Lord of the Rings Mafia - Town wins

[Manly]

I will just say you guys are gonna be sorry that I've gone. Honestly don't see the town winning.

 

[Spoobir]

I don't like this "settle for Maney" idea at all...

We already know that someone who has claimed is lying, my best guess is Zohaib or Highlander, so I'd much rather take a risk on one of them than go for someone who has a tiny chance to be in a cult and definitely isn't mafia. Who knows, they might even slip up if a bit of pressure is put on them.

And frankly, some of the analysis of the write-ups in the last couple of pages has been idiotic.

 

[Highlander999]

I'm suspicious of Tom because of his claim. I went into a bit of detail before. Also because the night after he had posted how dangerous I might be to the town if I was mafia in an attempt to get my lynched I got poisoned.
I don't see myself as an early mafia target to kill unless Tom is mafia.

Let's be honest Colin, if I was mafia you would have been dead night 1

I am a vanilla townie unfortunately. I didn't realise people would take the winking smilie to mean something about my role, I was more meaning it in regards to the irony of me meant to have great knowledge lol.

I'm sticking my neck out and gonna go for Spoobir I don't like the way he is playing it is too agressive and I have a hunch he is mafia

Lynch: Spoobir

 

[BKB1991]

What did Zohaib claim again?

 

[barmyarmy]

I don't like this "settle for Maney" idea at all...

We already know that someone who has claimed is lying, my best guess is Zohaib or Highlander, so I'd much rather take a risk on one of them than go for someone who has a tiny chance to be in a cult and definitely isn't mafia. Who knows, they might even slip up if a bit of pressure is put on them.

And frankly, some of the analysis of the write-ups in the last couple of pages has been idiotic.

I agree about Maney being a last resort but unless we can settle on something we'll end up with no lynch.

 

[Zohaib]

I don't like this "settle for Maney" idea at all...

We already know that someone who has claimed is lying, my best guess is Zohaib or Highlander, so I'd much rather take a risk on one of them than go for someone who has a tiny chance to be in a cult and definitely isn't mafia. Who knows, they might even slip up if a bit of pressure is put on them.

And frankly, some of the analysis of the write-ups in the last couple of pages has been idiotic.

What makes you say that?

I said what was in my PM, my knowledge of LOTR isnt that great to pick a character like Highlander has, which is such a weak claim, I havent even heard of him, despite watching the movies

Yeah I forgot what happened in the movies, so yeah

 

[barmyarmy]

Let's be honest Colin, if I was mafia you would have been dead night 1

I am a vanilla townie unfortunately. I didn't realise people would take the winking smilie to mean something about my role, I was more meaning it in regards to the irony of me meant to have great knowledge lol.

I'm sticking my neck out and gonna go for Spoobir I don't like the way he is playing it is too agressive and I have a hunch he is mafia

Lynch: Spoobir

I nearly did end up dead and now I'm wondering if you're lynching spoobir just because I did.

I'm almost certain that one of Spoobir and Highlander999 is mafia. I'm leaning more towards Tom. What do others think?

 

[Spoobir]

Unlynch: Chewie
Lynch: Highlander999

Shocker everyone: I am Gimli. Better claim than Treebeard? You decide

 

[Highlander999]

I nearly did end up dead and now I'm wondering if you're lynching spoobir just because I did.

I'm almost certain that one of Spoobir and Highlander999 is mafia. I'm leaning more towards Tom. What do others think?

Believe me Colin if I was mafia you would have been dead by now. Do you really reckon I would have kept you around?

Everyone look at the way Spoobir has reacted with the agression thing I mentioned. That is the sign (in my opinion) of a guilty person trying to pin the mafia tag on me

----------

I just noticed he went after Zohaib as well, he is totally flailing around at people with no proper reasoning

 

[Aditya]

And, there again Aditya comes, posts about SF and doesn't take part in any discussion, goes. I'm really not sure what to make of him.

He's the only one I'm suspicious of at moment. I either have the option of jumping on the bandwagon or post my views on the game. I'm suspicious of SachinFan and I want a role claim from him.

 

[Deleted member 13648]

Believe me Colin if I was mafia you would have been dead by now. Do you really reckon I would have kept you around?

Everyone look at the way Spoobir has reacted with the agression thing I mentioned. That is the sign (in my opinion) of a guilty person trying to pin the mafia tag on me

----------

I just noticed he went after Zohaib as well, he is totally flailing around at people with no proper reasoning

Perhaps you did try to kill him, Colin was poisoned remember?

 

[Highlander999]

Two different roles Stu. The mafia always have a killing role (the Godfather) Colin being poisoned would have been done by another mafia member. Either way if I had been mafia and wasn't the Godfather I would have put considerable pressure on him to kill Colin.

End of the day I am a vanilla townie who got a bit of a short straw with a piss poor character being assigned to me which was always going to cause me to look suspect when I claim (remember I wasn't even pressured into claiming) I am highly suscpious of Spoobir and something with Colin still isn't clicking.

 

[Aditya]

If I go by my gut feeling, I want to lynch Colin. He just doesn't seem townie to me, that poison thing is very confusing. Ah well, we must not take such a big risk to lynch Colin without any good reason.

 

[Spoobir]

Two different roles Stu. The mafia always have a killing role (the Godfather) Colin being poisoned would have been done by another mafia member. Either way if I had been mafia and wasn't the Godfather I would have put considerable pressure on him to kill Colin.

End of the day I am a vanilla townie who got a bit of a short straw with a piss poor character being assigned to me which was always going to cause me to look suspect when I claim (remember I wasn't even pressured into claiming) I am highly suscpious of Spoobir and something with Colin still isn't clicking.

Can I ask why you claimed then since you weren't pressured. You say you knew it was a role that would put you under suspicion, so why claim out of the blue?

 

[barmyarmy]

If I go by my gut feeling, I want to lynch Colin.

I get that a lot...

----------

Believe me Colin if I was mafia you would have been dead by now. Do you really reckon I would have kept you around?

I reckon you tried to but your mafia pals said don't be ridiculous - ARay is far more dangerous. You had to settle for poisoning me instead.
I couldn't be killed night 2 as I was protected and I'm certainly expecting you to have a go at me night 3.
I want you lynched off for my safety.

----------

End of the day I am a vanilla townie who got a bit of a short straw with a piss poor character being assigned to me which was always going to cause me to look suspect when I claim (remember I wasn't even pressured into claiming) I am highly suscpious of Spoobir and something with Colin still isn't clicking.

As Spoobir said if you have a dodgy character you keep quiet. I reckon you were trying to get in under the radar with everyone else claiming.