simsanta123
Club Cricketer
Cool. That does explain a lot!
"See how many we get" mafia - Endgame. BKB1991, mafia, wins
- Thread starter barmyarmy
- Start date
Gaurav_7
Executive member
- Joined
- Jan 3, 2010
- Profile Flag
- India
These are the two mentions of a prankster.
Number 1? andrinissac/whoever replaced him..(btw who?) How is that person a number 1 for PD? Care to explain PD?
Why would you chuckle to yourself? I can't really get any BD sort of a role out of this.
I feel PD needs to answer some of these questions.
Massive FOS: PD
Number 1? andrinissac/whoever replaced him..(btw who?) How is that person a number 1 for PD? Care to explain PD?
Why would you chuckle to yourself? I can't really get any BD sort of a role out of this.
I feel PD needs to answer some of these questions.
Massive FOS: PD
simsanta123
Club Cricketer
Woho.!! I missed that. I replaced andrinissac. I am number 1?
----------
User2010 is right. This isn't very clear.
----------
Also, if you did the same thing again (swapping yourself with someone), wouldn't the Night 2 allude to it?
BKB1991
Panel of Selectors
Hmm interesting. I see where Themer is getting at. So according to PD, hes mentioned here:
Night 0:
Night 1:
Can someone clear that out? is this what PD has refered to himself being mentioned in the nights?
If so then whom does this refer to:
Night 1:
Cause I believe ^ this refers to the jailbreaker?
I do suspect PD, but not based on his claim of BD, my suspicion is predominantly based on him claiming hes "the prankster" as mentioned by Colin and isnt that likely to be an anti-town role? Cause hes causing unnecessary confusion which doesnt help our cause
Night 0:
Night 1:
Can someone clear that out? is this what PD has refered to himself being mentioned in the nights?
If so then whom does this refer to:
Night 1:
Cause I believe ^ this refers to the jailbreaker?
I do suspect PD, but not based on his claim of BD, my suspicion is predominantly based on him claiming hes "the prankster" as mentioned by Colin and isnt that likely to be an anti-town role? Cause hes causing unnecessary confusion which doesnt help our cause
simsanta123
Club Cricketer
Yeah. this refers to JK jailkeeping Watcher. Which makes the statement "we don't like your type around here" seem strange.. Maybe because watcher is kind of snoopy and stuff..but still he is a town PR and one PR to say that to another is surprising.
----------
I would also think so, however IIRC (and it is amusing, that this is the third time I am using past game meta
), in the Planet Cricket game, the busdriver was always referred to as 'causing confusion', 'having fun', but he turned out to be town aligned.puddleduck
Chairman of Selectors
The reason I've assumed I'm the prankster is because Colin's Pm told me my role was a fun one and I wasn't even going to use it until I knew who to target. However I realised if I did use it to switch any night actions on me to someone else and from them to me, I would know full well the next day if anyone was lying.
Lynch me off if you want, I've answered the same questions so many times I don't really care any more. If people can't read, and keep ignoring my lines of inquiry then there's no point me being alive anyway. You basically lose your town doc if you kill me as that's what my role equates to.
Think it was BKB who initially suggested we had a bus driver after I tried to imply the prankster could be a jester role. How he figured that out is beyond me, but I'm home from work now so will give the whole thread a read through and see what I think.
Massively suspicious of Themer. He's taking a very mafia route, which is to target one person specifically and show no deviation. Whoever has backed him up is probably his partner, but as I said, give me an hour to read through and make some notes and I'll give you some detailed analysis. Then lynch me off then if you still want and you can at least use the information I collate to figure out who the mafia/cult/whatever the hell we're dealing with is.
----------
I've told you all at least a few times, that I specifically picked people that I felt wouldn't get night actioned or might be mafia/cult/etc so that I would constantly remain safe and could use whatever people posted later to get far more information that people might expect.
----------
Oh and no, I'm not posting what my night actions were, since I've already done so at least twice
Lynch me off if you want, I've answered the same questions so many times I don't really care any more. If people can't read, and keep ignoring my lines of inquiry then there's no point me being alive anyway. You basically lose your town doc if you kill me as that's what my role equates to.
Think it was BKB who initially suggested we had a bus driver after I tried to imply the prankster could be a jester role. How he figured that out is beyond me, but I'm home from work now so will give the whole thread a read through and see what I think.
Massively suspicious of Themer. He's taking a very mafia route, which is to target one person specifically and show no deviation. Whoever has backed him up is probably his partner, but as I said, give me an hour to read through and make some notes and I'll give you some detailed analysis. Then lynch me off then if you still want and you can at least use the information I collate to figure out who the mafia/cult/whatever the hell we're dealing with is.
----------
I've told you all at least a few times, that I specifically picked people that I felt wouldn't get night actioned or might be mafia/cult/etc so that I would constantly remain safe and could use whatever people posted later to get far more information that people might expect.
----------
Oh and no, I'm not posting what my night actions were, since I've already done so at least twice
simsanta123
Club Cricketer
5 people online! We can have some good discussion. 
----------
How do you work as a town doc? Pardon me but BD always massively confuses me.
----------
How do you work as a town doc? Pardon me but BD always massively confuses me.
puddleduck
Chairman of Selectors
Because I can essentially protect someone.
Basically. If A targets B. And C targets D.
I come along, and I target A and C. Then what happens is A targets D, and C targets B. I've been using myself (which I can do despite people trying to say it's not possible I just can't target the same two people on consecutive nights). So for tonight, I can target Varun and as an example myself. If the mafia try to kill him, the kill will instead happen to me. This is why I targetted people I didn't feel would get a night action on them so I remained anonymous. It's a shame Varun was blocked last night.
----------
So what I will do, is probably use Varun and whoever I feel is most suspicious, so that essentially any attempted kill goes back on themselves. Or I will double bluff and just pick someone random. Basically, mafia will have to think long and hard about who to target, as I will be sending their kill from either me/sedition/varun (depending on who I try and protect) onto any of the current people who haven't claimed. Potentially Manly to be fair, as his role is dangerous to town during lynching, but it doesn't matter if he gets night killed.
----------
Also, a hell of a lot of claims, except the only person to try and lead a lynch (on the only role that can protect the town's PRs).
Lynch: Themer again. And again. Couldn't look more guilty from where I'm sat.
Basically. If A targets B. And C targets D.
I come along, and I target A and C. Then what happens is A targets D, and C targets B. I've been using myself (which I can do despite people trying to say it's not possible
I just can't target the same two people on consecutive nights). So for tonight, I can target Varun and as an example myself. If the mafia try to kill him, the kill will instead happen to me. This is why I targetted people I didn't feel would get a night action on them so I remained anonymous. It's a shame Varun was blocked last night.----------
So what I will do, is probably use Varun and whoever I feel is most suspicious, so that essentially any attempted kill goes back on themselves. Or I will double bluff and just pick someone random. Basically, mafia will have to think long and hard about who to target, as I will be sending their kill from either me/sedition/varun (depending on who I try and protect) onto any of the current people who haven't claimed. Potentially Manly to be fair, as his role is dangerous to town during lynching, but it doesn't matter if he gets night killed.
----------
Also, a hell of a lot of claims, except the only person to try and lead a lynch (on the only role that can protect the town's PRs).
Lynch: Themer again. And again. Couldn't look more guilty from where I'm sat.
simsanta123
Club Cricketer
That is not a doc. And is not very useful. Its basically a swap between you and another town PR. Won't it be a lot better if you swapped a suspected PR and a suspected Mafia so that Mafia end up killing their own mates?
puddleduck
Chairman of Selectors
Ok, starting at the first page. Notepad ready. Gonna see what I come up with as apparently very few of you think there is a cult, so I'm gonna assume there are more cult members than I initially thought, or we do just have a mafia.
Varun
ICC Board Member
- Joined
- Mar 14, 2009
- Location
- Delhi, India
- Online Cricket Games Owned
- Don Bradman Cricket 14 - Steam PC
I trust PD on his role claim for the sole reason that if he was lying, it'd be way too early to claim, with all the players alive. The mentions of prankster/bus driver, though have been still slightly obscure, but still the role seems significant enough to be mentioned later in the game. I think there's no point in taking a rash decision.
I do have my doubts about Zhuorb, although his claim seems legit.
"Just as he was about to set off he was accostted by someone who looked familiar. "We don't like your type around here", he said as he locked him up for the night."
Noticed this though. Why'd Zhuorb look familiar to me? And then tell me "we don't like your type around here". Who does he refer to when he uses we?
I trust Sedition because of his gameplay so far. Sim has seemed clean too.
And finally, Beloved Princess is the last claim I wanted to see from Manly. It's the best role a mafia on the brink of getting lynched can claim, and it suddenly makes lynching Manly a huge risk.
I do have my doubts about Zhuorb, although his claim seems legit.
"Just as he was about to set off he was accostted by someone who looked familiar. "We don't like your type around here", he said as he locked him up for the night."
Noticed this though. Why'd Zhuorb look familiar to me? And then tell me "we don't like your type around here". Who does he refer to when he uses we?
I trust Sedition because of his gameplay so far. Sim has seemed clean too.
And finally, Beloved Princess is the last claim I wanted to see from Manly. It's the best role a mafia on the brink of getting lynched can claim, and it suddenly makes lynching Manly a huge risk.
simsanta123
Club Cricketer
Why target yourself then is what I am saying? It makes no sense and is very unselfish of you.
----------
selfless
of you.----------
selfless
puddleduck
Chairman of Selectors
Why target yourself then is what I am saying? It makes no sense and is very unselfish
I did say that was an example
This thread is like reading comprehension failure for the masses...I will almost certainly send the role back to whoever I most suspect of being mafia. Essentially, mafia have some thinking to do with their target tonight, and I would suspect that's why Themer is so keen to have me lynched off.
Varun
ICC Board Member
- Joined
- Mar 14, 2009
- Location
- Delhi, India
- Online Cricket Games Owned
- Don Bradman Cricket 14 - Steam PC
simsanta123
Club Cricketer
You said you did that both nights! Reading comprehension failure or forgetting your own 'lies'?
Similar threads
