Puddle Mafia 03 - Endgame

[ved_]

Unlynch:Sedition

 

[thedon5]

I shouldn't have said day 1, I wasn't active on day 1, I only came in on day 2.

His latest post is further proof that he is Mafia though. If he wasn't suspicious on day 1, why would Barmy have switched him? Also this insistence that BKB's night 1 investigation was wrong is a bit weird to me. Am I the only one who is entertaining the possibility that his investigation was right and that Sedition is Mafia?

 

[ved_]

Town drunk is a legitimate role, it is on epicmafia. Maybe the role blocker on the night write-ups is the town drunk?
Also, seeing as how almost everyone as claimed, can you claim too, thedon5? Varun also has to claim.

 

[thedon5]

Unlynch:Sedition

Any reasoning?

 

[ved_]

The bomb claim. I guess it is legitimate.

 

[thedon5]

How do you reach this conclusion exactly..?

 

[ved_]

His soft-claiming cop, I believe.

 

[thedon5]

Hell, if you guys are scared of placing the hammer on him, I'll do it. By all means.

 

[Sedition]

I wasn't convinced by his replies in the previous page, so Lynch: Aditya.

Vote Count

User2010 (1) - Aditya
Zhuorb (2) - Barmyarmy, Abhas
Aditya (3) - thedon, User, BKB

With 10 alive it takes 6 to lynch.

Just seen the vote count so I'm going to apply some gentle pressure:

Lynch: Aditya

There's your scum right there. Thedon starts the day with a lynch on Aditya for something in the previous day and no analysis or reason whatsoever. User follows it up and we know he's a potentially volatile 3rd party at this point. BKB comes in so there's one town we know. Then Manly adding the 4th vote when it takes 6 to lynch.. if people were thinking that me, Abhas and Varun were all mafia, then that's some pretty crazy town play going on there..

Thedon can be somewhat explained away as being new, but I would still like to put his claim to the test if he's going to lynch me. And if Varun thinks another investigative role is being referred to, then what were those results if it wasn't BKB?

 

[ved_]

You've already voted him, though.

 

[Aditya]

His latest post is further proof that he is Mafia though. If he wasn't suspicious on day 1, why would Barmy have switched him? Also this insistence that BKB's night 1 investigation was wrong is a bit weird to me. Am I the only one who is entertaining the possibility that his investigation was right and that Sedition is Mafia?

Colin being a townie doesn't justify his action or in other words, it does not indicate that if he switched Sedition on night 1, it by any chance makes him mafia. No, BKB's investigation can well be right and Sedition can indeed be mafia but I'm just putting forward my perspective because the way, you're looking at the game isn't right. Colin perhaps switched me with someone on night 2, does that indicate that I'm mafia! Sedition and I were very aggressive towards User on day 1 and Colin wasn't hence he may have felt that one of us is guilty and therefore used his role upon us. You're looking upon one perspective, that is believing BKB, I'm looking upon several other.

My point is, don't be in a hurry. I'd prefer Varun and BKB to be online and post their final thoughts on the current situation.

 

[thedon5]

Colin being a townie doesn't justify his action or in other words, it does not indicate that if he switched Sedition on night 1, it by any chance makes him mafia. No, BKB's investigation can well be right and Sedition can indeed be mafia but I'm just putting forward my perspective because the way, you're looking at the game isn't right. Colin perhaps switched me with someone on night 2, does that indicate that I'm mafia!

No, but seeing as IIRC you guys established that Sedition was switched with you on night 2, it would make sense that Barmy would have switched someone he thought was suspicious on night 1 as well. Chances are that is what happened. Sedition was not very suspicious on day 1 from what I gather, so there's a good chance that he was indeed not switched.

Also his claim of bomb is a good one for a Mafia to make, it's worked if you take a look, you were unsure on whether to hammer him and chances are the others felt the same as well.

Sedition and I were very aggressive towards User on day 1 and Colin wasn't hence he may have felt that one of us is guilty and therefore used his role upon us. You're looking upon one perspective, that is believing BKB, I'm looking upon several other.

My point is, don't be in a hurry. I'd prefer Varun and BKB to be online and post their final thoughts on the current situation.

Sure, they should be online in five or six hours, that seems to be the time when everyone is online.

Anyway my opinion is well known, I'll wait to see what others think. As I said I'm more than happy to place the hammer on him if need be.

 

[Varun]

Sedition is mafia for sure. Bomb is a last minute getaway to avoid a lynch.

If Sedition is hammered before I come on, I need Aditya to protect me at all costs. I am the cop and I can possibly clear one more person out. If I die that means Aditya was lying, because like I have mentioned there has been no sign of the doctor in the write up.

If only Sedition turns out to be the roleblocker. Otherwise it's so easy to block Aditya and kill you. We don't have Colin to switch, and I don't believe Manly at all, because Town Drunk seems very similar to a roleblocker.

I'm not the tracker/watcher, though I thought there was one in the game. I'm the Bulletproof Townie, so I have a one shot night kill protection in the form of a 'bulletproof vest'. In a two-killers game that makes sense I guess.

I'm convinced Sedition is mafia (given there is no tracker, the ambiguity in the writeups has lessened for me). The only thing that worries me though, is that he might be a Mafia Bomb instead of Town Bomb. Nevertheless, Lynch: Sedition.

I don't know if the SK targeted me on Night 1; if yes, then my bulletproof vest would be used up. But I don't think that's likely.

@BKB - The doc hasn't been blatantly confirmed to be there, but the clues in the writeup point towards the doc being there. So, I believe Aditya is town.

Zhuorb I have no option but to believe town. So logically if there is a last mafia, it is either Manly or thedon and correspondingly the other one must be mafia. I wonder if there's a town/individual convertible to mafia like the last game though. BKB and Aditya must not be, so there is a chance Zhuorb might be.

Also, PD, I feel User should be modkilled here. I know he's in a bad time, but it would be funny if he wins alone or something.

----------

Since you're the only one left to claim, I feel you should claim too thedon.

 

[thedon5]

Unlynch: Sedition

Whoever is scared that Sedition is the bomb can place their lynch now and I'll place the hammer. Easy as.

I'm the last one left to claim, but I don't believe that it would help our cause at this stage. I'll by all means claim on day 4 if need be, but unless more people than just you and Sedition want me to claim, then maybe I'll consider it. The way I see it, me claiming won't advance us in any way as we already know that lynching Sedition is the job for today. It won't help us gain any more knowledge.

 

[Varun]

It helps us consider the possibility whether you are mafia/SK or not, depending on your claim.

----------

His soft-claiming cop, I believe.

He did? Only Abhas pointed that out I guess.