Lord of the Rings Mafia - Town wins

[barmyarmy]

Trust me, its worth it. It'll most likely help you later.

Almost impossible to keep you alive for long. Doc can only protect you every other night. Whatever your role is hopefully you can get some use out of of before the mafia kill you.

----------

Mafia do care about lynching Mark.

We all care about lynching Mark

 

[AngryPixel]

What would happen if doc protects a mafia during night? Would there be any clue in the writeup for that night?

 

[P Squared]

Still the count is wrong. It should be 5

Right again

 

[Aditya]

the doctor will protect Frodo for sure which means the mafia will probably target someone else, the only other townie to claim is maney.

How you know that Maney is a townie? Actually, I've played one more mafia game with him and he looks to be a very good player and him role claiming so early in the game seems a little awkward to me. In Bevab's case it was fine, his gameplay isn't the best and he's still learning but Maney is a really good player and if I recall rightly, he hasn't told the reason of him role claiming so early. So,

FOS : Maney

Yudi, has been very inactive and if he doesn't post anything useful in the next few hours then I will lynch him, for the simple fact that I prefer to lynch noob players or inactive players on day 1 rather than experienced players.

 

[barmyarmy]

Right again

Prob easier to just do an updated one as it's actually 6 now...

----------

@Aditya - regarding Maney2k9 I'm willing to accept that he didn't really read it properly and was trying to post at work while distracted. Claiming Boromir would be very risky for a mafia with only one lynch on them as he is likely (although not certain) to be in the game.

----------

I see from the last game that AP played that he was modkilled and this is only his second game. That makes me a bit less suspicious about his play as he is probably just inexperienced. With 6 lynches on him I'd like to hear a better defence from him though. Defence meaning why we shouldn't lynch him rather than why we should lynch anyone else...

----------

Well I'm just lost in this game. Haven't had much time to catch up with the discussions going on here. Will have to read a hell lot of pages.

You will. You're currently the "inactive" lynch

----------

And just to stir the pot some more...

FOS: Chewie
Reason: has contributed almost nothing to the game so far.

 

[P Squared]

Spoobir - 1 (Chewie)
Chewie - 1 (Culli)
AngryPixel - 6 (User2010, ARay, Bevab, Zohaib, BarmyArmy, BKB1991)
BarmyArmy - 1 (Highlander999)
SachinFan98 - 2 (Hedger14, Mark)
Yudi - 3 (MaD, CG123, AngryPixel)

With 20 alive it takes 11 for a lynch.

 

[MaD]

Not many have contributed much really, and Bevab, you can stop mentioning your importance and try to do as much as you can before you're killed.

 

[Aditya]

@Aditya - regarding Maney2k9 I'm willing to accept that he didn't really read it properly and was trying to post at work while distracted. Claiming Boromir would be very risky for a mafia with only one lynch on them as he is likely (although not certain) to be in the game.

I understand the point that he was at work and posted that post while distracted but we cannot give away our roles so easily. As you said, he just had one lynch on him at that time so there was no question whether he was under pressure or not so even if he had not posted anything, it would have been understandable as he was busy at work. Another possibility is that, he is mafia and trying to confuse the townies very early in the game.

 

[Varun]

Trust me, its worth it. It'll most likely help you later.

Do you think you need to explicitly state it? Isn't it implied that the doc will protect you?

Really, he still makes me suspicious of him even though as you all say, he's claimed one of the main characters in the game.

Also, I'm not suspicious of AP, his play appears to me more like newbie play than mafia play.

Lynch : Culli

Post substantially please?

 

[BKB1991]

Bevab, please be quiet. And if you have any role then it might be a good idea to use it very soon, we wont be able to say you till the end of the game.

Good point Colin, havent seen Chewie in a while.

I do agree AP is digging a hole for himself, and unless we have any better candidates (an inactive member, or a real sus) then I am going to lynch AP. Right now looking to read more analysis from Chewie and Yudi.

 

[treva]

No editing posts, that is a clear rule. Just make another post with what you wanted to add.

I feel the Day should get a hurry up, as it's going in circles with people just voting for those who haven't posted 'substantially' yet. I'm going to give the day until the end of Sunday (tomorrow).

Day 1 ends at Midnight Sunday, BST.

 

[barmyarmy]

Do you think you need to explicitly state it? Isn't it implied that the doc will protect you?

I've had a think about this and I reckon that explicitly stating it can only help the mafia as they will know which role they've got rid of and which are left after they've killed him.

----------

Meant to mention that logic for this is that roles aren't being revealed upon death.

 

[CG123]

Well I'm just lost in this game. Haven't had much time to catch up with the discussions going on here. Will have to read a hell lot of pages.

Come on, you finally come on and this is what you post. My lynch stays on you for obvious reasons.

FOS: Chewie. Like Colin said he's been rather inactive, the second most inactive player so far, only ahead of Yudi.

 

[Manly]

I understand the point that he was at work and posted that post while distracted but we cannot give away our roles so easily. As you said, he just had one lynch on him at that time so there was no question whether he was under pressure or not so even if he had not posted anything, it would have been understandable as he was busy at work. Another possibility is that, he is mafia and trying to confuse the townies very early in the game.

I totally hear what you're saying, and in retrospect I would've stayed quiet until my shift finished. As I said, every game I've played I've been picked off Night 1 or 2, so I'm keen to get as involved as I can whilst I'm still around.

Just had a read of the last 3 or so pages, and I agree with what Varun's said, I'd like to see a bit more from Culli, but we'll have to see if he complies.

Spoobir post #215 - He says about 'causing some tension in the Mafia camp' by saying Saruman is a Usurper, which is a long shot. If he is a Usurper, as I'm sure we'll find out later, either it's a hell of a guess, or he's in the Mafia, and trying to bluff/double bluff (I'm unsure what a double bluff is, so I'll throw it in there) us, which would be very ballsy indeed. FoS on him.

AngryPixel hasn't been playing a good game so far, and he is under my FoS as well for the reasons the likes of Colin (for example) has said: he's being overly aggressive, and there's a lot of deflection on his part, and I cite post #288 for that.

 

[Sachinfan98]

Who are we going to lynch?
Chewie has been inactive,Culli too.
We should go for either one of them.I think Chewie is playing under the radar.Culli also seems inexperienced like me.

----------

Currently Active Users Viewing This Thread: 5 (1 members and 4 guests)
Some one think it is Chewie?