Video Game Mafia - Game Over: Maney and Spoobir Victorious

[Varun]

And on what grounds do we believe that you're not going to mislead us and since Tom was anti-hero as well, and there appears to be a cult recruiting, you could well be together, couldn't you? It's pretty easy to say you weren't. And above all, your defense seems a bit artificial. I remember Smurf's mafia where Tom made the same excuses that he wasn't going to harm the town, only to find the lover, and he turned out to be the SK after being lynched.

Of course, I would want a mafia lynch earlier than some anti-hero's, but you're probably the best bet to lynch here.

 

[Aditya]

Unlynch : Barmyarmy

For now, I think that's the way to go. We need mafia's first and by going by what Colin is saying, we can always lynch him in the future if he feels to be dangerous but for now, his role seems useful.

Now, believe me, I find that I've got something important to discuss. How many of you here think that Dr.Pepper has been playing a very silent game and a intelligent game. He hasn't posted anything substantial but some of his posts seem quite suspicious to me. He is someone who can be very helpful to the townies if he is a townie but in this game, he hasn't helped us. Didn't he try and defend Bevab when he was getting lynched? Not going to deep into this as I'm not sure but I'd look back at the old posts and I feel that I can find something useful.

 

[Chewie]

Themer just seems scummy to me :/

He also was confused on the protagonist bit

What Barmy said.

And just seemed too eager to lynch Colin.

 

[barmyarmy]

And on what grounds do we believe that you're not going to mislead us and since Tom was anti-hero as well, and there appears to be a cult recruiting, you could well be together, couldn't you? It's pretty easy to say you weren't. And above all, your defense seems a bit artificial. I remember Smurf's mafia where Tom made the same excuses that he wasn't going to harm the town, only to find the lover, and he turned out to be the SK after being lynched.

Of course, I would want a mafia lynch earlier than some anti-hero's, but you're probably the best bet to lynch here.

Tom claimed he wouldn't harm the town; I'm claiming that I can greatly aid it. I haven't seen any hint of an SK in the write-ups so far either.

 

[Papa_Smurf]

[/B]Unlynch: barmyarmy

Call me gullible, but I am actually inclined to believe him. Plus, we can always lynch him later down the road if need be.

P_Squared hasn't posted that much, and even when he has, it's not been useful. In fact, his entire manner reminds me of his behavior in Smurfs and Scooby-Doo mafia. And he was mafia there in both games.

Lynch: P_Squared

 

[Aditya]

You just said what I said in my last post with just adding few different words to it. Intelligent Smurf.

 

[Varun]

I am not saying you're SK, Colin. Just that I don't believe you, and the reasons I've already explained.

I feel I'll have to put up with this for now. After all, finding mafia is of the foremost importance.

 

[barmyarmy]

If you must know I'm deuteragonist.

Either a Greek joke or a slightly strange role.

 

[Papa_Smurf]

You just said what I said in my last post with just adding few different words to it. Intelligent Smurf.

Oh yes, how could I miss the lynch on P_Squared in your post

 

[Gaurav_7]

Damn, so much to read but, I haven't missed a thing. So, Colin is anti hero. Same as what Tom was. But, the interesting thing is he can't be killed by the mafia? Why is that? How was Tom killed then? Colin, can you please explain your role completely? I mean, if the mafia can't kill you and you can only be lynched, that would mean if you claimed what you just did, your role would easily be the best one. If we believe you that is, we won't ever lynch you. So, that surviving thing goes...

Themer also didn't know Protagonist thing. So, what's your alignment? Surely not antagonist, eh?

 

[Varun]

And I actually agree with Aditya and Smurf on Dr. Pepper and P Squared respectively. Especially, P Squared, I haven't seen him much.

Lynch: P Squared.

Themer just seems scummy to me :/

He also was confused on the protagonist bit

And just seemed too eager to lynch Colin.

Can't say. Don't know what he was doing. I really thought they were testing him out. And it turns out the other way now, atleast about Colin.

 

[Papa_Smurf]

Themer also didn't know Protagonist thing.

Not defending Jack, but he was obviously joking when he mentioned deutromangonsit or whatever the hell it was

 

[barmyarmy]

Damn, so much to read but, I haven't missed a thing. So, Colin is anti hero. Same as what Tom was. But, the interesting thing is he can't be killed by the mafia? Why is that? How was Tom killed then? Colin, can you please explain your role completely? I mean, if the mafia can't kill you and you can only be lynched, that would mean if you claimed what you just did, your role would easily be the best one. If we believe you that is, we won't ever lynch you. So, that surviving thing goes...

Themer also didn't know Protagonist thing. So, what's your alignment? Surely not antagonist, eh?

As I said I didn't know anything about Tom's role. Obviously he could be killed by the mafia. You're right, my role is a powerful one. As I said before I have currently taken on mafia immunity powers, if I take on a cop power or other town power role I lose the mafia immunity for that night. At the start of the game it obviously makes sense for me to take the mafia immunity power so I don't die at night.
In the later stages of the game that will be an incredibly powerful role against the mafia. A cop who can investigate anyone and publicise the results (assuming I don't get mafia-killed on the night I use them).

----------

Not defending Jack, but he was obviously joking when he mentioned deutromangonsit or whatever the hell it was

Grammatically he is quite correct. There can only be one protagonist...
My respect for his intellect has risen

 

[Aditya]

@Smurf - I was talking about the first line of that post.

Hmm so, we're going for P_Squared. Well, in all the games I've played with him, I've hardly understood his gameplay. He's yet another player who hasn't done much contribution to the discussion of this game. What does that make up?

 

[barmyarmy]

The reason I lynched him on day 1 is that he's been mafia for the last few games and said he is fed up of it. Therefore it figures that if he had a town role he would be much more active.

Lynch: PSquared