Lord of the Rings Mafia - Town wins

[barmyarmy]

Most inactive on actual post count is Yudi not sachinfan.

 

[Deleted member 13648]

Care to enlighten us on your thoughts regarding the game so far?

Most are getting a little tetchy and letting themselves be dictated by the more experienced players; personally, I feel as though Tom used Colin's overpowering presence thus far in the game to his own advantage as it propelled his own lack of involvement right up there to be level with Colin's.

You, Tom & Colin are taking control early; that's for sure.

--------------------------------------------------------

Bevab is certainly a townie with that role-claim though, it hasn't been revoked by any player so I'm positive of his status. Ben did jump to lynch him incredibly quickly which leads me to suspect him slightly, though I'm standing by my lynch I made before.

 

[CG123]

You, Tom & Colin are taking control early; that's for sure.

I haven't really thought I've had any control so far, I'm not really sure what you mean by that.

Yes I've been active, but that's because I'm trying to generate discussion in order to try to catch newish mafia players out early on which has happened in the past.

Not always, but quite often the town's acitvity does determine how well they go.

 

[Deleted member 13648]

You took a great deal of control by asking me a question; whether people want to see that as 'starting/stirring' discussion is up to them. I'm reading you as legit though.

 

[Spoobir]

FOS: User2010, MaD, ARay

Pushing to lynch a less active/new player is a classic day 1 mafia move...

 

[hedger_14]

That last part of your post does make sense but if a experienced member has the role of Frodo he would know that Bevab is making him counter claim him. Maybe, that member can throw out some hints for us.

Well hopefully if that is somebody, then they won't be stupid enough to openly reveal that. Just do sort of what I did in WWE mafia when Vedarshi (I think) claimed Stone Cold

And yeah, may as well lynch the most inactive player as he's not going to be any help anyway.

Lynch: SachinFan98

 

[Gaurav_7]

I'm not doing that. It's just he hasn't really been posting much. I know this is a ridiculous reason to lynch someone but, there is hardly anything substantial happening here.

----------

My post was in response to Spoobir.

 

[MaD]

I wouldn't say pushing, just pressuring, we need to get somewhere.

Looks like a no lynch atm, with all the lynches spread out

 

[hedger_14]

Pushing to lynch a less active/new player is a classic day 1 mafia move...

I would say more a classic day 1 move, not really a day 1 mafia move inparticular.

 

[CG123]

You took a great deal of control by asking me a question; whether people want to see that as 'starting/stirring' discussion is up to them. I'm reading you as legit though.

Asking someone a question isn't really control, I just asked you your thoughts because you had been rather quiet at that stage.

Yes I understand that it's up to people whether they want to participate in the thread, but I'm trying to get more people involved to get more clues. Sorry Riz if you're reading this, but I have to use you as an example (), he really did absolutely nothing in terms of discussion in one game and turned out mafia later on. Since we haven't played together, I might as well tell you that I'm not massive fan when people play that way.

----------

SachinFan98's played similar to Bevab, again I'm not really sure if he's mafia. I might as well leave him atm considering he's already got a few lynches on him.

 

[Deleted member 13648]

I appreciate that, I've just been busy in the real world the last few days. I'll be much more active from here on in.

 

[CG123]

All good. I might as well unlynch you now since it served it's purpose.

Unlynch: Culli

 

[Deleted member 13648]

Excellent news. I shall rest easy tonight.

 

[AngryPixel]

Lynch: SachinFan98

FOS: Bevab(I dont think he's that stupid to roleclaim as Frodo,so early in the game.)
Colin: Taking control of the game early on and diverting the spotlight on others. Nice

 

[BKB1991]

Can you explain that a bit?
If the people pushing were mafia they wouldn't know he was Frodo. As Aditya said we were looking for a defence without going straight to a RC.
People targeted bevab because of his poor gameplay previously. It was just unfortunate he had an important role.
I'll remove my lynch from maney2k9 although I reckon he also claimed way too quickly.

Unlynch: Maney2k9

Meaning if I was mafia, I knew if I wanted to lynch anyone, then going for Bevab would be easy, put some pressure on him, and a roleclaim should come and people just need an excuse to lynch him off.

I was thinking maybe if Bevab was mafia, the mafia might have intentionally let him claim Frodo, so the REAL one could counterclaim, and they would find his identity. But no one has really counterclaimed, so I guess hes safe for now.

No clue on whom to lynch this is really too wide, I think if we dont get any majority we should go for the least helpful/inactive person.