PC Graphics Maker Championship Season 8 | Final Round - R#10 Results + Season Summary!

[mattfb]

Surprised no one is saying how good Entry 10 is... Simply superb.

I'll send in my ratings now pranav.

 

[treva]

Entry 2 and 10 are immense. 2 is my favourite and I think it'll win.

 

[Aoun13]

Surprised no one is saying how good Entry 10 is... Simply superb.

I'll send in my ratings now pranav.

No need to surprise I had already appreciated entry 10 work, it's fantastic to me also.

 

[Bounce]

I am loving Entry 11. Its simple and sweet.

 

[Varun]

I am loving Entry 11. Its simple and sweet.

Simplicity doesn't count in this competition. If you are simple, you are just kicked off.

 

[mattfb]

Since when? A lot of people go for simple and absolutely fail. Simple is meant to look clean and easy but not take 1 minute... eg entry 10 is so smooth and clean yet I bet it took a long time.

 

[Monzi]

^^It is made from a tutorial so it must take a long time to do.

 

[mattfb]

Well he must of followed the tutorial to perfection... Following tutorials isn't a crime.

 

[Monzi]

Well he must of followed the tutorial to perfection... Following tutorials isn't a crime.

I din't said tutorial is crime,But i suggest that it should not be used in competition.

 

[KBC]

Executing a tutorial is as important as a tutorial itself. So don't try to demean the entries if they're inspired from a tutorial. Makes no sense whatsoever if you're whining about it. The Judges will rate as the entries deserve;

 

[apsamrit]

Executing a tutorial is as important as a tutorial itself. So don't try to demean the entries if they're inspired from a tutorial. Makes no sense whatsoever if you're whining about it. The Judges will rate as the entries deserve;

It is unfair then. There isn't any self creativity used in that entry. Its like stealing or using the creativity or ideas of others to their own advantage. Even the text is not self made. There is no skill involved in making the text. Its made in a different software where you only need to type the text and the rest is done by the computer.We have seen lots of graphic makers minding and getting angry when someone uses their ideas or concepts.

 

[Pranav]

Well this indeed is a debatable topic. As I said earlier, following a tutorial is an art in itself. If I was rating the entries this week, I'll definitely deduct some points for creativity, but it'll still be on the top 2/3 of my ratings. Ultimately it boils down to the individual that's rating the entries. One can give it a perfect score while others may think the other way round. That's the reason we have so many Panel Members and not just one.

 

[Monzi]

many Panel Members

How can you say many it is only a few,Only three members are rating.

 

[KBC]

It is unfair then. There isn't any self creativity used in that entry. Its like stealing or using the creativity or ideas of others to their own advantage. Even the text is not self made. There is no skill involved in making the text. Its made in a different software where you only need to type the text and the rest is done by the computer.We have seen lots of graphic makers minding and getting angry when someone uses their ideas or concepts.

You could have known there are points for creativity as well. So there's no panic.

Edit: You talk about the text, so when you use textures is memory blank?

 

[Aoun13]

I guess there is no rule that we should have to use PS for creating art. Entries must be judge on basis of what we see, not what softwares he used. I guess I am totally agree with pranav and KBC except deducting some creativity marks there is nothing more you can do.