Lord of the Rings Mafia - Town wins

[Sachinfan98]

Wth we are giving the mafia a free kill?
Im suspicious of those that started the no lynch thing.
FOS-Maney and Mark
Maney defending Mark.Typical scum technique.
Lynch:Mark
Im going for Mark right now because he seems the most scummy.

 

[CG123]

Mark just seems to be doing with what the majority of people do. He's not really contributing anything, but at the same time he's not really giving off any mafia vibes.

 

[AngryPixel]

Lets hope cops can get two investigations right during night1 and Doc protect the townies. That way we can hit the mafia hard on Day 2

 

[hedger_14]

Ok, well I'm guessing a bit of suspicion is on me cause I've been quiet and lynched SachinFan98.

Anyway, as nearly everyone should know, I hate first days of mafia and I'm normally this quiet on the first day as I try and sit back and read into everyone a little. I'm also very sick so I've been tired reading through all these pages so I can't say I'll be a huge help.

Normally I end up lynching an inactive member (he was before I posted my lynch) and wait for a defence from them. As nobody really backed me up in that so I didn't really feel much point in unlynching as I didn't really have any other options, and I felt AngryPixel was town, although mainly from last game which he put the pressure on himself much like he has. He just feels town to me and his roleclaim sounds legit atm.

Chewie was one that looked suspicious as he was very quiet until a bit of suspicion was put on him but I'm feeling that he's more likely townie. So mafia? Well I'm not sure. First day's are always the hardest to decipher. Well it looks like it's going to be a no lynch. I can't say I agree but there's real no options now. I would have liked to lynch someone on day 1 but oh well. It does give help, especially later in the game and especially if it's a mafia lynch.

Unlynch: Sachinfan98

No Lynch

 

[AbhishekS]

The day is going nowhere. And people seem to be going for a no lynch. I have always preferred a no lynch on day 1 but for some unknown reasons I don't think that it's the best of ideas in this game with so many people.

And from the list CG123 has provided, barmyarmy, ARay and Mark are the guys who were common in lynching Bevab and AngryPixel.
If the way Mark is playing the game is his usual manner of playing, then the only guy who seems scummy is barmyarmy. Not scummy tbh but at times he has been acting as if he is the boss and has tried to influence the players heavily.

FOS: Mark, barmyarmy
Lynch: barmyarmy (lynching him won't cause any difference anyway as we are probably heading towards a no lynch)

 

[BKB1991]

Why are we heading towards a no-lynch? Seriously this is just not helping the towns cause.

We lynch a townie, we know atleast one mafia played a part in lynching him. We see people who genuinely defended him, the ones who wanted to write him of ASAP.

I am prepared to lynch Mark or AP, whichever the majoritys reaching. At Day 2 this will help us decipher some townies and mafia. We cannot go for a no lynch guys.

 

[ARay]

Okay so here is the main issue that I have with everyone wanting a lynch.
Our candidates are Frodo and Sam. Are we honestly going to lynch them? That is a huge risk that is being undertaken unnecessarily.
I am all up for a lynch, but lynching known characters is pretty bad.

----------

On another note where is User2010 and Zohaib? I have hardly seen them post anything at all. Infact Chewie and Hedger are really quiet as well.

 

[BKB1991]

Lol thats actually weird, the two roleclaims we know are Frodo and Sam

Point I am trying to make is we need to take a chance, because looking at the odds we will still be in a similar situation tomorrow. Seems like I am outnumbered here but if everyones going for a no lynch, then I cant change it on my own.

no lynch

 

[Chewie]

For the most part, I am quiet because there's isn't much to add. People are just going round in circles, and we're not going anywhere.

 

[Gaurav_7]

I don't know but, I'm not convinced the way AP has played this. He's claimed Sam? By seeing people react, I think he's another important character of the series.

But, guys seeing as Bevab already claimed so quickly, what if AP (supposedly a mafia) claimed Sam just to get away and be town trust sort of thing later. I mean he knows town won't risk it if he's an important character? I'm not actually too blown away with that claim. I think this is some sort of a plan. My lynch on AP stays.

 

[Bevab]

Why is Barmy playing funnily? Something is wrong.

Unlynch:Angrypixel

I hate no lynches on Day 1. I would rather prefer test ARay.

Lynch:ARay

 

[Gaurav_7]

Lets hope cops can get two investigations right during night1 and Doc protect the townies. That way we can hit the mafia hard on Day 2

Indirectly you want cops (if there are more than 1) to reveal themselves and the doc to protect you (since you claimed one of the 'townies'). Nice theory.

 

[BKB1991]

I don't know but, I'm not convinced the way AP has played this. He's claimed Sam? By seeing people react, I think he's another important character of the series.

But, guys seeing as Bevab already claimed so quickly, what if AP (supposedly a mafia) claimed Sam just to get away and be town trust sort of thing later. I mean he knows town won't risk it if he's an important character? I'm not actually too blown away with that claim. I think this is some sort of a plan. My lynch on AP stays.

Hmm, how convinced are you that hes guilty?

 

[hedger_14]

Infact Chewie and Hedger are really quiet as well.

Already pointed out

 

[Zohaib]

Like what Chewie said, there isn't much to post on

My lynch with AP stands, he playing is not that of a townie, it really has change from the last game from which he was a townie

Being way more aggressive which is a type of mafia play