I think you both are wasting your time explaining to him because he will not even give him credit even if Dhoni gets a 5-fer.
You are right. Cause the performance has to be consistent. He does play, he does produce a beautiful gem once in a while, but MSD has the capacity to do much more if he uses his brains a bit more. This can be achieved by coming up the order and not making stupid statements and or decisions.
I have never mentioned that MSD cannot bat. The entire discussion revolves around his captaincy. If you want,go back a few posts and you will find that the debate started when I asked the question about him leading us to 3 white-washes. The debate is on his captaincy, not his batting.