PlanetCricket Mafia | Endgame!

[Abhas]

If I was mafia I would wait and see you give out a reason to why you were presumably silenced. It would make more sense for them to try and understand what is going on (remember they know more than town, so they would like to keep them in check) then lynch someone, anyone, randomly.

Look back, Ollie did just that. He confidently claimed there I was lying, and lynched Riz for inactivity, putting me under FOS.
Then came Spoobir, and led a lynch against me, based on the 'lie'.

Plus they are very unlikely to mention that you are silenced considering its usually a mafia role (even if they are trying to show they are town, its very unlikely).

Who is the 'they' referring to here? If you're talking about why I claimed silenced, you'll know at the end of the game, who was right and who was wrong.

Staying quite on the MaD thing might actually be a very good idea for you. In the last game it was Simsanta who was quiet during the mafia lynches and hence we couldnt really figure out his alignment and we basically lynched him for his inactivity.

If I have a possibility of getting lynched, is it a good thing or bad for me?

I am not saying you are mafia, but you LIED. Thats something townies should not do unless they are protecting themselves because they have a role. And you dont fit in the category just yet.

Agreed, but look at the holistic situation, without focusing on the point that I lied. I played the lie to put the mafia in doubt, rather than confusing the town. As townies, it is easy to believe a person may have been silenced, as was the case with me, but with Mafia, they know, either the person is lying, or there is something messy going around.

It wasn't rocket science for them to know I was lying, so they were the first to pick on that, which was exactly what I was after. A lie is an easy lynch, but look what that lie has got for the town - We have 2 mafias uncovered.

I think we need your character claim, because I am prepared to lynch you off just because you lied to the town and how do we know that you are saying the truth when you are town. You have already lied once..

I'll claim, I'm Pranav, the Survivor, Individually aligned
"I win if I survive till the end of the game. Being a master graphic artist, I don't want to choose sides, and aim for survival so that I can continue to make avatars and signatures for the survivors.
I don't have any role."


I want you guys to go through the thread after night 2, when I didn't post for the entire day. Look at how people reacted to the fact that I wasn't posting, and to the suggestion that I may have been silenced.

I want you to look at the events as they happened, and not from hindsight. Clearly, some people would have been surprised by my silence, and they are most likely to be the mafia.

All I ask for now is a little support to pressure Spoobir.

----------

* The part of my claim in quotes is paraphrased from my PM.

 

[BKB1991]

Your claim is ver believabe. Should clear you for the time being. I think I am going to look back at the posts surrounding you, but I think you have already done that, so wo do you have in mind?

They was referring to mafia btw. I think I finally see where you are getting at.staying from the outside what have you observed then?

 

[Abhas]

My Lynch candidate is Spoobir. He's definitely mafia.
FOS: Ollie, Highlander.

I've outlined pretty much everything I felt about the game and my suspects.

I'm not completely sure about the FOS people, but the cop should be able to help us on that. At the moment though, I'm 100% certain about Spoobir, hence my lynch.

If you guys are still intent on lynching me, you know whom to go after. Though, I would like to remind you there's one townie poisoned as well. So, as I see it, there may be a situation very soon that even though we know the mafia, we can't do anything to get them.

----------

Anyway, I'm off to Uni, and won't be able to login for atleast 6 hours.
I request everyone to read through the last day and today to comprehend what I'm trying to say.

 

[Spoobir]

Why should anyone believe anything you have to say Abhas? You have already been exposed and admitted that you lied, therefore nothing you say can be trusted one bit.

Also you have now claimed survivor, so even if what you are saying is true why would you pull such a stupid move which at best has only caused major confusion amongst the town.

I have done nothing to show to show I'm mafia other than expose your lies. You on the other hand:

• Started the lynches on Vedarshi on day 1 knowing he would defend himself poorly.
• Didn't post for a day then claimed to be silenced.
• After Zorax's death showed there couldn't be a silencer you admitted you flat out lied because of some grand plan to find the mafia.
• Claimed survivor which means pulling such a dumb stunt was completely unnecessary for your role.
• Tried to attack the people who called you out on your lies.

 

[CG123]

I'm not really sure where I sit atm, but why is it such a big deal that he lied? My lie in Pokemon mafia to get rid of Papa_Smurf was pretty much the turning point in the game, as after that four more mafia died in consecutive days. I'm just struggling to see why it's such a major reason to lynch him, as it could be a tactical decision like he's saying.

By the looks of things though it seems that one of Abhas or Spoobir is mafia, but I'm just not really sure who is out of them.

Spoobir does make a very good point, it seems strange that as a survivor you'd try such a move like that. Where as being mafia it would be a good stunt to pull, as you could have though a few more might have jumped on you.

He roleclaim does seem plausible though, but I did say the same thing about MaD's claim (because p# took a while to counterclaim him, as he's not the most active going around). There is no certainty that Pranav would be in the game though.

Also another thing is that MaD claimed survivor right, and since you weren't actually silenced, why didn't you counterclaim him saying you were the survivor?

 

[riz7khan12]

Also another thing is that MaD claimed survivor right, and since you weren't actually silenced, why didn't you counterclaim him saying you were the survivor?

because he was either mafia himself and they planned this out or he knew somehow that mad was bs and in that case he would have a role.

 

[CG123]

Well the first part's obvious which is why I asked it, but what do you mean by the second part, how does having a role relate to being a survivor and counterclaiming MaD?

 

[riz7khan12]

how does having a role relate to being a survivor and counterclaiming MaD?

first of all i'm not sure if he even is who he claims to be although it seems good enough, secondly a survivor might have some sort of a role which allows him to know some sort of investigation role which he may have used on mad the night before idk.

 

[Ollie_H]

Look back, Ollie did just that. He confidently claimed there I was lying,

Yeah, I came out and called your bluff and then you had to say you were lieing. You lied to try and benefit the town and in your opinion you have found 2 'mafia's.' So now you want to try and lead a lynch of Spoobir and then me. So if Spoobir comes out town, you can then say: 'well, Spoobir wasn't that mafia member, it's Ollie' and then you waste another day period lynching me off and after 2 day lynches and AT LEAST 2 night kills that would leave only 8 alive and the Godfather and his buddy would be in full control.

It's a clever move for you to try that, so you now have two suspects who, giving your influence in the game, you can persuade people to lynch off whilst you sit back and know that you are simply causing confusion in the town camp.

I also don't believe your claim, it just doesn't quite add up and if you really weren't silenced you would have come out and cc'd MaD when you could because there was a big gap between MaD claiming and p# counter claiming.

----------

Riz, you're viewing the thread so it would be advisable to post.

 

[CG123]

@ Riz - I don't think that has anything to do with what I'm asking.

I'm asking Abhas if he is who he says he is (a survivor), and he's trying to find mafia (like he says he is), why didn't he say anything when MaD claimed survivor, because he says he wasn't actually silenced so he could have counterclaimed, but he didn't.

 

[Ollie_H]

If I was mafia I would wait and see you give out a reason to why you were presumably silenced. It would make more sense for them to try and understand what is going on (remember they know more than town, so they would like to keep them in check) then lynch someone, anyone, randomly.

I didn't wait for him to give a reason and try to understand. I was immediately suspicious that he may have just been using a clever ploy.

 

[Ollie_H]

Just seen Riz's posts, but they are still adding absolutely nothing which makes me more suspicious.

Why have you been so quiet Riz? And when you do post, why aren't you analyzing different situations? You seem to only focus in on one and then just try and cause more confusion from it.

 

[Highlander999]

TBH, Abhas, I don't see why I should believe you when you did lie. I don't really know if I should belive your role-claim, so for the moment I'll leave my lynch on you as I need a bit more convincing. The thing is, I am a bit concerned about Spoobir as well and ever so slightly Ollie, because whilst you did not exactly help your case with confusing everyone, Spoobir has been pursuing you very agressively, so if you are lynched and it turns out you were telling the truth I feel Spoobir has some serious explaining.

 

[Chewie]

Vote Count:

Spoobir (1) - Abhas
Abhas (2) - Spoobir, BKB1991, Highlander999
Riz7khan12 (1) - Ollie_H

With 12 alive it takes 7 for a lynch

 

[Ollie_H]

Abhas (2) - Spoobir, BKB1991, Highlander999

Shouldn't that be 3? Unless someone's vote doesn't count.