Lord of the Rings Mafia - Town wins

[Sachinfan98]

Culli what is that post? ^^
---
Night write up has been mostly decoded, I haven't got much to add. Only a few points though.
---
So, I'm assuming it to be that User 2010 got a one shot healing role. He then healed barmy, who, according to others, is the person in the write-up. I have got another theory on this.
---
But
The phrase 'a victim of his own arts' makes me suspicious of barmyarmy. Didn't someone give a theory that barmy might have poisoned himself? Barmy, then vigorously gave hints that he was poisoned to make sure that he would get healed. I don't know why the doc healed him. Anyways, at least we have got some sort of a lead. User2010 was very quick to appear innocent by claiming to have healed barmy.
My theory might also be wrong.
---
And, I am suspicious of barmy because he didn't also help in decoding the previous night write-up. I think Yudi knew something about barmy, that is why he was pressing for his lynch.
---
People might rubbish my theory and become suspicious of me to attack their 'proven town'. I'm fine with the theory, but I can assure you guys that I am not against the town in any manner.
---
Barmy has posted a lot,though but it could be another tactic to make it look like he is town-aligned. This is just a total WIFOM situation.
---
Also, the mafia must have missed the kill. The 'Frodo used his power to hide' theory seems to be OK with me. Just one query, what do you guys think? Does Frodo have a one shot self-protect ability or a multiple time one?
---
Oh and BTW, LOL Varun!

----------

I suspect a mafia team on
->MaD :- already proven
->barmyarmy :- I've given my reasoning based on him.
->User2010 :- He has claimed Samwise, but was quick to add that he healed barmyarmy. I'd say a 50% chance on him being mafia.
There should be around a couple more people. I'd say (a blind call) hedger_14, Chewie, Culli or maybe Spoobir - Could there be Zohaib??

----------

Somebody needs to change the thread title to Day 3.
---
Highlander also is playing under the radar.

----------

Sorry for the long read guys.

 

[Manly]

@751 (the end bit): I'd suggest User2010 isn't mafia, because he, like the rest of us, was convinced that Colon was a poisoned townie. From the write-up it now seems more than likely that he is mafia poisoned by mafia to divert attention away. Certainly my first choice now.

Lynch: barmyarmy

 

[Varun]

Oh and BTW, LOL Varun!

What? That pressure lynch?

And now it appears like Culli is trolling, so my vote on him stays.

 

[barmyarmy]

The writeup is definitely confusing me. "A victim of his own arts" is wierd.
Will address a few points:

Night write up has been mostly decoded, I haven't got much to add. Only a few points though.
---
So, I'm assuming it to be that User 2010 got a one shot healing role. He then healed barmy, who, according to others, is the person in the write-up. I have got another theory on this.

The PM said that I wasn't able to say directly that I'd been poisoned or to ask the doctor for help. A big thanks to user2010 for saving me.
I had thought that being poisoned by the mafia would put me above suspicion but unfortunately there are some probable mafias sowing doubt.

The phrase 'a victim of his own arts' makes me suspicious of barmyarmy. Didn't someone give a theory that barmy might have poisoned himself? Barmy, then vigorously gave hints that he was poisoned to make sure that he would get healed. I don't know why the doc healed him. Anyways, at least we have got some sort of a lead. User2010 was very quick to appear innocent by claiming to have healed barmy.
My theory might also be wrong.

It would be extremely high risk to poison yourself when you're not sure if the doc is alive or not going to be roleblocked. In previous games the poisoner has often been a one shot role so it would also be a total waste.

And, I am suspicious of barmy because he didn't also help in decoding the previous night write-up. I think Yudi knew something about barmy, that is why he was pressing for his lynch.

What are you talking about? I did decode the previous night write-up here. As Yudi himself admitted he hadn't been following the game and didn't really know what was going on so I don't see that he had any special information.

->MaD :- already proven
->barmyarmy :- I've given my reasoning based on him.
->User2010 :- He has claimed Samwise, but was quick to add that he healed barmyarmy. I'd say a 50% chance on him being mafia.
There should be around a couple more people. I'd say (a blind call) hedger_14, Chewie, Culli or maybe Spoobir - Could there be Zohaib??

This just makes you look suspicious as you've named someone we all know mafia and two people who have the strongest claims of anyone (bevab aside) to being town.


I can't really address the write-up seeing as I don't understand it but I'll be looking carefully at all those who are suddenly very keen to lynch me.

----------

The fat little person went about searching for the wise old man who had not been seen much during the day. The reason put out was weakness. As he entered the man's room, he saw him on his last breath, a victim of his own arts. The fat person quickly gave him the antidote and saved him from his death.

Let's measure this against what happened. In LOTR-world I may not have been seen much but in the thread I was (too much according to some). I can't see Saruman being referred to as a wise old man though.

 

[Gaurav_7]

The phrase 'a victim of his own arts' makes me suspicious of barmyarmy. Didn't someone give a theory that barmy might have poisoned himself? Barmy, then vigorously gave hints that he was poisoned to make sure that he would get healed. I don't know why the doc healed him. Anyways, at least we have got some sort of a lead. User2010 was very quick to appear innocent by claiming to have healed barmy.

Did you read what I said? Normally, the doc doesn't heal anyone. There's most probably a healer. A completely different role. I got that, used it and now am vanilla again.

Also, I'm suspicious of Colin. Yes, he might have pulled an excellent thing but, maybe it didn't come off. But, his quick suspicion of MaD and that Trev's post make me think otherwise. I'm confused.

I'm keeping my lynch on Culli. Not helping at all.

 

[barmyarmy]

Sounds kinky!

Great stuff, we needed a kill-less night after you guys lynched a townie yesterday...

Freudian slip? By "you guys" you mean the town rather than the mafia.

----------

Just to straighten the record before everyone accuses me and user2010 of disseminating false information it wasn't me who was had a quick suspicion of MaD. It must have been someone else.

----------

A victim on his own arts. Perhaps it is someone the old man created or something? Was this Saruman created by Gandalf

This sounds like a dead-end. Saruman and Gandalf are members of the same order but Saruman is head of it Gandalf definitely didn't create him.

 

[Gaurav_7]

Just to straighten the record before everyone accuses me and user2010 of disseminating false information it wasn't me who was had a quick suspicion of MaD. It must have been someone else.

Umm weren't you the one to point out 'you should all too' post by MaD? After I claimed Sam and lynched AP? Or was it someone else?

 

[barmyarmy]

Oh yeah, that was me.
Sorry

 

[Gaurav_7]

It would be extremely high risk to poison yourself when you're not sure if the doc is alive or not going to be roleblocked. In previous games the poisoner has often been a one shot role so it would also be a total waste.

I agree with this. But, how can you be so sure about the doc 'healing' someone? I mean I just got a one shot heal, that's it. I'm vanilla again. I think this game too poisoner was a one shot thing as I got the power and no one else is poisoned this night.

 

[barmyarmy]

The write-up is really not helping here so all I can ask people to do is to think logically whether I would really poison myself if I was Saruman. I draw attention to myself and the write-up gives it away anyway. Not smart.
I don't blame anyone for being suspicious so all I can ask you to do it look beyond the write-up as it's very confusing.

----------

I agree with this. But, how can you be so sure about the doc 'healing' someone? I mean I just got a one shot heal, that's it. I'm vanilla again. I think this game too poisoner was a one shot thing as I got the power and no one else is poisoned this night.

Which I guess either clears both of us or labels both of us mafia

 

[Gaurav_7]

Colin, you have any idea of the first para? The stealing thing.

 

[barmyarmy]

Refers to the hobbit who was roleblocked on night 1 - the thief.
Sounds like mafia found him and silenced him or something. We'll maybe be able to tell once everyone has posted.

----------

I don't think sachinfan98 is mafia - I think he's just reading too much into the write-up. My FOS is on spoobir.

 

[Gaurav_7]

Also, the mafia must have missed the kill. The 'Frodo used his power to hide' theory seems to be OK with me. Just one query, what do you guys think? Does Frodo have a one shot self-protect ability or a multiple time one?

I don't really know but, I'm confused here too. Frodo protected himself it seems then. I mean 'vanished' would only mean that. Or, could also be that he hid behind someone? If he had that sort of a role... And, luckily and co-incidentally, that person was protected?

Which I guess either clears both of us or labels both of us mafia

Actually, as you said it would be very very risky, especially not knowing who is killed and who isn't. I doubt anyone would do that. So, I guess, for me, you're clear as of now. Also, I also feel 'wise old man' is a bit too much respect for a bad character. Also, is Saruman the highest evil thing? I mean 'Dark Lord' that is mentioned in 3rd para.

 

[barmyarmy]

I'm guessing Frodo is immune to at least one nightkill. Hopefully more than one...

 

[Manly]

Unlynch: barmyarmy

I need to stop being so hot on the draw.

Still FoS, though. Seems like plausible reasoning, but there is no smoke without fire, as the saying goes.