Puddle Mafia 03 - Endgame

[puddleduck]

Vote Count

Sedition (3) - Zhuorb, thedon, Manly
Manly (1) - BKB


With 8 alive it takes 5 to lynch.

 

[BKB1991]

Not surprised at your claim. Not convincing imo. Lynch: Sedition

----------

Unlynch: Manly
Lynch: Sedition

----------

hmm, guys should we hear Manlys claim too? Think we should, and then see accordingly.

If Sedition is hammered before I come on, I need Aditya to protect me at all costs. I am the cop and I can possibly clear one more person out. If I die that means Aditya was lying, because like I have mentioned there has been no sign of the doctor in the write up.

 

[thedon5]

Yeah I don't believe his claim either.

He is scum. Clear as day.

 

[Manly]

I'm the town drunk, received my role (which I think it's best to withhold until at least the next Day), last Night, and the very last paragraph referring to 'sobering' is me.


Interestingly, I am foooooooooking sloshed right now.

 

[thedon5]

Is there such a thing as town drunk in Mafia?

 

[BKB1991]

Never heard of it. Another person who seems to be lying. Personally, I think hes the SK

 

[thedon5]

Never heard of bomb either.

Furthermore, IIRC Sedition was the one trying to link the roles in this game to the roles in PD's previous games. There wasn't a bomb in either of PD's previous games, so it's a bad lie from him.

Whoever has to place the hammer, don't be afraid, you won't die, he is lying.

Who will you be investigating tonight BKB?

 

[puddleduck]

Vote Count

Sedition (4) - Zhuorb, thedon, Manly, BKB



With 8 alive it takes 5 to lynch.

 

[Sedition]

Never heard of bomb either.

Furthermore, IIRC Sedition was the one trying to link the roles in this game to the roles in PD's previous games. There wasn't a bomb in either of PD's previous games, so it's a bad lie from him.

Whoever has to place the hammer, don't be afraid, you won't die, he is lying.

Who will you be investigating tonight BKB?

Seeing as though this is your first game, it's not surprising that there's roles you've never heard of. Both of PD's previous games only had 9 players, so it would be hard to include all of the same roles. Furthermore neither of those games had a Miller or BD. The only role I was really linking to previous games was the SK, and what a surprise I was right. I had the added advantage of knowing that with a Bomb included, there was always going to be 2 killing roles though.

 

[Aditya]

Town Drunk? As per my perception, I don't really find Manly to be totally convincing.

@BKB - If I shall hammer Sedition and he dies, although if he is telling the truth about whoever hammering him dies along with him, I die and hence you cannot get protected during the night phase. Just something we shall think about.

 

[Sedition]

So it's only thedon and Varun that haven't claimed then? Varun had asked for the watcher/tracker to claim if there is one, so I guess if it's not him, he know who it is. Given that thedon is new, he may not have prepared a claim yet, so I think it's worth knowing whether we can test them out here and now.

 

[Aditya]

I don't really see the point. As much as I would support the point about thedon being a noob and if he is mafia, he may not have prepared a claim. As far as Varun is concerned, he doesn't need to role claim. If you are actually town and if you are lynched, why do you want the mafia's to know the remaining town roles or am I missing something here?

 

[thedon5]

I don't really see the point. As much as I would support the point about thedon being a noob and if he is mafia, he may not have prepared a claim. As far as Varun is concerned, he doesn't need to role claim. If you are actually town and if you are lynched, why do you want the mafia's to know the remaining town roles or am I missing something here?

He is mafia, that's why. None of this bomb rubbish, you won't die. He was a bit suspicious on day 1 and 2, but after all that has happened on day 3 you shouldn't have any doubts whether he is Mafia or not.

 

[Sedition]

Because I want to know what this other investigative role that Barmy could've tampered with on Night 1 is, because so far only BKB has such a role and it proves that it was the result on me. It's alright if you're a confirmed town PR, but when you're innocent with a guilty result, you have a different perspective.

 

[Aditya]

Thedon, how was Sedition suspicious on day 1? To me, he wasn't. Simply because along with me, he was the one going after User and I believed and perhaps still do, that User is mafia. However, we wont know until someone replaces him and provides a better defense.