The PlanetCricket.org Mafia - End game

[SiriusBlack]

I agree with Rudolph's hunch of a 3rd party. 6-2-1 seems completely fair. I'm kinda convinced it's not an SK since it would be too anti-town. Something like another forum maybe - someone who can win regardless of everything as long as he's alive, i.e. a survivor.

lynch: AliB

I don't like how he's trying to go off by saying he's a poor player, and being extra defensive when Jack Ryder puts out a very neutral observation. I'm all for a no lynch at this stage but I think we need to put pressure on Ali (and Perfect Square too) in order to make them contribute. Either one of them could be mafia and could let something slip.

 

[Till Valhalla]

I don't like how he's trying to go off by saying he's a poor player, and being extra defensive when Jack Ryder puts out a very neutral observation. I'm all for a no lynch at this stage but I think we need to put pressure on Ali (and Perfect Square too) in order to make them contribute. Either one of them could be mafia and could let something slip.

We all know his posts attract a lot of attention on the first day and hence we might advise him to change his playing style a bit but suddenly this much change in one day is not possible. It's like someone is feeding him what to post.
FOS: ALIB.[DOUBLEPOST=1494510160][/DOUBLEPOST]

I agree with Rudolph's hunch of a 3rd party. 6-2-1 seems completely fair.

So 9 members, I think two hackers and one more anti-town, that leaves 6 of us.

Something like another forum maybe - someone who can win regardless of everything as long as he's alive, i.e. a survivor.

A Lynchee maybe? trying to lynch off the old head.

 

[swacker]

I agree with Rudolph's hunch of a 3rd party. 6-2-1 seems completely fair.

Is this a hint at the fact you have evidence?

 

[Perfect Square]

I also agree with Rudolph's post. Most probably there will not be more than 2 Mafia. There could be 6 townies, 2 mafia and any other. Like Simon said Surviror. But we are still not sure.

Since User2010 said couple of time this is advance gaming setup and you have to think out of box. So we can see a/few totally different roles of what we are thinking. But 3 killing roles at night won't make any sense. If there are 2 anti-townies killing role and a vigilante (townie killing role) than we can see 3 deaths a night which is very unlikely. So I'm guessing there will be one mafia killing role and a townie/3rd party killing role.

 

[zwarrior]

I think we should go with a No Lynch, as there are no clues as always on Day 1.

No Lynch

You are in hurry. Agreed that there are no clues on day 1, but we should pressure. Saying 'no lynch' directly will not yield anything

I somewhat agree, but the night can cause a plenty of damage if its a 6-3 combo. We'll lose a pro-town for sure. Let's first hear from @zwarrior and @asprin before concluding it. swacker has been one post and goner, would want something from him as well.

FOS: zwarrior
Lynch: TBD

FOS me because ? I have been posting less as this is first day and had a rough day at office.

It's interesting that Swacker has been active as soon as you posted it (bolded part). Was he trying to remain silent to hide any suspicion ? Now that you mentioned his name, he has come out.

FOS: Swacker

 

[SiriusBlack]

Is this a hint at the fact you have evidence?

I ask the same to your reply.

 

[AliB]

So what? Dauq? When I play agressive, pundits come and say he's magnet and all, when I play defensive they say he's changed a lot. These are facts of Indian mother in laws.

Simon seems to drag attention away from him.

I agree with Rudolph's hunch of a 3rd party. 6-2-1 seems completely fair.

This point proves out to be an indication that there's a third party and he is Simon himself.

FOS: Simon.

 

[asprin]

These are facts of Indian mother in laws.

Unrelated to the game currently, but I laughed so hard at this

 

[CerealKiller]

hese are facts of Indian mother in laws.

LOL good one

 

[Till Valhalla]

LOL good one

Unrelated to the game currently, but I laughed so hard at this

Maybe add something to the game other than laughing.

I believe AliB to be mafia. He certainly took his time to post an defense which was weak.
LYNCH: AliB

 

[Gaurav_7]

Vote count

AliB (2) - Simon, Jack
NL (1) - CK

With 9 alive, it takes 5 for a majority.

 

[Perfect Square]

AliB gets a lot of attention. In the previous short game he also got all the attention and couldn't defend himself successfully. Instead he sometimes post things that open another get of suspection for him and this confuses me. But I still suspect him.

F.O.S : AliB

Simon is one who try to get off the attention. We may also be aware of the others. As we don't wanna lose any townie.

 

[zwarrior]

Ali is a magnet for some reason. All the games, he will be getting lynches and he turns out to be townie. That is just the way he plays. So, I am not lynching him now.

 

[swacker]

It's interesting that Swacker has been active as soon as you posted it (bolded part). Was he trying to remain silent to hide any suspicion ? Now that you mentioned his name, he has come out.

I come at a time which was suspicion? Now you got to explain me whether you read what I wrote, or not. I replied to the part where CerealKiller edited which was at a time difference of 20 odd minutes. One is not suppose to edit and you telling me, I didn't post until that point?

Personally, I think you trying to make something out of that, makes you suspicious.

I ask the same to your reply.

Okey, lets do this. Make a mass roleclaim, would have the town telling the truth and the mafia lying about their roles, possible are pretty hard to fake, so if someone's lying, it'll take some detective work but I'm sure they'll be exposed.

 

[RUDI]

Not enough info to go with at this moment.
NO LYNCH