Story SOTQ(October,November,December 2010) - Evaluation Completed

[Aditya]

The nominations are.
1.ICC Battle For Supremacy - Riz and User
2.Australia's Journey In International Cricket By Hedger
3.Aditya's India's Journey To World Cup 2011
4.Oceania Premier League - Just_Cricket

Reminder on how SOTQ works.

1) Voting in poll just counts 50%.
2) Remaining 50% is calculated based on evaluation from panel members which would be,

a) Commitment as a writer ( Points out of 10 ) - This also includes the writers' attitude of taking the readers' comment and improving accordingly.
b) Quality of a story ( points out of 10 ) - This also includes the writers' tendency to take the story in long runs with consistency.
c) Presentation and Other Innovative stuffs ( Points out of 10 ) - Not only the graphics part, but the way writer presents the story to the readers.
d) Story Line ( points out of 20 ) - Bottom line of every story.

Panel Members :- User, Treva and Roo.

 

[riz7khan12]

oh dear, i hope user isn't bias.

 

[AbhishekS]

Just cannot decided on one out of the four to cast a vote. All of them are superb and equally good.

 

[hedger_14]

User won't be able to evaluate his own/your story though, well at least that was what happened last time.

Anyway, I won't vote as I'm actually part of it.

 

[riz7khan12]

i'm hoping to get some criticizing feedback for once....

 

[Prithvi]

I'm going with Hedger!

 

[Gaurav_7]

Yeah, I won't be evaluating ICC Battle For supremacy. But, I can vote if I think it is the best of the lot after my calculations.

 

[hedger_14]

haha, only 4 votes so far. I have a feeling that Riz and User's story will win it.

 

[Aditya]

The poll is closed and it's a tie so far. I haven't got the ratings from all the panel members yet, if I get the ratings/comments from all the panel members till tomorrow, the results will be posted tomorrow.

 

[Aditya]

Aditya - 38/50
Hedger - 36/50
JC - 36/50
Riz & User - 34/50

(With votes,)
Aditya - 41/50
Hedger - 39/50
Riz & User - 37/50
JC - 37/50

Comments from panel members :-

User2010,

Australia's Journey In International Cricket - Hedger

a) Commitment as a writer ( Points out of 10 ) - 9

b) Quality of a story ( points out of 10 ) - 8

c) Presentation and Other Innovative stuffs ( Points out of 10 ) - 7

d) Story Line ( points out of 20 ) - 14

Total - 38/50

India's Journey To World Cup 2011 - Aditya

a) Commitment as a writer ( Points out of 10 ) - 9

b) Quality of a story ( points out of 10 ) - 7

c) Presentation and Other Innovative stuffs ( Points out of 10 ) - 8

d) Story Line ( points out of 20 ) - 15

Total - 39/50

Oceania Premier League T20 - JC

a) Commitment as a writer ( Points out of 10 ) - 7

b) Quality of a story ( points out of 10 ) - 9

c) Presentation and Other Innovative stuffs ( Points out of 10 ) - 9

d) Story Line ( points out of 20 ) - 14

Total - 39/50

Treva,

ICC Battle For Supremacy - Riz and User

a) 7/10
b) 9/10
c) 8/10
d) 17/20

Overall - A still fairly new story with only two matches completed. Both writers have presented the story well and the idea is a good one. Hopefully the two of them will keep up the high standard for months to come.

Australia's Journey in International Cricket - Hedger

a) 10/10
b) 9/10
c) 7/10
d) 15/20

Overall - An excellent effot from Hedger who has been updating since mid-2010. Having covered several tours updates have been consistent. Using cricsim can hinder the writers choices for presentation, but Hedger has made his story stand out with the use of a consistent layout.

India's Journey to World Cup 2011 - Aditya

a) 9/10
b) 9/10
c) 9/10
d) 15/20

Overall - Aditya has recently assed the year mark on his fabulous story, in which he picked up the 'Best Cricket Story Thread' award. He has taken time to complete his opening tour, having not yet finished the final part, showing his focus on quality presentation. Aditya has taken note of the story greats and, if he continues to produce great work, there is no doubt he will join them.

Oceania Premier League - Just_Cricket

a) 7/10
b) 9/10
c) 8/10
d) 18/20

Overall - Just_Cricket has produced some brilliant stories in the past, most notably his superb Cricket 2004 Northern Knights story. Once again his writing has led the way to form a solid base at the beginning of the story. This story is unique in terms of storyline, and will be among the greats if completed.

Roofrom50,

ICC Battle For Supremacy - Riz and User
a) Commitment as a writer ( 6 Points out of 10 )
b) Quality of a story (5 points out of 10 )
c) Presentation and Other Innovative stuffs (7 Points out of 10 )
d) Story Line (5 points out of 20 )

Australia's Journey In International Cricket By Hedger
a) Commitment as a writer ( 7 Points out of 10 )
b) Quality of a story (7 points out of 10 )
c) Presentation and Other Innovative stuffs (8 Points out of 10 )
d) Story Line (7 points out of 20 )

Aditya's India's Journey To World Cup 2011
a) Commitment as a writer ( 8 Points out of 10 )
b) Quality of a story (8 points out of 10 )
c) Presentation and Other Innovative stuffs (9 Points out of 10 )
d) Story Line (8 points out of 20 )

Oceania Premier League - Just_Cricket
a) Commitment as a writer ( 6 Points out of 10 )
b) Quality of a story (5 points out of 10 )
c) Presentation and Other Innovative stuffs (8 Points out of 10 )
d) Story Line (8 points out of 20 )

Thanks for your co-operation for this SOTQ.

Congrats to me for winning SOTQ. Rest of the stories were equally deserving for the win but in the end it's just the matter of 2 or 3 points. I hope that the story writers will continue their good work with their stories. Cheers!

 

[AbhishekS]

Roo has been so strict in giving the ratings, especially for the 'storyline'.

And congrats Aditya on winning the SOTQ.

 

[treva]

Think he thought it was out of 10.

 

[AbhishekS]

Think he thought it was out of 10.

Yeah even I have the same feeling.

 

[riz7khan12]

good stuff Adi, hopefully i can keep my story going when school starts up again.

 

[Gaurav_7]

When does it start? Maybe I'll be able to keep it going then.