Puddle Mafia 03 - Endgame

[Aditya]

Alright, I seriously can't take this any more. Go with your gut feeling guys, I've lynched User and no one else apart from Zhourb (has done anything at all suspicious).

 

[Varun]

My role is sort of a tricky one, so I believe I'll just go on and claim it. It kind of confirms that there is a cop, and atleast it will help me somewhat later if the cop gets a guilty report on me. I am the miller, town aligned. So, there is definitely a cop in this setup.

Since when Miller became a tricky role?

----------

Guys, that success and depending on who you work for might be me. Success might mean that I survived!

Still makes no sense.

Something tells me Aditya and Zhuorb aren't partners so I'd assume if one is mafia, the other isn't (of course, it may be that both aren't). Aditya has seemed more scummy than Zhuorb.

 

[thedon5]

In other words, how is the don's first post in the day lynching me, makes him town?

How does it not make me town?

Still not at all convinced by your posts, especially your insistence on lynching User so early in the day.

Agree with Varun that Aditya is looking very scummy.

 

[Varun]

It doesn't do anything for now. Neither makes you town nor mafia. We don't know what is Adi's alignment, and above all a post or two doesn't guarantee anything.

----------

Especially since you're new.

 

[barmyarmy]

Zhuorb as miller? High chance of a CC so risky claim for a mafia but also the only claim to make had the cop investigated him.

Haven't seen much of Abhas recently...

 

[thedon5]

It doesn't do anything for now. Neither makes you town nor mafia. We don't know what is Adi's alignment, and above all a post or two doesn't guarantee anything.

----------

Especially since you're new.

I was asking for a response from him as to why I would not be town.

 

[Sedition]

Unlynch: pallu
I don't see why User2010 has not posted after Night 1. He was taking part in the previous day's discussion. More like he has now got a free ticket?
Sedition is definitely town though, I believe. Aditya is like his usual self, making long posts which make neither head or tail to me. I feel thedon5's first post into the day, lynching Aditya is more town than mafia, so I'll let hi off the hook for now.
What's helping you by lynching me, barmyarmy? I don't see how it moves the game along.
My role is sort of a tricky one, so I believe I'll just go on and claim it. It kind of confirms that there is a cop, and atleast it will help me somewhat later if the cop gets a guilty report on me. I am the miller, town aligned. So, there is definitely a cop in this setup.

Kind of annoyed at your premature claim if it's true. I'm not convinced since I feel any non-PR should stay quiet about their role and attempt to draw the mafia's sights, but it's a risky play coming so early when you could easily be CC'd. The fact that you've claimed early like this in the past when town strengthens it somewhat, but maybe you realised this and took the risk.

One possible way to confirm is if we have a tracker, we can make sure Zhuorb isn't venturing out at night, whether tonight or tomorrow night just to keep him on his toes. If we don't, then at least we can make him nervous and re-evaluate later.

As for Aditya, I guess I haven't paid much attention to him since he was on with the survivor/whatever lynch, but he has seemed a bit eccentric at times. In the past I've mistaken that sort of play as bad mafia, but usually ends up being paranoid town, so I'm not too sure. Little bit suspicious of thedon and User moving in quickly for the lynch on the other hand.

and yeah haven't heard much from Abhas today, and still nothing on the Pallu/Manly situation.

 

[ved_]

Manly is viewing this thread so I assume he has replaced pallu.

Aditya, your post immediately counter-attacks me. I don't find that something extremely towny. You seem to be afraid that we're inching closer towards you. I'd rather believe you're mafia if you don't do anything helpful.

What I said, thedon5 is town because he came into the day with a lynch. What kind of mafia would just come in and lynch someone, bringing immediate attention on himself?

I claimed because I'm pretty sure the cop will investigate me tonight. I'm un-counter claimed till now, so that confirms me as miller.

FOS:Aditya

Abhas needs to come back and say something. Also, I feel that we should be mass-claiming tomorrow, just to narrow down on the mafia.

 

[Aditya]

Again, Zhourb's claim hasn't come at the right time. Questioning Colin about lynching him and then in the same post, role claiming. I actually see him under pressure. If he is indeed Miller, why didn't he claim on day 1 and clear all the doubts about whether or not this game has a cop or not.

 

[barmyarmy]

I agree with sedition; it can be annoying when players claim with just one or two lynches on them. In some mafia versions you can't claim until you have a certain number of lynches. To me it should come after an explanation of why you're not scummy, why your play has helped the town and what your take on the other players is. Claiming should be a last resort regardless of role.

 

[Aditya]

Oh yes, I am afraid that you guys are after me. TBH, I don't really bother because you guys clearly have got not a single substantiated evidence against me and hence I wouldn't really bother putting forward a defense. All that nonsense about my long posts, my aggressiveness towards User and how I've questioned you stating that the don's first post in the day lynching me makes him look more townie than mafia, if all these points make you lynch me then go ahead because to me, it sounds absolutely non substantiated.

In earlier games, I've been too defensive and that hasn't gone in my favor. In this one I'll just play it cool.

----------

Why is it so, that in this game I'm basically agreeing with whatever Colin is posting? I don't don't like this..

 

[barmyarmy]

I claimed because I'm pretty sure the cop will investigate me tonight.

This bothers me a bit. Why do you think you were an obvious target to be investigated? How do you know you haven't been investigated already?

----------

Why is it so, that in this game I'm basically agreeing with whatever Colin is posting? I don't don't like this..

Basically I post sense. You can be a very paranoid townie so always difficult to tell which side you're on.

 

[Varun]

Not sure if Zhuorb is a silly townie, or an even more silly mafia. I don't think much of what he has said makes sense. He might be desperate, but I don't see any reason why he'd need to be.

 

[Manly]

@Zhuorb post 248: Not yet mate.

 

[puddleduck]

Manly you up for subbing in dude? I have spoken to Pallu and he's happy to sub out and is sorry he doesn't get the game enough to play

Will send you the PM anyway, and you can just start posting if and when you're ready

----------

Vote Count

User2010 (1) - Aditya
Zhuorb (1) - Barmyarmy
Aditya (2) - thedon, User

With 10 alive it takes 6 to lynch.