I'll take
Chandrakant Pandit for my next pick. A batsman for India in the late 80's/early 90's, he had quite an impressive FC career for a "scrub". He was also quite impressive as a wicketkeeper as well. Which leads to an issue. See, in his first 3 Tests, he was picked as a specialist batsman. For that, his average of 24 definitely isn't up to par for a mid-to-lower-mid order batsman. At the time when he played, wicketkeepers were becoming more than just glovemen, they needed to bat too. An average of 24 would have been perhaps on the lower edge of being able to be called a wicketkeeper/batsman in that era.
Which brings me back to my issue. I can't pick him as a wicketkeeper even though he would be a great choice. That's the issue - he's too good of a keeper. In the two matches he played as the specialist keeper, he had 13 dismissals across the 4 innings (11c, 2st), which is actually pretty good, however it gives him a higher number than the Draft limit of 2. So...that eliminates him from donning the gloves, unfortunately. Because he played more Tests as a batsman and not as a keeper, it's only fair that I also pick him as a batsman.
Of note, he's pretty much a golden manager over the past few years in the Ranji Trophy, leading both Vidarbha (2018, 2019) and Mumbai (2003, 2004) to back-to-back titles. At the moment he's back with Madhya Pradesh, the team he played many years for domestically while the national selectors kept ignoring him.
5 Tests, average 24.42, best 39
138 FC, average 48.57, best 202, 22 centuries, 42 fifties
16/50 caps currently
(EDIT: Just putting in my batting order)
1.
2. Shafiq Ahmed
3.
4.
5.
6. Chandrakant Pandit
7.
8.
9.
10. Shaun Tait
11. Tabraiz Shamsi
@blockerdave again.