PlanetCricket Mafia | Endgame!

[Abhas]

FOS: Abahs at the moment too, saying he was silenced could have been a very good ploy for him to be on our side and rid him of suspicion unless we find out that someone has been silenced today too.

Hmm, so we have 3 mafias down. Lost/Usurper, Roleblocker and Doctor plus we know there is a mafia poisoner. That plus the godfather makes 5 which is probably all the mafia accounted for. So... how did Abhas get silenced?

Right, Spoobir, how can you be so sure that the mafia cannot have a silencer? Oh yeah, because you're mafia, and you know all the roles your fellow mafia have.

Same with Ollie.. He knows very well that nobody will be silenced today, and knowing there isn't a silencer in the mafia, it was easy for them to know I wasn't actually silenced. By saying this, he would have got a lynch started against me.

Guys, I wasn't silenced. I pretended to being silenced, so that the mafia can come out against me.

Lynch: Spoobir

FOS: Ollie

 

[Ollie_H]

Right, Spoobir, how can you be so sure that the mafia cannot have a silencer? Oh yeah, because you're mafia, and you know all the roles your fellow mafia have.

Hahaha what? Why would there be 6 mafia members in a 20 person game? Which then makes sense for there to be know silencer because they have already lost 3 and if it's a 5 person mafia,unless the Godfather has multiple roles it isn't really possible for there to be a silencer.

Same with Ollie.. He knows very well that nobody will be silenced today, and knowing there isn't a silencer in the mafia, it was easy for them to know I wasn't actually silenced. By saying this, he would have got a lynch started against me.

Yeah, I know exactly that no one has been silenced today I just thought i'd do it to get another lynch. I never even said that we would have to wait and see if someone was silenced and didn't want to do anything immediate hence why I went for Riz and not you.

 

[ZoraxDoom]

DAMN YOU PAPA SMURF.

And I knew I was the SK. I just knew it

 

[Spoobir]

Lol so you admit you lied about being silenced and you expect people not to lynch you now?

----------

I bet you were really annoyed the SK killed Zorax because it totally exposed that there couldn't be a mafia silencer.

 

[Abhas]

If I had a wrong intention, I wouldn't have admitted.
If people use their brains, they can easily notice the fact that you're mafia. Infact there wasn't even a semblance of defense from you.

Hahaha what? Why would there be 6 mafia members in a 20 person game? Which then makes sense for there to be know silencer because they have already lost 3 and if it's a 5 person mafia,unless the Godfather has multiple roles it isn't really possible for there to be a silencer.


Yeah, I know exactly that no one has been silenced today I just thought i'd do it to get another lynch.I never even said that we would have to wait and see if someone was silenced and didn't want to do anything immediate hence why I went for Riz and not you.

There can very well be, considering MaD was a hidden mafia, who needed to be recruited. It was unfortunate for us that he was recruited the first night itself, making the mafia stronger.
Remember, there is a possibility of the mafia killing the hidden mafia or poisoning him. It also may take them 2-3 nights to find their target.

 

[Spoobir]

Why do I need to defend myself? You're the one that's been caught out in a blatant lie.

I gotta admit it would have been a pretty smart plan, you claim you've been silenced then the next day another of your mafia buddies claims he was silenced and one by one you draw suspicion off yourselves by pretending to have been targeted by the mafia. Too bad Papa ruined it for you.

Also why are you still arguing with Ollie that there could be a 6th mafia who might be silencer when you already admitted you LIED! Clutching at every straw you can eh?

 

[Ollie_H]

There can very well be, considering MaD was a hidden mafia, who needed to be recruited. It was unfortunate for us that he was recruited the first night itself, making the mafia stronger.
Remember, there is a possibility of the mafia killing the hidden mafia or poisoning him. It also may take them 2-3 nights to find their target.

I guess that's true is because he was the Usurper, so if you take that into account it's possible that there could be 6 mafia. Still feel that 6 + 1 SK is slightly overbalanced.

Also, there is a member who has been poisoned on Night 2, so will either die at the end of this day period or the next night period.

 

[Spoobir]

Lynch All Liars - MafiaWiki

 

[Abhas]

Why do I need to defend myself? You're the one that's been caught out in a blatant lie.

Because you have been uncovered as the mafia because of that lie.

I gotta admit it would have been a pretty smart plan, you claim you've been silenced then the next day another of your mafia buddies claims he was silenced and one by one you draw suspicion off yourselves by pretending to have been targeted by the mafia. Too bad Papa ruined it for you.

Umm.. Sorry, I don't get your point? If you're trying to say I was protecting myself from the SK, then you should know that would have been the dumbest thing to do. It's better for the SK to kill the townies rather than mafia because confirmed townies are the toughest to get rid off. His aim is sole survival.

Also why are you still arguing with Ollie that there could be a 6th mafia who might be silencer when you already admitted you LIED! Clutching at every straw you can eh?

I never said there are 6 mafias in this game. Neither did I once say that there is a silencer in the mafia.
I'm simply bringing out a fact that 6 mafia is very much a possibility.
Who's clutching at straws?

 

[Spoobir]

Whatever man, I know everyone considers you some sort of mafia royalty around here so you may be able to brainwash enough of them into believing your blatant lies but to be honest if they do they're beyond help anyway.

The case against you is good enough for a lynch right now so I'm pretty much done for today, my lynch stands and people can believe who they want.

 

[Abhas]

Whatever man, I know everyone considers you some sort of mafia royalty around here so you may be able to brainwash enough of them into believing your blatant lies but to be honest if they do they're beyond help anyway.

The case against you is good enough for a lynch right now so I'm pretty much done for today, my lynch stands and people can believe who they want.

Firstly, I don't consider myself as the best player around. Not at all. I regard many in the current lot better than me. I have never used "experience" as a reason for lynching anyone, nor have I used it as a reason to persuade. Go back and read the threads if you want to. I play each game afresh, and same is here.
So, persuasion based on my status is out of the question. If there is anyone I would like to be persuaded, it would be done through proper reasoning.

Regarding the fact that I lied, a lie is something which is uncovered by others, or not uncovered at all. I myself came out to declare that I wasn't silenced. If I wanted to lie, I could've continued to say I was indeed silenced.

Anyway, you're trying to distract people away from the fact that you're mafia, rather focusing on the method I used to uncover you.

My lynch stays, and FOS on Ollie stays as well.

 

[Varun]

TBH, it makes sense to have 6 mafia + SK, and it isn't overbalanced considering there was a lost mafia, and we have a killing role on our side as well. (the guy who perma-banned)

----------

And adding to Abhas' argument, coincidentally, both Spoobir and Ollie are gunning for 'inactive' players, especially Abhas. It could be an attempt to get Abhas out of the way and compensate for the three mafia deaths, huh?

 

[Spoobir]

FOS: Varun

Defending Abhas to the death.

 

[simsanta123]

Last 20 member game's composition (it was considered pretty balanced)
5 mafia
1 individual aligned
2 cult (1 of which was recruited)
12 townies

----------

So basically, there were 7 anti-towns , 1 neutral, and 12 pro- towns.

----------

So now..what we KNOW in this game
3 mafia
1 individual
4 townies

----------

If I take that this game has roughly the same composition as Pokemon Mafia,
then there would be 4 more anti-towns (+- 1).

 

[Varun]

FOS: Varun

Defending Abhas to the death.

I'm the one who suspected MaD first and quoted his 'lost mafia' post as suspicious. Then how I could be mafia?

Also, I didn't defend Abhas to the death, it's just that you've actually reacted weirdly to his allegations. We all know we can never trust Abhas, and he can be so tricky at times, but his allegations seriously make sense.