PC Graphics Maker Championship Season 8 | Final Round - R#10 Results + Season Summary!

[Pranav]

What? Entry 1 had to win this. It had superb lighting and excellent imagination.
What has happened to our panel members?

That's one of the reasons we discontinued public voting. Guys like you can never judge the real effort and finishing/persona of an artwork. If the panel members start giving the best score to an entry like that, I will quit managing this competition.

Anyone that has a decent knowledge of photoshop can work out that it would have taken less than 5 minutes to create an entry like that. It is too bright in some areas, has below par text, and several other things that aren't right about it. The only thing that's good is the stock choice and positioning. That's about it.

 

[Viral Shah]

Made my Best wallpaper. I also can't believe that i made it.

 

[Aditya]

Naresh :

Entry 11
Avatar: 2/3
Signature: 5/7
Total Rating: 7/10
Comments : nice thinking there but horrible execution... Watch some tuts

Entry 11
Avatar: 1.5/3
Signature:3.5/7
Total Rating: 5/10
Comments : lol at the ava...creative ...good sig...liking the lightning in the middle one...though text is pretty decent....sig looks incomplete to me..somethings missing there...would loved a touch more work on this sig.......overall great entry KIU

I was going through the ratings by panel members and I am sure that one of the above ratings for entry 11 has been rated by Neo because Neo ratings does not have entry 11 rating.

 

[Pranav]

Should be corrected now.

 

[KBC]

Announcement:

Since creativity and Inspiration are base to judging, Though much creativity shown in entries was not recognized properly in recent times. It's a proper Idea to mind the discrimination of work done by people for rightful judging. So, to enrich the result of the judging, we ask ALL Entry senders to send the stock/render images (only the main stock) along with their entries used in them. They will be put with the entries on display. So it will be better for judges to sight a quality of an entry than to judge a finished entry alone.

 

[Meet]

Good idea!

 

[Viral Shah]

But if we don't have stock and render saved than what?
For Eg:- i have used a abstract stock as a main stock than used any render on it than i have to post both render and stock. And if yes than it is hard to find that abstract stock from my bulk of resources.


But if we give PSD along with entry than it will do instead of render and main stock.

 

[Varun]

ALL Entry senders to send the stock/render images (only the main stock) along with their entries used in them.

Can we just give the link to it? For eg if I am using Ahad's renders.

 

[MaD]

Just the render or stock of the player, not the texture stocks
I think

 

[Monzi]

Announcement:

Since creativity and Inspiration are base to judging, Though much creativity shown in entries was not recognized properly in recent times. It's a proper Idea to mind the discrimination of work done by people for rightful judging. So, to enrich the result of the judging, we ask ALL Entry senders to send the stock/render images (only the main stock) along with their entries used in them. They will be put with the entries on display. So it will be better for judges to sight a quality of an entry than to judge a finished entry alone.

Is it officially confirmed?As it looks bit odd.

 

[Pranav]

Nothing official yet. I'll have a chat with KBC before giving a thumbs up to it.

 

[KBC]

But if we don't have stock and render saved than what?
For Eg:- i have used a abstract stock as a main stock than used any render on it than i have to post both render and stock. And if yes than it is hard to find that abstract stock from my bulk of resources.


But if we give PSD along with entry than it will do instead of render and main stock.

No, just the image of the person you've used. Since it's the main subject. No textures or any thing else. Just the Image of the player. Be it stock or a render.

Can we just give the link to it? For eg if I am using Ahad's renders.

Just the link of the image you've used will do.

Just the render or stock of the player, not the texture stocks
I think

Yep. Nobody is ought to post their textures or stuff, for obvious reasons. Only the renders/photos of the players.



This is for many reasons other than from the light of judging. For safe reasons, and to avoid that lame doubt of ripping used works.

It's mostly official, but Pranav wants to hear it for himself.

KBC added 3 Minutes and 36 Seconds later...

Something more practical like this:

Entry 1:

Stock used:

http://www.cricinfo.com/db/PICTURES/CMS/117500/117592.jpg

THERE's the idea. So what happens is that it gives a more greater relevance for judging. And to convey the work of the artist more easily than not.

 

[Bounce]

The idea looks good to me.

 

[Viral Shah]

No problem with that KBC

 

[Pranav]

It's mostly official, but Pranav wants to hear it for himself.

I won't put it up unless you discuss some things with me.

This seems to become way too problematic in some situations.

*PM me*