Normally I'd have no problem believing a doctor claim but in this case Chilton and the type of doctor he is is very ambiguous. He undermines Clarice, is desperate for credit and almost prevents her from finding Bill. If we're focusing on the theme it's hard to see Chilton as a purely town characater
----------
One more point I like to bring it up, if you remember on day 1 - I was asking Varun to extend the day as much as possible. I don't think any mafia members would have loved to extend the day time, they should be insane to do that.
Well this is a weak argument seeing as I was the one who claimed on day 1 and generated most the activity. You're somehow claiming credit there because you happened to "ask" for the extension. I've also been the one constantly encouraging discussion, refusing to accept claims as readily as you did with thedon and making clear that no discussion on day 1 only helps the mafia.
You really want to try and argue that's scummy behaviour?
----------
Typical category of mafia team to get a person under suspect radar to get a lynch with safety cautions. I have nothing to say any further.
Some might that the opposite of preaching safety is to blunder ahead blindly convinced in your own head of arguments that don't stand up to examination.
I repeat that both your arguments against me have no basis:
1. Senator Martin wouldn't be in the game - I think I've demolished this to the point where you've actually stopped talking about it so so progress there at least.
2. Senator Martin wouldn't have the role governor - Of course she would. She works with the judicial branch to draw up a document promising a convicted murderer an improvement in conditions if he helps her save her daughter. If that isn't the power to reprieve what is?
----------
On Colin's claim, I would be inclined to believe that if the Senator's daughter were to be in this game then the Senator would be as well. If someone claims her then he's got to be leaning town imo.
I haven't watched the movie though, so no idea whether they were major characters.
And on thedon's claim, I said before that I found it fishy, that view hasn't changed yet.
I think with 5/7 claimed we need the other two to claim. Otherwise we're working with incomplete information. That said I'm confident that Catherine Martin is in the game but she may not be able to claim (for theme-related reasons).
----------
Why I did not investigate Colin?
He was so sure about coming as town in his claim. Like I said, my hunt is for Lecter to continue further hunting. This means, lecter may be lawyer to protect Bill until Clarice reaches him( this part is what I have been mentioning as me thinking over 1000 times ). Due to this ambiguity of Lecter being lawyer or it is just the bold deviate act from Colin, I am not ready to waste my night investigation skills on Colin. As it is 7 players set up, I am very sure that this game is going to be short.
This needs explaining much better. You have to find Lector and despite thinking I may be Lector you didn't investigate me? Do you know how incredibly suspicious that sounds?
