PlanetCricket Mafia | Endgame!

[Gaurav_7]

It is 3 actually.

Vote Count:

Spoobir (1) - Abhas
Abhas (3) - Spoobir, BKB1991, Highlander999
Riz7khan12 (1) - Ollie_H

With 12 alive it takes 7 for a lynch

 

[Chewie]

oops yes

----------

I've made heaps of mistakes with the vote count But I thought I should do it since User wasn't online

 

[Gaurav_7]

I haven't actually modded this one as I'd have liked to. Been busy sometimes or sick the other times. Should hopefully be more into this now. Chewie has been brilliant.

 

[simsanta123]

I really don't know who to believe. What about Spoobir also character claiming?

 

[Abhas]

Spoobir does make a very good point, it seems strange that as a survivor you'd try such a move like that. Where as being mafia it would be a good stunt to pull, as you could have though a few more might have jumped on you.

Also another thing is that MaD claimed survivor right, and since you weren't actually silenced, why didn't you counterclaim him saying you were the survivor?

1. Being a survivor is separate, being Abhas is a situation that's worse. If I'm alive after the first night, suspicion is already on me for being alive. I'm playing for the town, but I'm 100% sure there is little town support because they feel if I'm still alive after 3 nights, it means I'm mafia for sure.
I'm paying a price for being experienced.

By claiming Silenced, I could accomplish 2 things together -
1. Try to unsettle the mafia,
2. Show to the town that I was targeted.

Mafia know this fact very well that experienced players are bound to go early, look back at the thread, each day there has been a mention of this fact. They left me to live on purpose, so that they could lead a lynch on me, without being suspicious.

2. Regarding the reason why I did not counter-claim MaD, I was online before he had claimed survivor, and when I came back on, p# had counter-claimed as busdriver. This meant there was no need of me to counter claim, because he was getting lynched anyway. It also meant, there was a possibility that another mafia might claim survivor in the future, where I can counter-claim.
Also, posting then meant, breaking my silence, which would have been damn hard to explain. Especially to this lot, considering at the moment, it seems we are on a different wavelength altogether.

The reason why I want Spoobir lynched today is, so that the Cop can perform his duty easily. He has 1 less person to focus on. We also have the bus-driver tomorrow because he was role-blocked tonight. This means, we can play around with mafia's targets and try to attack the mafia itself.

If I live the day, the Mafia will definitely target me at night, that means the cop can do his job easily.

 

[Ollie_H]

I don't see how you could unsettle the mafia by 'silencing' yourself? It was just a bit of a silly play and wasn't really needed.

 

[Varun]

I'm confused between Abhas' and Ollie/BKB's arguments. One question I want to ask Abhas, you say by claiming as 'silenced', you could unsettle the mafia, what if there was a silencer indeed? (although we're almost sure there's none for there haven't been any other silenced players.) They'd surely know you were bluffing and then get you lynched. You claimed to be silenced, Abhas, but couldn't that have backfired on you instead if there was a silencer?

----------

*was really a silencer?

 

[simsanta123]

Yes, it seems like a weird ploy. Tbh both Spoobir and Abhas are looking scummy to me.

 

[Abhas]

If there was, do you think the real silencer would have come out in the open? Silencers are most likely to be mafia, anyone claiming that he did not silence me would have been suicidal.

----------

I agree what I did was unconventional to say the least, but trust me, there are numerous things pointing in his direction being the mafia.
Unless people comprehend what I did though, there is no point in putting up an argument.
Hindsight is a beautiful thing, but dwelling on what could have been only distracts from the present. I want you guys to look at everything from the "present tense", not the past tense.

 

[Ollie_H]

Okay, so lets dwell on the fact that you lied to everyone and then expect people to believe you? It's just such an unnecessary thing to do. There was no real reason to silence yourself, because I still don't get how it benefits anyone.

 

[Spoobir]

If there was, do you think the real silencer would have come out in the open? Silencers are most likely to be mafia, anyone claiming that he did not silence me would have been suicidal.

He wasn't saying the silencer would counter-claim you, he was saying the person who was actually silenced would counter-claim you. But obviously because you are mafia you knew that wouldn't happen...

Hindsight is a beautiful thing, but dwelling on what could have been only distracts from the present. I want you guys to look at everything from the "present tense", not the past tense.

Watch out! My meaningless bullshit meter is overloading!

 

[Varun]

He wasn't saying the silencer would counter-claim you, he was saying the person who was actually silenced would counter-claim you. But obviously because you are mafia you knew that wouldn't happen...

Exactly. And the mafia would just get rid of a well experienced player like Abhas pretty easily. Abhas, from how good a player he is, should have been well aware of this possibility, wouldn't he? Then why did he risk it?

I'm not exactly against anyone here, nor in the favour of anyone. I have my own doubts, and I am clearing them off to get a better observation of the game.

 

[Varun]

Ah, scanned the last few pages once again, and that makes me suspicious of Highlander. Zorax and him have exchanged a lot of banter, and if we read their exact conversation, it signals that they might be mafia partners. Also, Tom suggested that Mark could be the serial killer. Perhaps he is Mark himself, and I don't see why Mark would be a serial killer.

----------

FOS : Highlander.

 

[Abhas]

It is possible to have 2 silencers in a game. It is very much possible to have 2 people having the same role in a game. We've had 2 roleblockers, 2 double voters, 2 persuaders, among others.

Besides, since I wasn't actually silenced, if I believed someone else is silenced, and not posting due to that, I could have posted.
If I plan something, it's not set in stone, it is dynamic according to situation.

Clearly, had I wanted to continue lying about the silence, I could have, but since I had no malice, I admitted to lying.
Even after Ollie "exposed" me as he wants to say, there was no pressure on me to say that.

 

[CG123]

Well the last page or so hasn't got me any closer to deciding who I'll be lynching.

The safe bet (I'm not saying it's the smartest atm) would be just to go for Abhas, because I think we can be certain that he's not town. Then if he turns up survivor, we can then pursue Spoobir, otherwise if he turns up mafia, we can go from there.

The problem with that is that we're more than likely going to lose someone to poison tonight or tomorrow night, and on top of that the mafia have the possibility of killing others.

Just in terms of how they've posted over the last day, I'd be leaning towards Spoobir as mafia due to his more aggressive nature, but the actions of Abhas yesterday were just so strange, that it makes me want to lynch him.