Lord of the Rings Mafia - Town wins

[Highlander999]

Can I ask why you claimed then since you weren't pressured. You say you knew it was a role that would put you under suspicion, so why claim out of the blue?

Because we weren't going anywhere, I knew it would get everyone talking and it would let me see who would look a bit suspect in their reasons for going after me, and top of that list is you. What would be quite useful is Colin's updated graph thing with who has lynched who as you really seem to have been flailing in regards to lynching people.

P.S. Love your sig

 

[Deleted member 13648]

Colin is obviously a Townie, I have absolutely no doubts about that. Mafia aren't smart enough to self-poison.

 

[barmyarmy]

He's the only one I'm suspicious of at moment. I either have the option of jumping on the bandwagon or post my views on the game. I'm suspicious of SachinFan and I want a role claim from him.

I actually agree with you but I'd rather focus on Tom.
Forgot to do this:

Unlynch: Maney2k9
Lynch: Highlander999

 

[Highlander999]

Hmm Colin this brings me around to the fact that I reckon you and Spoobir are both mafia, because end of the day, I am the only one who is talking about going after you two and surprise surprise, within minutes of each other you both go for me. Coincidence, I think not.

Aditya is right the poisoning thing is very confusing and the write-up highlights that if people remember that. End of the day, yes if you lynch me off, you aren't loosing a power role, but can you afford to lose an active, semi-intelligent townie? If so, so be it, but make sure one of either Colin or Spoobir gets lynched the night after!

 

[Spoobir]

Hmm Colin this brings me around to the fact that I reckon you and Spoobir are both mafia, because end of the day, I am the only one who is talking about going after you two and surprise surprise, within minutes of each other you both go for me. Coincidence, I think not.

Aditya is right the poisoning thing is very confusing and the write-up highlights that if people remember that. End of the day, yes if you lynch me off, you aren't loosing a power role, but can you afford to lose an active, semi-intelligent townie? If so, so be it, but make sure one of either Colin or Spoobir gets lynched the night after!

Now who's flailing?

 

[Highlander999]

Not at all, my point is in fact highly accurate, in regards to how Colin was going on about how he was happy to go after Ben (I believe) earlier today, and yet the moment you come along and start putting pressure on me, within 1 reply he is there saying I have to be lynched for his safety. Incredibly fishy in my opinion.

 

[Spoobir]

Well I've already claimed Gimli, if you think he's not gonna be in the game you're an idiot. If you think someone will counter-claim me you're wrong. I assume barmyarmy decided to believe me because my claim is a lot more believable than yours...

 

[barmyarmy]

Not at all, my point is in fact highly accurate, in regards to how Colin was going on about how he was happy to go after Ben (I believe) earlier today, and yet the moment you come along and start putting pressure on me, within 1 reply he is there saying I have to be lynched for his safety. Incredibly fishy in my opinion.

I'll quote my post so there's no confusion:

You might have the support. If peope feel Tom's claim is legit and choose not to lynch him then I'd be prepared to lynch Maney.

I lynched you first...



----------

I was already leaning towards believing spoobir before he claimed.

 

[Highlander999]

Well I've already claimed Gimli, if you think he's not gonna be in the game you're an idiot. If you think someone will counter-claim me you're wrong. I assume barmyarmy decided to believe me because my claim is a lot more believable than yours...

Where did I say Gimli isn't in the game? How do I know someone won't counter claim him, it's been what about 20 minutes since you claimed him Talk about trying to quickly push through an agressive lynch before people have a time to look things over and make a proper decision.

----------

Again Colin, the more you post in Spoobir's defence the more I believe this whole poisoning thing was staged by the mafia. Anyone can see how incredibly agressive Spoobir is being, far more then needed by a townie, more like a mafia member, who is trying too hard.

----------

Anyway, I'm off to cook dinner

 

[barmyarmy]

Because we weren't going anywhere, I knew it would get everyone talking and it would let me see who would look a bit suspect in their reasons for going after me, and top of that list is you. What would be quite useful is Colin's updated graph thing with who has lynched who as you really seem to have been flailing in regards to lynching people.

P.S. Love your sig

Seeing as it proves you wrong here you go:

 

[barmyarmy]

Again Colin, the more you post in Spoobir's defence the more I believe this whole poisoning thing was staged by the mafia. Anyone can see how incredibly agressive Spoobir is being, far more then needed by a townie, more like a mafia member, who is trying too hard.

See here's your mistake. If you were arguing that I'm obviously a townie and must have been duped you might have had a chance but insisting that spoobir and I are both mafia flies in the face of all the evidence.

 

[BKB1991]

Hmm Tom, you haven't really done yourself favours here. I believe Spoobir is town, he's been aggressive and his roleclaim is very legit. Plus the points raised do cast suspicion on Tom.

I am just gonna have to see where we go from here. I would prefer to lynch Ben, but I don't mind joining the bandwagon on Tom

 

[Manly]

Hmm Tom, you haven't really done yourself favours here. I believe Spoobir is town, he's been aggressive and his roleclaim is very legit. Plus the points raised do cast suspicion on Tom.

I am just gonna have to see where we go from here. I would prefer to lynch Ben, but I don't mind joining the bandwagon on Tom

Why are you so hell-bent on killing me?

 

[BKB1991]

Haha, you seem like a safe bet afaic, though I am not impressed by Toms defence.

 

[Highlander999]

What can I say? I'm a great big bloody tree which walks around and talks about as fast as Ben thinks!

I do reckon Colin and Spoobir are being overly agressive with trying to lynch me. End of the day, I know I got put behind the 8 ball with this character, if I was mafia, would I really claim such a weak character when there are so many more prominent ones which haven't been claimed? Nothing more to be said. If you genuinely think I am stupid enough to be a mafia and claim like this, then lynch me, all I can say is you're wasting time going after me.