Pokemon? Mafia - Endgame | Town (BKB1991/P Squared) wins!

[BKB1991]

I am suspicious of Simsanta too. But he hasnt posted much at all, and missed out when we were discussing whether to lynch the dead mafia, and that really is important in helping us decide his character. Hes simply been inactive at this point but with less members left its important that he needs to pick his activity up.

If he comes now, I would like to ask him on his thoughts, on who he thinks is mafia, and who is not.

 

[Near]

I find it highly suspicious.

Players with no role are very common in Mafia games.

It's a bizarre theory.

I wouldn't go so far as to say that you might be the Ditto and that it could link you to cult/anti town...yet. Cause you have P Squared backing your Metal Coat theory.

But it's interesting.

I don't know why its suspicious just because I put my thoughts down. I know its a bizarre theory, but everybody who claims vanilla is always suspicious in my eyes because that's a mafia's only claim. And in the two games I played I think I just saw one or two people with no roles at all

 

[ZoraxDoom]

I don't know why its suspicious just because I put my thoughts down. I know its a bizarre theory, but everybody who claims vanilla is always suspicious in my eyes because that's a mafia's only claim. And in the two games I played I think I just saw one or two people with no roles at all

Seriously? Vanilla Townie is highly common normally. A normal mafia game, if they had 4 mafia players, would probably have 1 cop, 1 doc, 2-3 other townie roles, and like 4 vanillas.

Your bizarre theory has little focus or basis on it. Seems very much like someone trying to shift attention onto a person/role that they may feel could be associated to them. A Freudian slip if you will. P_Squared has backed your claim so far, but I have seen Mafia double voters.

I'm suspicious. That's all.

 

[P Squared]

So I'm a mafia double voter now. Brilliant work guys.

----------

For those of you who don't understand I'll just add this smilie-


----------

I'd also like to add that sim is looking really suspicious right now and he should probably roleclaim to save himself.

 

[AfridiRulez]

Not much activity happening on the long weekend.

 

[CG123]

I am sure you are a townie. However, you seem to have a grudge against me. Once again, your attack doesn?t have solid backing.
You say I lynched you. I definitely did. That was before you were a confirmed townie. (and you had no evidence against me, so that defintely aroused my suspicion). Do you mean to say that everyone who has lynched you, ? a confirmed townie? is mafia. Ha Ha Ridiculous. Similarly, look when I lyched p# (another confimed townie?). Aray, Chewie, AfridiRulez, Ollie..Hedger All of them either lyched or were suspicious of him. Congratulations, you have just got your mafia. ?Cough Cough? Oh just remembered Aray, Ollie and Hedger are confirmed dead townies. There goes your logic.

How do I have a grudge against you? At this stage of the game lynching someone doesn't need solid backing. There's four people out there who I'm not sure about, and you've been the least helpful to the town out of them, and the second most inactive behind BKB. My lynch on you stays, as you've pretty much just attacked what I posted, and again posted nothing of substance. You not lynching any of the mafia players just adds to my suspicion on you, as Chewie and BKB both lynched them early.

My thoughts on my fellow players..
AfridiRulez- Most probably not Mafia. He was the one who first brought up Aditya's name, and if you think from a mafia perspective, that would be a stupid thing to do. I am not really sure about the cult's attitude towards mafia (enemy of enemy is friend?), so he could be cult/town.
Vedarshi- I am inclined to believe his roleclaim, unless fake role-claims were provided. So could be mafia/townie.
Spoobir- I strongly feel he is cult.
psquared- Nearly confirmed townie.
Callum- Nearly confirmed townie.
Zorax- Nearly confirmed townie.
P#- I wouldn't say much, cause Callum might jump on it again. I am still not very convinced about him.
Chewie- Not really sure, any which way.
MaD- Same as above. Nobody has properly attacked him. Could somebody spell out the reasons why they suspect MaD?

Re what you said about p#, that's the sort of not helpful stuff you've been saying.

I don't think you read over the thread as well, I've investigated both Vedarshi and p#, so bar something unusual happening which is possible, they're both town. MaD roleclaimed, which is now why he's in the clear. So from you perspective as you're saying you're town and Spoobir is cult, one or both of Chewie and BKB has to be mafia, of which you didn't even post about BKB, and you just said "Not really sure" about Chewie.

You lynching Spoobir and not putting any pressure on one of Chewie/BKB could be because you don't want to get their attention, as they're not currently suspicious of you, although I'm not really sure about that.

I'm just playing in the best interest of the town, so I hope you see where I'm coming from and don't just rubbish everything I say like you pretty much did before. As I said above, my lynch on you definitely stays.

He can check any line for truth. It's just that role claims are normally the easiest to check.

No, I can't check players alignments directly. Here's summery of what I've done:

Night 1 - Vedarshi - "i am butterfree" - True
Night 2 - Papa_Smurf - "I am Haunter" - Lie
Night 3 - Spoobir - "I am Gengar" - I couldn't use my role
Night 4 - p23456789 - "I am now Steelix" - True

So on night three I was either roleblocked, or Spoobir's telling the truth. I don't think we should kill Spoobir today anyway, even though I'm heavily suspicious of him, as I think we need to look at other players.

 

[MaD]

No not roleclaim, but I want BKB, Chewie and Sim to all character claim

----------

It's highly likely you were roleblocked because that's exactly what Varun said to me last night when I was roleblocked.
The roleblocker could also potentially be cult aligned, no reason why he wouldn't.

 

[CG123]

What did he say exactly to you, like the quote?

(We might as well make sure)

----------

Also P Squared might as well character claim as well, as we know he's the double voter.

I'm still not sure on whether it's the best tactic for everyone to character claim atm, I would have liked to have waited another day, but with it down to four of which two/three of them are going to be anti-town, it's probably best they do now. Of course one of them's going to be be you know who, so that will mean it's down to three players, of which two or if not all of them are anti-town.

So yeah, it might be best if everyone character claims now.

 

[Chewie]

What did he say exactly to you, like the quote?

(We might as well make sure)

----------

Also P Squared might as well character claim as well, as we know he's the double voter.

I'm still not sure on whether it's the best tactic for everyone to character claim atm, I would have liked to have waited another day, but with it down to four of which two/three of them are going to be anti-town, it's probably best they do now. Of course one of them's going to be be you know who, so that will mean it's down to three players, of which two or if not all of them are anti-town.

So yeah, it might be best if everyone character claims now.

'You know who'? Not HP mafia

I'm Ditto. I don't mind role claiming too if you want. Though you can probably guess what my role would be.

 

[MaD]

We can't quote the Pm but he said I couldn't use my role last night

 

[CG123]

'You know who'? Not HP mafia

Pikachu...

We can't quote the Pm but he said I couldn't use my role last night

Yeah, he said the same thing to me.

 

[Chewie]

Thinking about it, character claiming might not be the best idea, because for some pokemon it is extremely obvious as to what they are. For example, no one's claimed Chansey yet, and I don't really want them to claim that...

 

[Near]

Yeah true. But I do want to hear Sim's claim though, he did say he has no role at this point

EDIT: *night role

 

[CG123]

Here's what I got atm:

MaD - Charizard
p23456789 - Steelix
Vedarshi - Butterfree
Afridirulez - ???
Chewie - Ditto
CG123 - Alakazam
Zoraxdoom - Dragonite
Spoobir - Gengar
P_Squared - Double voter
BKB1991 - ???
Simsanta123 - ???

So assuming at least one of the three people remaining are mafia, they're going to have a one in two chance of finding Pikachu/Chansey, so we might as well just put everyone out in the open, and try and find a mafia today.

----------

Looking at that I think one of the claims atm is fake as well, just putting it out there. As we've only found two mafia, and you think there's going to be at least two more, so if there's also Pikachu and Chansey it doesn't add up. Plus if there is a cult, that means someone else has faked as well, so there's potentially two fake claims currently.

 

[Near]

Hmm, No Mewtwo yet. Chances are he will be the cult leader as he hated both Team Rocket and the good pokemon

EDIT: Mewtwo should be in the game, right?