Lord of the Rings Mafia - Town wins

[Varun]

Colin did you know you were poisoned? Kind of a stupid question but just clearing it out.

No, this is weird question. Very weird question.

http://www.planetcricket.org/forums/2185139-post711.html

Treva said he was going to change it, doesn't that mean there was going to be more poisonings? And if BKB is indirectly suggesting us he is? I have no idea, just a speculation.

We're lost, I've got no idea about SachinFan actually. I actually want him to role claim for the simple fact that when some experienced members have already role claimed I don't think it will be a bad idea to tell SachinFan to role claim as well. I'm still suspicious of him, he has really not provided good enough reasons to lynch/unlynch anyone. It's his first game, he has to learn a lot from this game. It would be easier for him and for us as well if he role claims so that we can move forward as he's the only one left who is not much experienced in mafia games.

Not good reasoning, Aditya.

@6ry4nj - Night 0 writeups don't have hints, only an introduction to the game. Sort of building up the writeups.

And sigh, I believe Tom. For some gut feeling, he doesn't seem mafia to me. Instead, it rather appears Maney and Spoobir are trying to trick us. Gimli, whoever he is, might be in the game, but isn't it possible that if Maney was cult, he could've recruited Spoobir.

FOS : Maney, Spoobir

Lynch : Maney

----------

No it doesn't appear to me as simple as that, Colin.

 

[Papa_Smurf]

If Mark's gone, can I replace him?

 

[hedger_14]

Ok, I was going to suggest using this to prove myself as the double voter. I really do not like Highlander's claim so I have no problem in lynching him.

Lynch: Highlander999

----------

And his defence of course, I should add.

 

[Chewie]

If Mark's gone, can I replace him?

He's not technically gone, he's on mod preview which means his posts have to be approved by a moderator, but he can't be bothered waiting for that so he just disappears until it's over

 

[Sachinfan98]

Aditya is just hell-bent on attacking me. I see no reason at all. Scummy on that. But he's 90% cleared in my mind. Aditya, can you please be more clear on why you want a role-claim from me?
---
Lynch:Highlander999
Going with the rest over here, and if he turns out town then we surely know who to lynch next day.

 

[P Squared]

Culli - 1 (CG123)
Sachinfan98 - 1 (Aditya)
Maney2k9 - 3 (Varun, User2010, 6ry4nj)
Spoobir - 1 (Highlander999)
Highlander999 - 7 (Sachinfan98, Hedger_14, BKB1991, Chewie, Maney2k9, Spoobir, Barmyarmy)

With 16 alive it takes 9 to lynch.
__________________

 

[Sachinfan98]

Ok so hedger isn't the double voter. He has faked it.
Unlynch:Highlander
Lynch:hedger_14

 

[Varun]

I guess it's hidden.

 

[Sachinfan98]

Varun what does hidden mean?

 

[Varun]

Means he is the double voter, but it doesn't show up in the vote counts to prevent others from knowing his role. Mod just tells you the hammer has been reached.

 

[Spoobir]

Now that Sachinfan unlynched we need 2 more people to lynch Highlander if we want to test the double voter claim.

 

[Sachinfan98]

Ok
Unlynch:hedger_14
Lynch:Highlander999

 

[Aditya]

I don't understand how I'm not clear in my point about SachinFan. I simply want him to role claim, when members like Tom and Chewie can role claim on the basis of being pressurized why cant he? Well, we must agree that he hasn't contributed much and to me he has looked very suspicious. He hasn't provided good enough reasons to lynch or unlynch someone and that's the BIGGEST reason I have for him to role claim. It's him first game so he must be careful while lynching someone. Another point is that, he is the only inexperienced member left. He's bound to be under pressure unless he role claims and his role claim seems valid to us. I might sound a bit selfish here but that's how it is, the time he lynched me and then later unlynched me without any doubts in his mind I was suspicious of him. He was maybe told by his mafia team mates to pressurize me because the truth is, in the previous games my defense has been pretty poor and that's the reason I posted a long post in my defense this time around to clear all doubts at once. In one of the posts, he said that my defense seems fine to him and then later when User and BKB pointed out that my defense was too long then he posted the same thing. Now, he's not suspicious of me but yet he doesn't understand my point that he should role claim to get out of the suspicion list. SachinFan, if you still have any doubts do let me know, I'd try to clear them.

 

[Sachinfan98]

So according to you Spoobir, Highlander is being taken as a sacrificial lamb in order to test hedger's claim. Are you serious?

 

[Aditya]

Fair enough, I should lynch Tom right?