrives.

 

[AngryPixel]

lol, the game changed so drastically in last few hours. Everyone on bevab bandwagon jumped on me just cuz I unlynched him. @colin, different timezones mate, I came home late then watched a few shows which were recorded on my satellite box. Only now I have some time.
I can understand why people have voted for me.

Bevab: cuz I lynched him first. Typical noob play.
Zohaib: he's still carrying the grudge from the last mafia game where he was killed cuz of me.
Mark: well he's mark .
Barmy: He suspected me cuz I was inactive during last few hours. Well, there are a lot of players who haven't voted yet and have posted a lot less. They have evaded your radar so far. Fix it colin.

 

[barmyarmy]

Nothing wrong with my radar. I didn't say you hadn't posted anything, I said you hadn't posted anything worth reading. Completely different.
Convince me with some more analysis of other players and how you see the game.

----------

Amusingly in pretty much every mafia game I've seen on the site the day 1 lynch has been an inactive player or a townie who hasn't defended themselves properly.
I wonder if people know what to do if all players are active and role claiming to protect themselves...

 

[AngryPixel]

I think ARay could be mafia. He jumped on the bandwagon late without any significant reason. That doesn't mean bevab is not a mafia. However unlikely it may seem, this could be a brilliant play by bevab.
Think it this way. Bevab comes under FOS. Some townies happen to vote against him and the mafia also vote against him. Then he roleclaims as frodo which is pretty easy guess in a LOTR game. A townie with a power role would never do this. Now the mafia who voted against bevab quickly change their vote posing as good townies and vote for a townie. Now their vote would appear legit and other townies would be fooled. They would follow them.
So we are looking for the people who changed their votes to lynch bevab after the first 2 votes against him and then unlynched right after the roleclaim.

 

[barmyarmy]

Your logic is flawed here:

Then he roleclaims as frodo which is pretty easy guess in a LOTR game. A townie with a power role would never do this

It's an easy guess that Frodo would be in the game but a suicidal claim for a mafia (and as others have observed probably a suicidal one for bevab too).
My lynch stays.

 

[Highlander999]

Colin when are you going to lemme have a peek at the mod forums

It really ain't cracked up to what ya think. Pics of Matt with strippers really is stuff you don't want to see...!!!

Right I'm gonna rock the boat here and gonna say I'm suspicious of Colin. A) As much as I hate to admit it, he is a smart(ish ) guy and by basically playing a very active and directing presence the one person who no one is even looking at is Colin himself. B) I can't remember what previous mafia game it was when a mafia member did this, but it takes the heat off them and it allowed the mafia to get into a winning position. C) I'm always going to suspect Colin mainly because if he was mafia he would be the hardest person to pick up on as he is too clever for his own good.

Players like Bevab and AP are always going to attract early attention because they suck at these games (no offence ) I reckon if Colin, was a power town role he wouldn't be this loud and trying to direct the game as eventually he would draw attention to himself, which therefore leads me to come to the conclusion that he is either a vanilla townie or anti-town. That is why I think he should be lynched he is his own worse enemy because I feel he is too dangerous to be around unless we know 100% he is town.

Unlynch: Varun
Lynch: barmyarmy

 

[barmyarmy]

I think there was a compliment hidden in there somewhere. I'm not directing the game - I'm just more active than most people.

 

[Highlander999]

Oh it is a compliment to you, don't get me wrong, I just know you better then most the guys here and know how capable you are of totally confusing everyone if you wanted to (myself included!) which is why I think you are just too dangerous to have around

 

[pcfan123]

also remember he has access to our PMs

 

[Highlander999]

Nah, it takes an absolute age for an admin to access PM's and apparently they appear on a tiny screen so are hard to read (I can reveal all secrets! )