The Silence Of The Lambs Mafia - Endgame - SK (Sulaiman7) WINS

[P Squared]

Looks like I'll have to claim as well.

I'm Catherine Martin, Daughter of Senator, Town Aligned

No power, vanilla.

And its the way in which my role is described, as 'daughter of senator', which makes me think that the senator is in as well. So yeah that's why I was believing Colin's claim a bit.

 

[thedon5]

Believable claims, as I stated earlier, I'm certain I'm not the only townie. Colin definitely picked up on your soft claims.

 

[barmyarmy]

I guess everyone has to claim vanilla townie otherwise Surendar will accuse them of making up a role...

 

[thedon5]

"your soft claims" is directed at Sulaiman btw.

 

[P Squared]

I've been soft claiming as well(only once though) but I guess nobody picked up on it.

 

[barmyarmy]

I've been soft claiming as well(only once though) but I guess nobody picked up on it.

I think I quoted your post saying something about she might not be able to claim. I was expecting your role to be a hidden or silent one so you couldn't say who you were.

----------

I'm inclined to believe P Squared for two reasons:
1. It fits for me to have my daughter in the game
2. Suren has an innocent on him

With Surendar I've on the fence between whether he is a clever mafia or a misguided townie playing poorly. I think his role is probably too important to take a risk on so I would have to FOS: Sulaiman, thedon5 and Zhuorb.

 

[Sulaiman7]

I've no complication in you lynching me, Surendar investigating me and anything else. Just one thing I'd say, I was hoping to be jailkeeper but unfortunately I'm not.

 

[thedon5]

I've been soft claiming as well(only once though) but I guess nobody picked up on it.

I didn't pick up on it.

Soft claiming doesn't say a whole lot though in this sort of game where the Mafia have been given fake claims.

Given the chance to analyse the gameplay and claims of each and every player, I am right now most suspicious of Zhuorb. He has been taking sides way too easily IMO.

FOS: Zhuorb

----------

And its the way in which my role is described, as 'daughter of senator', which makes me think that the senator is in as well. So yeah that's why I was believing Colin's claim a bit.

Interesting. My role is "Best Friend", by that same logic that would mean Clarice would have to be in the game. It's possible though that fake claims count as 'people in the game', though.

 

[barmyarmy]

I've no complication in you lynching me, Surendar investigating me and anything else. Just one thing I'd say, I was hoping to be jailkeeper but unfortunately I'm not.

Please explain. If you're town and we lynch you we lose...

----------

Interesting. My role is "Best Friend", by that same logic that would mean Clarice would have to be in the game. It's possible though that fake claims count as 'people in the game', though.

I suspect that's the case. The mafia players are going to be hidden behind false claims and those claims could be anyway (yes Suren; even you).
Otherwise as I said the theme breaks the game rather than enhances it.

 

[ved_]

Whose side did I take?

 

[Sulaiman7]

Please explain. If you're town and we lynch you we lose...

Didn't realize that it's a MyLo here.

 

[barmyarmy]

Well as thedon said on the previous page it's probably MyLo. Depends on the setup.

 

[thedon5]

What surendar posted made complete sense. I fail to understand why PS didn't get it.
I'm going to go ahead and claim, right now.
I am Dr.Frederick Chilton, Crime Doctor, Town Aligned. I protected surendar last night, because Clarisse would more likely be the sane cop, with Crawford as paranoid/insane.
If Hannibal Lecter is investigated, I will get to know the name of the killer.
---
Now,
Surendar - cop - Starling
Zhuorb - doc - Chilton
P Squared - town(report)
Barmyarmy - governor - Martin
I don't exactly remember the characters Sulaiman and Don claimed.
---
I claimed because the game will be decided today; 6 people alive and 2 mafia or 1 mafia, 1 SK. Either way, if we lynch a town member off it's lost. From my point of view, 2 out of thedon5/Sulaiman7/barmyarmy are anti-town roles. This is due to surendar's report on PS. P Squared being lawyered wouldn't make sense, because barmyarmy was obviously a better choice.
---
What we can do today is lynch barmyarmy off. If he is the governor, he can use his role to overturn the lynch to either of the 2 claims. And then this night, surendar will investigate someone. This should be an easy win. Mafia can't kill surendar this night because I will be protecting him.

The bolded part is a problem for me, that was just a theory I had before the end of day 1, that is no reason to believe everything surendar says as gospel. Something tells me you were looking for a reason, any reason to side with him, and you just used that. You too easily believed surendar's claim.

You seem very keen to lynch Colin off and aren't even ready to consider that perhaps Colin is telling the truth and surendar is lying. You were also explaining things FOR surendar, too far for me. The whole ending to this post gives me a massive Mafia quick-lynch vibe.

Ahh well governor IS an un-cc'able role, so the claim should be legitimate. Ruth Martin as a SK? I don't see that happening.

You changed your mind so easily too. You believed Colin seemingly unconditionally on day 1, this was the extent of your contribution after Colin's claim as well as this post:

Chilton, Clarisse and Crawford are must-haves in this game, I think. 2 of them have claimed already, along with a governor and a vanilla. I believe Chilton will be some sort of jailkeeper/doctor, so if everyone claiming was speaking the truth, we have 3 power roles claimed and 1 unclaimed. This would make a somewhat unbalanced setup. One of the claims is probably lying.

OK so a soft claim here and a possible attempt yet again to try and clear surendar to some extent.

You've been very keen to discuss power roles, what about myself, Sulaiman and P Squared? There is every chance that there is a Mafia amongst us. In fact it would make sense that the Mafia have one power role fake claim and one vanilla fake claim (in this case, .

Am I suspicious of you? Yes. Am I convinced you're Mafia? Nope. Do I think you're in a team with surendar? Not necessarily, as due to the size of the game, it is possible you are following him as you want to get in a mislynch on Colin. But, the way I see it, either you or Colin must be Mafia.

So FOS: barmarmy, Zhuorb.

 

[barmyarmy]

The problem with Zhuorb is that it's hard to take any of his FOSs or lynches seroiusly as they're usually backed up by totally flawed logic; like that part about Senator Martin being a serial killer.

 

[Varun]

Vote count:

Sulaiman7 (1) - surendar

Day ends in about 48 hours at least.