Mini Mafia - Town wins!

[barmyarmy]

Um, are we waiting on a defense from Manly that is probably two days away if it's coming at all...

I want to know why he lynched Sedition. I won't even deign your first point with a response.

 

[puddleduck]

So.. now that barmyarmy has gone back to the cricket, what does everyone think of him? I'm actually thinking of targetting him instead of Puddleduck tonight, got a good feeling that Manly is his mafia buddy.

I think he's cute when he's angry, and he has dreamy eyes. But I'm not sure how that helps in this game.

 

[Sedition]

Well depending on what the others think, I can change my target from PD if they'd rather someone else. This is all if Manly is mafia obviously.

 

[hedger_14]

Lol, nor did I expect a response

And lol, barmy's gone, now let's go conspire against him behind his back - is what you are sounding like

But in all seriousness, he's been town looking. If manly flips mafia, feel free to block him and at least I'm happier knowing barmy is clear but tbh, you may be off blocking a different player. Tbh, I think you shouldnt block PD, let him protect you and if you die, then PD is mafia and if that's not the case, you have a chance of blocking the kill.

----------

But sim's another one who I have felt has slipped under the radar. He just seems to lurk for a few days, take everything in and then come up with a long, well thought response that makes it look like he is very active. However, if he's town, hes probably an important power role and blocking him could be harmful.

 

[Sedition]

Hmm yeah, I think we'd all be better off knowing whether barmyarmy's clear to be honest. Relying on him a lot, so it would be better to know it's coming from the right place

So yeah, barmyarmy is the new night target if Manly is mafia.

 

[puddleduck]

Well depending on what the others think, I can change my target from PD if they'd rather someone else. This is all if Manly is mafia obviously.

Yeah as far as I can tell you're logic is sound regarding the whole only sticking to your pre-revealing if Manly turns out to be mafia.

Since Barmy started the whole lynch on Manly and hasn't taken it off with 3 lynches there I would suggest they're not working together, though perhaps roleblock Barmy to at least make sure he makes it through the night, I think he could be an important town role, since he's never really batted an eyelid at how many potential towns there are. If he's mafia, he also can't murder. Either way, I feel you'll be blocking a mafia member or the potential killing of an important town player. That said, I'm happy to be roleblocked, because it means I wake up tomorrow alive. Which isn't something I've been particularly good at so far in these games

----------

Although, he could also be the cop, which would mean we lost the investigation... Interesting point about Sim, Hedger. He has been very cautious. Saying only what he needs to. He could like you say be an important role as well. Which side, I don't know, but he felt town earlier.

 

[barmyarmy]

You guys realise I can still read this on my iphone as I watch the cricket!

 

[puddleduck]

You guys realise I can still read this on my iphone as I watch the cricket!

Everyone hide

----------

You guys realise I can still read this on my iphone as I watch the cricket!

Completely off topic, but I got given an old iphone by a family member the other day and have been completely adicted to New Star Soccer. It's awesomely addictive. For 67p it's been worth every penny

 

[Sedition]

I'm not sure about Sim either, I think he was still suspicious of me well after the roleclaim and my explanations, which I thought was weird. Same with Manly.

Just a little bit suspicious of barmy after reading the start of D2 where he's pushing for roleclaims, under assumption of normal setups. Might be nothing and he genuinely felt, like I did, that we could checkmate the mafia if we played our cards right today.

 

[barmyarmy]

Just a little bit suspicious of barmy after reading the start of D2 where he's pushing for roleclaims, under assumption of normal setups. Might be nothing and he genuinely felt, like I did, that we could checkmate the mafia if we played our cards right today.

Under classic setup it was basically game over. Sadly this isn't classic.

 

[puddleduck]

So am I right in thinking we have Adi, Sedition, and Sim currently without any kind of vote placed. All of them waiting on some kind of response from Manly?

If Manly is mafia, surely one of them has to be? If he isn't like I said before, surely at least one from Me, Barmy, Hedger must be?

 

[Sedition]

I can hammer the lynch if you guys are happy to go with the plan, which is currently for me to target barmyarmy if Manly is mafia.

----------

Reason being I'm not as suspicious as PD anymore and it would be better to confirm the guy we're looking to is on our side.. and to protect him in that case also.

 

[barmyarmy]

I'd like to hear why he's lynched you before he hammer (or don't hammer) him.

----------

It would be quite suspicious for you to hammer him as he has accused you...

 

[puddleduck]

I would have liked to have heard why Manly put a lynch on you, but we could literally end up waiting until the deadline for him to bother, judging by his current lack of interest in this game, and I think I'd have liked some more from Sim.

I'm excited though, first blind lynch in a game I've played where I didn't already know the target was mafia or I was already dead Nervous now though... what if he's town? I think I'll be too hurt if Barmy or Sedition have been lying this whole time. Might have to find a new forum to click new posts on

----------

(I am of course joking here a bit) I won't be hurt, but mighty impressed!

 

[Sedition]

Ah okay, if you guys are waiting, I won't hammer it. Just wanted honours of hammering Manly

If there's some kind of massive turnaround and everyone tells me to target someone else, I'll do it, otherwise the plan will remain the same.