Puddle Mafia 03 - Endgame

[BKB1991]

Agree with Sedition, its more likely that the years of training means doctor. I am not entirely convinced on the busdriver despite pointing out the theory myself. Agreed with Colin, lynching User is absolutely foolish for us right now. We are basically letting the mafia pass.

What are your hunches on people, Colin and Sedition? You two are probably the best players so I would like to hear what you guys think

Btw prostitute is the RB for mafia right?

----------

Oh and Abhas is also online, waiting to see if he comes up with some revelation

 

[Abhas]

Much has already been analyzed from the writeup,
In summary, I feel there's a mafia roleblocker, the training thing probably refers to the doc. Last one definitely nothing but Manly being killed by the godfather. (The eyes of the devil unblinking as the first steps into ordered chaos began.) This tells us it's mafia who killed him, not a SK, so that would mean User indeed was telling the truth about his role (unless he doesn't have a kill on all nights).

He slunk around, at home as he always was when day went to rest. He had his target in mind, but confusion instead veiled his eyes.

Not convinced with the day-cop or day role theory completely. A tracker or watcher wouldn't normally be at home.. Not sure, because definitely there's something I'm missing here. Maybe there's an implication of a paranoid/naive/etc type of role?

Successful indeed. Depending on who you work for.

This however is the worrying part for me. I feel, depending on who you work for implies an individual inclined, much like what User had claimed, but what would a survivor be successful about at night? And, that too, relative to his allegiance?

 

[barmyarmy]

What are your hunches on people, Colin and Sedition? You two are probably the best players so I would like to hear what you guys think

Flattery will get you nowhere. Too early to get proper reads and hunches can be dangerous on day 2. Either you get it wrong and misdirect people or you get it right and become a mafia target
I prefer to operate in broader strokes for now.

Btw prostitute is the RB for mafia right?

Yes.

 

[Sedition]

Yeah I'm hesitant to potentially waste a day on a lynch we probably should have made yesterday. While the chances of User being mafia are low, we're at least certain that he's not town. If it turns out that there is a SK on the loose and it's not User, we can't just lynch him off then either. I can't believe we let him survive Day 1 honestly But for now we can't compound the error, so moving on somewhat..

My suspicions were mostly on BKB and Zhuorb on Day 1 for being uncertain on the lynch, but looking back BKB is more active than I expect him to be when mafia. That leaves Zhuorb and a couple of posts that have caught my eye:

I'd lynch User2010 tomorrow if we don't have anything to go on, because survivors can be potentially dangerous later in the game, I believe.

I don't really understand this reasoning. Seems like a delay tactic, help User get through Day 1 and waste Day 2 lynching him, or help him get through again.

There's a bus driver, a roleblocker and some sort of town PR indicated in the write-up. A third party role cannot be counted out, though.
Lynch: pallu
Just to get the day rolling. I'm never in favor of people lurking around and doing nothing.
I'd lynch User if everyone agrees, though.

Any time there's a significant delay in getting through the night phase, I generally blame inactive/new players for not submitting their role. It could be that he has a mafia role, but in the past the mafia team has been able to submit it.

Since it's been obvious that he's needed replacing, I don't understand why you'd be so quick to go after him today when Manly's pretty much ready to come back in.

And then there's still 1 player we've got absolutely nothing on. Nothing from Mark on Day 1, and while it's thedon's first game and he's still trying to figure the game out, we can't just let him fly under the radar for a few days.

 

[puddleduck]

Vote Count

User (1) - Zhuorb

With 10 alive it takes 6 to lynch.

 

[Sedition]

A lot of ugly, ugly, quiet faces in here Not a lot of stones being thrown around, but I guess with 2 players that we don't have much on, it's a little difficult.

How are you coping with the game Don? Following the basic idea?

Is Manly coming in for Pallu soon?

Also I think the vote is:

Pallu (1) - Zhuorb
User2010 (1) - Aditya

 

[thedon5]

Still learning, but I do have a decent grasp of the game. Better than pallu.

 

[Varun]

I agree with Sedition on Zhuorb. Although I'd keep pallu around if I was mafia, the only two people Zhuorb seems inclined to lynch right now is pallu and User, which IMO must be a last resort for the day if we have nothing to go on. I see no reason we should be lynching them so early in the day.

I was actually suspicious of Manly on Day 1 but since he was the DV so whatever. Sedition is giving strong town vibes though. Abhas leaning town. Given how well they can disguise themselves, still won't completely trust them. Colin and BKB not so sure. Zhuorb always acts suspiciously and rashly I guess. Null read on TheDon and pallu for obvious reasons. User, well, has yet to post, but it's likely he's survivor.

 

[barmyarmy]

I'm still suspicious of Aditya but, in the interests of getting this game moving, lynch: Zhuorb.

 

[puddleduck]

Vote Count

Pallu (1) - Zhuorb
User2010 (1) - Aditya
Zhuorb (1) - Barmyarmy

With 10 alive it takes 6 to lynch.

Ta Sedition

 

[thedon5]

I wasn't convinced by his replies in the previous page, so Lynch: Aditya.

 

[puddleduck]

Vote Count

Pallu (1) - Zhuorb
User2010 (1) - Aditya
Zhuorb (1) - Barmyarmy
Aditya (1) - thedon

With 10 alive it takes 6 to lynch.

Ta Sedition

 

[ved_]

Unlynch: pallu
I don't see why User2010 has not posted after Night 1. He was taking part in the previous day's discussion. More like he has now got a free ticket?
Sedition is definitely town though, I believe. Aditya is like his usual self, making long posts which make neither head or tail to me. I feel thedon5's first post into the day, lynching Aditya is more town than mafia, so I'll let hi off the hook for now.
What's helping you by lynching me, barmyarmy? I don't see how it moves the game along.
My role is sort of a tricky one, so I believe I'll just go on and claim it. It kind of confirms that there is a cop, and atleast it will help me somewhat later if the cop gets a guilty report on me. I am the miller, town aligned. So, there is definitely a cop in this setup.

 

[Aditya]

@Don - Not convinced by my replies? At least I'm replying, some aren't.

@Zhourb - You say, my posts neither make head or tail to you, which basically suggests that they haven't been of a great use. Apart from this, you support the don's move to lynch me however you yourself don't lynch me. Might wanna explain this? In other words, how is the don's first post in the day makes him town?

----------

In other words, how is the don's first post in the day lynching me, makes him town?

----------

I mean, makes him more town than mafia.

 

[Gaurav_7]

Guys, that success and depending on who you work for might be me. Success might mean that I survived!

Now, again look at Aditya's post above. Don just sus'd him and he posts how is he more town than mafia..

Does it mean he can't sus you?

I am sure Aditya is one of the mafias if he proves otherwise.

Lynch: Aditya