Oh yeah. I stopped following and watching WWF many years back too (probably the moment I grew up to be a young adult
Because I started knowing that it was all scripted). But I agree that the Taker's scripted story is probably the best written story of all time. We used to go crazy about it in schools and the moment he featured in any of those wrestling bouts, it would spooke us crazy! And he genuinely looked scary with those eyes, the costume and the build. I mean I probably might get scared even today if I see that again.
Personally, I was a fan of 'The Rock' and 'Stone Cold Steve Austin'. I still have very nostalgic memories of the day when The Rock was fighting Triple H (with MacMahon by H's side) and as Rock was losing the battle, Stone Cold made a stunning entry to turn the tables and help Rock win it. Till then, Rock and Stone Cold shared rivalry vibes. That moment was so dope and so stunningly done that I still remember it with fond memories. Those were the days.....
I found the video! Here is that game I was talking about (Backlash 2000)