Puddle Mafia 03 - Endgame

[BKB1991]

I know you posted this somewhere Varun, can I know where? I will actually give it a shot and see if i follow

 

[thedon5]

Time to come open then. I am the cop, and I was roleblocked. I investigated Sedition on night 1 and he came mafia. Hence, I was pressing for his lynch. The fact that Colin, a known townie should also confirm it.

Defence please Sedition. Lynch: Sedition

This sealed it, Sedition is Mafia.

He got a positive result on night one obviously since Sedition was indeed Mafia, no other explanation for me, this discussion about what happened with Colin in night one is too open to interpretation and going nowhere.

Am getting suspicious of you too Varun.

 

[ved_]

I'm trying to use the writeup to deduce whether he was actually switched by Colin or not, or what are the chances of that. Don't know why it is really difficult to follow. You're not able to comprehend it, and Zhuorb is getting sick of all this (like he always does). I believe I'm the only one trying to analyze things besides Sedition, and yet the suspicion will come on me especially if Sedition turns out mafia.

I'm actually sick, not getting sick of this.

 

[BKB1991]

haha Zhuorb

Before we nail down Sedition, I still like to hear from Manly. Hes been too quiet and just biding his time

 

[Varun]

http://www.planetcricket.org/forums...mafia-03-day-3-game-81574-31.html#post2397178

From here, BKB.

Ironically, I'm getting suspicious of you, thedon. You've become unusually desperate in your last few posts, compared to earlier in the game.

lol sorry Zhuorb.

 

[thedon5]

http://www.planetcricket.org/forums...mafia-03-day-3-game-81574-31.html#post2397178

From here, BKB.

Ironically, I'm getting suspicious of you, thedon. You've become unusually desperate in your last few posts, compared to earlier in the game.

lol sorry Zhuorb.

Easy explanation. It's 2:30 am here, I'm almost certain that Sedition is mafia so before I go to bed I want everyone else to believe the same. I don't want to come back when I wake up and see we've deviated off track or anything.

I would obviously not be this desperate if it was 2:30 pm or something.

Manly is delay after delay and anyway looks to be the SK. I want us to lynch Sedition this round and then we can look at Manly.

----------

Also there is every chance that if Manly is the SK that he is indeed just a normal SK and that pallu didn't know what to do on the first night or something.

 

[Manly]

I am home! Just need to finish this bowel evacuation and start the laptop up.

 

[thedon5]

Great. Make it quick, I'm bloody tired!

 

[Manly]

This is PD's third game and both of his previous games had a SK. They were 9 player setups and on this occasion we have 11. PD also said that he might have to rebalance since not all 11 of us were active in the beginning, which suggests to me that it was turning scum sided when I was MIA, Mark dropped out and pallu wasn't sure how to play.

Most games have only had 7 or 9 players starting, so the extra players are one reason why we haven't made as much progress as usual, but as I said, I feel there must be multiple factions with differing agendas operating here and that's why we can't reach any kind of consensus.. except for those forcing the doc claim out of Aditya.

The mafia don't know what other roles exists besides the doc, and if the SK is in this game, there's a good chance he hasn't figured out the mafia either and could potentially take one out for us. The temptation to kill will be great tonight after not doing so last night, so that's another reason why I'm suspicious of Barmy suggesting that he should be protected tonight, which potentially leaves 2 people wide open.

Despite this game already going for a month, we're only on Day 2 with 10 players left and it's too early to try to formulate a plan with so many unconfirmed players and roles. If our roles stay hidden for now, the mafia don't know which targets take priority and the chances of us catching at least 1 scum tonight are fairly high. Once we gather more info, then I think we can narrow things down considerably tomorrow.

If our PRs get results tonight, then a massclaim tomorrow could be smart no? There is potential for one depending on our results and what clues we can gather from the write-ups. Speaking of the write-ups..



This line almost certainly refers to the doc, and if you were the one Aditya protected, then it being "misplaced" just casts further doubt on you in my mind.

Not at all convinced that at this stage of the game a mass RC would have been beneficial to the town.

Vote Count

Sedition (2) - Barmyarmy, BKB
User2010 (1) - Abhas
BKB (2) - Aditya, thedon
Varun (1) - Zhuorb

With 10 alive it takes 6 to lynch.

There are a couple of hours left in the day.

Extension can be requested, but more than likely going to go to night as game doesn't look too close to going to a majority.

I'm fairly sure BKB is town, and with what we must assume barmy knew, this makes me think that Sedition is maf.

http://www.planetcricket.org/forums...mafia-03-day-3-game-81574-31.html#post2397178

From here, BKB.

Ironically, I'm getting suspicious of you, thedon. You've become unusually desperate in your last few posts, compared to earlier in the game.

lol sorry Zhuorb.

Yeah I'm not sure this suspicion has any grounding to be honest, I understand I've been pretty poor at keeping my activity up, just had other stuff getting in my way to be honest. I look at my phone and this thread specifically on my phone, but playing along with a keyboard on a screen is pretty much impossible.

Also, there's a prostitute for the mafia, which is basically the roleblocker you're all going on about.

----------

Ooops. Lynch: Sedition

----------

Has my post disappeared for anyone else?

 

[thedon5]

Yeah that's another thing. During their bid argument in the second day, I was thinking that one of Sedition and Colin is Mafia. I was completely neutral on both, but Colin proving to be town, BKB's investigation and Sedition's replies in day 3 making no sense lead me to believe he is almost certainly Mafia.

Bed time gentlemen, hope to see Sedition lynched by tomorrow. That's Manly, Zhuorb and myself, plus BKB will surely put his lynch back onto him. Varun is the other who is suspicious of him so should put in a lynch too, not to mention others who may come in.

Also I'm pretty much certain BKB and probably Aditya are town too. Zhuorb most likely as well. Varun is leaning Mafia for me. I have very little read on User for obvious reasons, and Manly too.

----------

@Manly: Nope, you double posted. You must have refreshed or something, whenever I refresh in PC after making a reply my reply disappears.

 

[thedon5]

Also, another thing about the Mafia, if BKB got blocked on Night 2, then who got blocked on Night 1? It was pretty clear in the write-up that the prostitute was successful in Night 1, so perhaps the Mafia know two of our power roles?

 

[BKB1991]

They could have simply blocked a person without a role.

Aditya for confirmations sake, I believe you protected Colin on night 1 and sedition on night 2 right?

----------

Also looking back at it there is no gurantee that there is a doctor in the game. The more I read from it, it seems like we have a tracker/watcher and me. No indication of protection. And I havent seen Aditya post as well in a while.

Sedition, I need a claim from you. Otherwise I am hammering you.

----------

Is User still playing?

 

[Aditya]

@BKB - Yes, I protected Colin on night 1 and Sedition on night 2.

TBH, I'm very confused as of now. Sedition's defense is weak and as much as I would like to believe BKB, he too at times has looked suspicious (at least to me, if you see the discussion on day 2). However, I'd be more than happy to go with the majority.

 

[ved_]

Why hasn't Sedition claimed yet?

 

[Sedition]

I went to bed with only 2 votes on me, but I have to claim if you guys are going to blindly lynch me off and BKB hammers.

I'm the Bomb, town aligned. My killer dies with me if they target me at night or hammer my lynch, so obviously having BKB or Aditya hammering leaves us up the creek, especially if the SK is able to kill again tonight.

I've been softclaiming cop and hinted at two cops at various points in an attempt to draw the mafia's sights, rather than some people who claim these roles on Day 1 or Day 2 and hand PR's over to the mafia. But with my cover now blown and no BD to redirect the kill onto me, you might aswell lynch me and have whoever you think is scum hammer it.

Given that Manly continually ****s up his claims when mafia, it would be worth having him claim before deciding whether he or someone else does the honours.