PC version 1.15.x discussion/bug reporting thread

[Sourabh007]

Now i am fully bored with the stumping bug that's very annoying. 1)In a match i faced 3 time and out...out...and...out. This is so boring.2) Wide balls are not giving wide.3)A runout by AI bowler shoulder and also bowl go through the wicket. This is like there haven't any physics. Also this was called as runout.Here some pictures:

 

[Snowy]

Couple of things

• You need to understand that the visual clipping on this game isn't perfect
• You REALLY need to better understand the laws of cricket - those stumps aren't broken yet. Nor was the image on a previous page definitely a wide. The line outside off stump is used as a subjective guide - there is no black and white rule that says if the ball is outside that line, it has to be a wide.

 

[Plotinus]

A bug found :

Career Player is being allowed more than 10 overs in a One Day game which isn't right obviously and also never happened before.
View attachment 148619

This has always been the case in my experience. In career mode the restrictions on number of overs you can bowl is not enforced for your career player. Not a new issue with this patch.

 

[Sourabh007]

Couple of things

• You need to understand that the visual clipping on this game isn't perfect
• You REALLY need to better understand the laws of cricket - those stumps aren't broken yet. Nor was the image on a previous page definitely a wide. The line outside off stump is used as a subjective guide - there is no black and white rule that says if the ball is outside that line, it has to be a wide.

"You REALLY need to better understand the laws of cricket - those stumps aren't broken yet." Just see the image right side bell is it flying(half)? OK but in 1st picture you see that stumps are hit by the bowl which was hardly threw by AI fielder but stumps weren't broken and bowler received it in the stumps.I have no video then you understood it clearly because images are not clear for this incident but i am sure it's a bug or animation problem.
wides are call when ball travel outside of the offside line or on the line. so you see the ball and also shadow.


"The line outside off stump is used as a subjective guide - there is no black and white rule that says if the ball is outside that line, it has to be a wide." - so why umpairs use to with this line as a wide line in international and other matches ?

 

[cricket_online]

Now i am fully bored with the stumping bug that's very annoying. 1)In a match i faced 3 time and out...out...and...out. This is so boring.2) Wide balls are not giving wide.3)A runout by AI bowler shoulder and also bowl go through the wicket. This is like there haven't any physics. Also this was called as runout.Here some pictures:
View attachment 148777
View attachment 148778

If this was given run out I don't see anything wrong with it. One of the bails was dislodged and the bat hadn't crossed the line. Wide in the pic is a subjective call and can go either way.

 

[Snowy]

"The line outside off stump is used as a subjective guide - there is no black and white rule that says if the ball is outside that line, it has to be a wide." - so why umpairs use to with this line as a wide line in international and other matches ?

IS IT USED AS A GUIDE. There is no objective law in relation to the offside line. The answer is in the post that you quoted.

And the bail has to be completely dislodged, not half-dislodged for the stumps to be broken. It is only half out in the image you posted.

 

[Gamer Pradosh]

Does the game actually give run outs only when the stumps are completely dislodged??

 

[Sourabh007]

ok. That's run out and wides are subjective ok. And stumping bug? If anyone tell me how to upload video? Because mp4 videos are not uploading. Then i will post video.

 

[cricket_online]

Does the game actually give run outs only when the stumps are completely dislodged??

Why should stumps be dislodged? I've been given run out with bail(s) dislodged, as it should be. Run out rule is pretty simple... if even a single bail is dislodged and some the batsman's bat hasn't crossed the line, he is out. Only one solitary bail needs to be dislodged to be given run out.

If bails for some reason were dislodged earlier, you can go for the run out by dislodging one of the stumps from the ground. If in some weird scenario all the 3 stumps are dislodged too and you still want to attempt a run out, you will have to replace/put one of the stumps in the ground and dislodge/break it again.

I recall seeing a match where this scenario played out... batsmen attempted a run, the throw came to bowlers's end and it was a little wide of the stumps. The bowler attempted a dive to catch the ball and landed on the stumps demolishing all 3 stumps. Batsmen attempted an overthrow and the backing fielder threw the ball back to the bowler. Meanwhile batsman at the striker's end refused the overthrow and the batsman at the non-striker's end was left stranded. The bowler put a stump back in the ground and took it out with the ball in hand. The batsman was given out after some deliberation between the umpires.

 

[MattW]

ok. That's run out and wides are subjective ok. And stumping bug? If anyone tell me how to upload video? Because mp4 videos are not uploading. Then i will post video.

The stumping thing was reported very early on in the thread and there isn't a need to keep repeating the same bugs over and over again. Upload videos to YouTube and then paste the link here.

 

[Sourabh007]

Does the game actually give run outs only when the stumps are completely dislodged??

yes, i also want to say this question to all. Because if bells are not fully dislodged then it's not full out or not out. It has to be complectly dislodged.

 

[Dutch]

yes, i also want to say this question to all. Because if bells are not fully dislodged then it's not full out or not out. It has to be complectly dislodged.

Bells? Was Quasimodo on strike?

 

[Gamer Pradosh]

Why should stumps be dislodged? I've been given run out with bail(s) dislodged, as it should be. Run out rule is pretty simple... if even a single bail is dislodged and some the batsman's bat hasn't crossed the line, he is out. Only one solitary bail needs to be dislodged to be given run out.

if even a single bail is dislodged COMPLETELY off the stumps [so the bails shouldn't be touching the stumps] only then can be called out...

As MattW said its a bug reported long time ago so we just have to wait for the gameplay related patches to come....Though you should wait for a longer time...

 

[MattW]

An old post from Ross explains things better than I can:

The key is to understand that the graphics are not tied to the physics.

The physics is run and the graphics are a representation of that in 3D. There may well be bugs in the graphical representation, agreed, however the underlying physics are reasonably true.

The ball through bat, etc. are issues with frame rate and the speed of the bat. The physics model sees a miss, the graphical representation is that the ball went through the bat as the bat has not been rendered fast enough.

Occasional visual weirdness is something you just need to accept - sure it sucks when a lot of cricket relies on viewing frame by frame replays, but as far as the game knows, it's all right internally.

 

[Gamer Pradosh]

Occasional visual weirdness is something you just need to accept - sure it sucks when a lot of cricket relies on viewing frame by frame replays, but as far as the game knows, it's all right internally.

So same goes with the fielders going through the stumps etc??