Lord of the Rings Mafia - Town wins

[ARay]

2)Ah,ARay putting some pressure vote on me.ARay,do you need to know something about any person while playing mafia? According to me,nothing except for which side he is on( I may be wrong). But I clearly know that im town(you should know it too).

Well I based my lynch on the fact that I have never played with you or seen you around the forums. So my lynch was made to stimulate discussion from your end.

FOS: User2010, MaD, ARay

Pushing to lynch a less active/new player is a classic day 1 mafia move...

Flawed logic there! An inactive member is a useless townie and makes no contribution to the game. They only cause confusion about the rest of the members. I have also always advocated the lynching of members who are not active because honestly I feel like the confuse my judgement.

Lynch: SachinFan98

FOS: Bevab(I dont think he's that stupid to roleclaim as Frodo,so early in the game.)
Colin: Taking control of the game early on and diverting the spotlight on others. Nice

The reason why I lynched you is because of this post. I feel like this is a perfect example of bandwagoning. You decide to lynch Sachin, you give no reason (but according to your post your suspicion lies on Bevab and colin). So why lynch Sachin then? I feel like its more of an attempt to get a majority lynch and end the day.
You did first with Bevab and then followed it up with Sachin.

 

[barmyarmy]

I can't work out why AP is still suspicious of Bevab. Mafia or just horrible play?

----------

As far as I can see we can either lynch Yudi for being totally inactive or AngryPixel for being n00bish/scummy.

Would like to read something more definite from Varun and Spoobir too. No lynches at all from either so far.

 

[AngryPixel]

I don't know why anyone isn't suspicious of Colin yet? Trying to dictate the votes. Hmm. You sound scummy now

 

[barmyarmy]

People are suspicious of me - doesn't really bother me. I'll claim if I have to.
You still haven't explained why you are trying to lynch a townie (bevab).

 

[BKB1991]

I dont see why people are lynching Sachin when he has made some posts and has shown some form of activity

We need to try get the players who havent posted yet, we need to get them under pressure

Well they are trying to put pressure on sachin to see how he responds. This is quite common mafia routine

And I don't see why you are so desperately defending him. Unless you are a mafia and trying to help him out. You said that others should look out for more inactive members and leave Sachin alone as he has been active. Well then you should reconsider your lynch too.

Seems rather aggressive AP. I am not getting good vibes from you. Needless to say I am going to keep my eye on you

----------

I don't know why anyone isn't suspicious of Colin yet? Trying to dictate the votes. Hmm. You sound scummy now

This isnt helping, you seem like a cornered mafia trying to rattle anyone who points fingers at you.

tbf I am not a fan of Colins gameplay, but its does generate activity and I think hes atleast contributing to discussions by raising fair points, plus I dont know enough of him to consider his moves mafia-type, but I dont think I am going to lynch him.

Unless I get some solid stuff on anyone, I am going to go forward and lynch AP.

For the time being

Unlynch: BarmyArmy (I Think)
Lynch: AngryPixel

 

[AngryPixel]

@colin, I'm not lynching bevab, I've unlynched him couple of pages back. I just suspected him. Right now you are under my FOS and yudi is as well. He has posted absolutely nothing. Staying under the radar. Classic mafia technique.

 

[pcfan123]

that was Colin's reasoning for Yudi, you're just parroting it.

I'm on whichever bandwagon gets going, I started the Bevab one but that turned out horribly for the town. Am on the sachin one now cause it's the biggest but I could switch to a Pixel one if it's quick.

 

[barmyarmy]

Ok, why are you suspicious of bevab? Can you outline a scenario where his Frodo claim might be false?

----------

^ That question is aimed at AP. Mark's post just got in the way...

 

[ARay]

@colin, I'm not lynching bevab, I've unlynched him couple of pages back. I just suspected him. Right now you are under my FOS and yudi is as well. He has posted absolutely nothing. Staying under the radar. Classic mafia technique.

This is what I find highly amusing that you find Colin most suspicious and yet choose to lynch Sachin over some ambiguous reason. My lynch will stay on you until I find some reason otherwise.

 

[CG123]

Where's Yudi at?

I still want to no where he stands atm, in terms of his normal day one no lynch position?

Might as well lynch him because he's only got one lynch on him so far, and that might get him to post.

Lynch: Yudi

Also FOS: AP. The only explanation for his suspicion on Bevab could be that he's Frodo. Other than that he's only hurting yourself by saying that he's suspicious of someone who's claimed as one of the main "good" guys.

----------

Tbh I haven't minded Colin's gameplay so far, he's definitely stirring the pot which is what you want early on.

 

[P Squared]

Spoobir - 1 (Chewie)
Chewie - 1 (Culli)
AngryPixel - 5 (ARay, Bevab, Zohaib, BarmyArmy, BKB1991)
BarmyArmy - 1 (Highlander999)
SachinFan98 - 4 (User2010, Hedger14, AngryPixel, Mark)
Yudi - 2 (MaD, CG123)

With 20 alive it takes 11 for a lynch.

 

[AngryPixel]

Okay here is my explanations for FOS

Bevab: Well, even though he has roleclaimed, i have a gut feeling about him. I'm not getting a good vibe. Thats about it. You can't do anything about that can you. Still i unlynched him coz i needed some additional proof. I wont lynch him but keep an eye on him.

I've lyched SachinFan to get some reaction from him and he hasn't explained his case very well either. Yet I'll unlynch him coz Yudi has done absolutely nothing and i dont want him to get through the day 1 like this without any discussion. Thus

Unlynch: SachinFAn
Lynch: Yudi

 

[pcfan123]

I think you just thought you'd kill two birds with one stone, have frodo done with by the town so you can kill someone else at night and have 2 done quickly.

 

[AngryPixel]

I'm on whichever bandwagon gets going, I started the Bevab one but that turned out horribly for the town. Am on the sachin one now cause it's the biggest but I could switch to a Pixel one if it's quick.

Isnt that what mafia usually do. Jump on the whichever bandwagon is going on as long as it is not a mafia.
FOS: Mark, His sole reason for lynching Bevab and now me is that he will join the herd.

----------

I think you just thought you'd kill two birds with one stone, have frodo done with by the town so you can kill someone else at night and have 2 done quickly.

At least i gave some sort of explanation when i lynched him. Whereas you just lynched him for kicks. That sound hell a lot like Mafia than me.

 

[pcfan123]

Mafia does not lynch for kicks, they don't really care about lynching, they kill at night. The people staying quiet or overreacting are most likely to be mafia, rather than overly active directors like Colin. I think he's probably a vanilla townie or the gutsiest mafia ever.

as for you, I think your overreacting is shady,