I agree with your review. Batting is WAY too easy. Why, oh why did they not make it easy at the lower levels and challenging at test. In my third game at test level I scored 630-9 as England versus New Zealand in the World Cup Group game. Ridiculous.
Also generating innings produces ludicrous results and scores (ie New Zealand 427 all out, batting first in a World Cup Group match. In test matches I played Eng vs Australia and the AI generated a test match that was over in one day!
Also the wicketkeeper is a fool. His takes are absurd and completely unrealistic.
I am so annoyed that this game is virtually unplayable. BLC 2005 was almost there - it only needed a few tweaks - and they advertise this as being REALISTIC!?!?!?
I have not tried online play. Perhaps that is the sole bit of good news. Codemasters, you have spoilt my year.