Time to speak up.
I'll admit that I've pretty much failed to analyze this very well, but being busy modding the other game, I couldn't do much. But I've spotted Abhas as lying, and the thing is, I would've posted this, and lynched Abhas even if Abhas hadn't accused me, because he's openly using references to my character to make up his own.
I'm
Shawne Merriman, Cheater, Town-aligned. Known around the NFL as 'Lights Out', I'm a strong but injury prone linebacker. In 2006 I was suspended for four games after violating the NFL's steroid policy. Because of this Iam the Cheater. Each night I learn a role that is in the game, but not who has it.
The key phrase here is 'Each night I learn'. I don't choose if I learn about a role or not. Just do. All the three descriptions on the three nights referring to a person gathering information from various sources (and on night 1 being roleblocked) refer to me.
With most of the players fast asleep, one man couldn't. Instead he visited a friend, asking for some information. He knew he couldn't know everything but at least he had got something. This information would come in handy later and he knew he'd learn more the next night.
Having gathered information the previous night he wanted more and knew where to find it. The only thing he didn't count on was being hounded by a former team mate, wanting to go grab a drink and catch up. Reluctantly he agreed. The information would have to wait.
Having been distracted last night, he was hungry for more information. He met with his trusted source and gained information, this time from the other side. He didn't know who, but he knew their aim. 'Interesting', he thought to himself, before heading back to his room.
I cannot provide evidence that Abhas is lying about his character (although I'm darn sure he's not a Gunsmith, because I don't have a gun). But I can prove I am telling the truth and it isn't Abhas who's been referred to in the writeup.
I know from my role there's a Voyeur in the game (who is definitely town), and a Usurper (mafia) as well. I can also fully explain all the three paragraphs describing me (besides 'The only thing he didn't count on was being hounded by a former team mate', although I have reasonable explanation for that as well.).
Night 0, and Night 2, I have been described visiting a friend, and a trusted source respectively. Now who but a Cheater would do this to gain information? Wouldn't Abhas search people instead if he was the Gunsmith? I can assure you that the friend and the trusted source are not characters in this game. 'This time from the other side', on Night 2 refers to the fact that I gained information about the other alignment, that is the mafia. Of course, Usurper belongs to the mafia. That clearly proves that the Voyeur is town. The news of Usurper to me was 'Interesting'. I know his aim but obviously didn't know who it was. Also, 'This information would come in handy later and he knew he'd learn more the next night.' simply shows that I am forced to use my role on every night.
Coming back to Night 1, I was roleblocked, yes. Strong arguments by Abhas and Haarithan, La Tomlinson being his former teammate, and Haarithan assuring all that he froze Abhas actually made me ignorant of the fact that it was me, I also being engaged in the other mafia game. The Night 2 writeup confirms that I was roleblocked, and the only thing I can't explain properly enough is who was that 'former teammate'. It couldn't be Abhas, it couldn't be Haarithan (although they are my character's former teammate'), for Haarithan time-froze Abhas on Night 1, and I can only speculate he's the mafia roleblocker, the one who blocked Themer.
I have also made a grievous fault even by suggesting that there is a cult. While examining the night writeup again, I have been assured that 'currently without a team' refers to a free agent rather than a person without any alignment or cult. He can be anyone, and I feel either mafia/SK. Although it has no connection to my role whatsoever.
I know for sure Abhas is lying. To convince you, I would only like the Voyeur to come up (obviously I don't expect the Usurper to do so, although I believe I've caused the tension in the mafia camp already
), and testify that he's in the game, which would confirm my identity as a Cheater, and thus disprove Abhas being a Gunsmith, for I don't have a gun. And there goes Abhas.
Obviously, my lynch stays.
