Puddle Mafia 02 - Game over - Sedition wins - 3rd Party Win

[Themer]

So we know that there's definitely a DV then.

 

[puddleduck]

Night 1

The day passed in a hurry. He had always looked out for himself. His parents had died when he was young and he'd learnt from an early age to survive. His nonchalance with regards to his direction was betrayed by the town's existing fears. He had hoped to find new friends within the turmoil, but instead he was reunited with his family.

In death he would prove more useful than he'd ever been in life. The reward for his early demise was the potentially priceless comodity known as information. As the sun settled down to sleep, the town of Duckton now breathed into life. The pages of the story were still blank, the paper dry, but the ink was wet with anticipation.

Spoiler

BKB1991 is dead. He was Survivor - 3rd Party Aligned.

It is now Night 1. Please submit your night roles. You have 24 hours.

 

[Abhas]

God that was really quick. Can't understand what caused such a sudden lynch.
A survivor is not anti-town. He's just a different alignment who wins with either of the town or the mafia.
That was poor play from the town really.

 

[puddleduck]

Pretty sure I've had everything submitted. Just got back from work. Will sort out role results PMs and get the writeup done and we'll get back into day

 

[puddleduck]

Day 2

Life had been tough. The money had never made it any easier. He had appreciated her on more than a few occassions, and in his employment she had served him well. Again he sent her out into the night, and again she found a payday.

His years of service had given him plenty of contacts. He began his investigations without haste.

He saw plenty of activity outside his target's residence, but nothing that he could make sense of. He was skilled at remaining unseen, but tonight was as fruitless as a bad harvest.

He had a plan, but in the end pleasure took precedent.

He was important to this town. People listened to him. His voice carried twice the weight of many of the other residents. His family had always had connections and he had inherited them. It was his vote that had secured the death of the loner. He knew he could be vital to the future of Duckton, that he could maintain the balance against mounting odds. During the security of day he was king, but with the absence of light he was just another pawn. He made his way out of the office blocks that contained the family business and prepared to head back to his riverside penthouse flat. He entered his personalised Ferrari Enzo and settled in for a thrilling ride home. His foot pressed down on the accelerator and the circuit was complete. He had been important to this town, his voice though was now silent.

Spoiler

Papa Smurf is dead. He was Double Voter - Town Aligned

It is now Day 2, with 7 alive it takes 4 to lynch.

 

[Papa_Smurf]

That sucks.

 

[puddleduck]

I might want either you or BKB to sub in for Yoki if possible. The guy hasn't responded to my Pm's and I'm not entirely sure he has any idea what he's doing Anyone ever played with him before?

 

[Papa_Smurf]

Has he posted yet?

 

[Sedition]

God that was really quick. Can't understand what caused such a sudden lynch.
A survivor is not anti-town. He's just a different alignment who wins with either of the town or the mafia.
That was poor play from the town really.

Easy to say when he was confirmed Survivor by the time you arrived. I'll make that lynch every time on Day 1 with very little other information.

Life had been tough. The money had never made it any easier. He had appreciated her on more than a few occassions, and in his employment she had served him well. Again he sent her out into the night, and again she found a payday.

His years of service had given him plenty of contacts. He began his investigations without haste.

He saw plenty of activity outside his target's residence, but nothing that he could make sense of. He was skilled at remaining unseen, but tonight was as fruitless as a bad harvest.

He had a plan, but in the end pleasure took precedent.

1. Prostitute, mafia roleblocker.
2. Cop.
3. Watcher with some results it seems, though not conclusive, so I guess Smurf wasn't the one being watched.
4. Someone blocked by the mafia roleblocker. Probably the doctor since it's not mentioned this time.

----------

and if the doc knows he was blocked, it'd probably be a good idea to claim since the mafia know who you are and will likely target you tonight. Since it seems we have a watcher, they can offer some protection.

 

[puddleduck]

Has he posted yet?

He hasn't posted, but he did confirm by PM but then didn't post in the thread like I asked him to. Hence I haven't answered your PM question yet

If he hasn't posted by tomorrow are you happy to sub in for him? Even if he knows how to play, his inactivity will annoy me a lot

 

[BKB1991]

If Smurf hasnt called dibs, I wont mind subbing in. I have some unresolved business with some people here

 

[puddleduck]

Ha, yeah sure. Will give Yoki until tomorrow when I finish work, and if Smurf doesn't want to sub in that would be appreciated thanks dude. Will give Smurf first dibs just because he hasn't played in a while.

 

[Sedition]

Good thing we have an inactive player, otherwise we'd have nothing to talk about.

 

[Abhas]

Easy to say when he was confirmed Survivor by the time you arrived. I'll make that lynch every time on Day 1 with very little other information.

What would lynching a known non-mafia do to help the town?
I dont know what people think here, but by my reckoning, a survivor can very very rarely 'side' with the mafia. It is helpful to remember he doesn't know the mafia members, and even if he is analytical enough to guess the members early on, he doesn't have any guarantee that the mafia won't kill him off.

Of the people that lynched bkb, I'm confident there is at least 1 mafia. We know smurf was the DV, so that leaves 3 people:

FOS: Themer, Sedition, Zhuorb

Just to pressure one of the these,
Lynch: Zhuorb

Let's wait to see if the cop or anyone else has any result.

 

[Sedition]

A known non-mafia? So you just 100% believed his claim no question? Maybe we should have just let him hang around until endgame, where he doesn't care if he lynches town. His reasons for claiming were to avoid being night killed by the mafia anyway, so he's just putting the target back on another town.

Like I said, it's easy to say what we should have done when he's now confirmed as survivor. Your reaction to us taking out the 3rd party on a day that usually ends with a no-lynch is pretty dodgy from where I sit. I consider it a good result.