Australia in South Africa Oct-Nov 2011/12

I'm banking on Siddle stepping up this time.. Johnson can't be relied on for anything anymore. If he can't fire even on this pitch, he's gotta be done.

Amla and Kallis are the only guys I see as a threat, everyone else is pretty average.
 
I'm banking on Siddle stepping up this time.. Johnson can't be relied on for anything anymore. If he can't fire even on this pitch, he's gotta be done.

Amla and Kallis are the only guys I see as a threat, everyone else is pretty average.

I'm backing harris again. Siddle and Johnson are now useless. Copeland would of loved the pitch.
 
This problem has been around for years. Put a tricky track at us and we crumble. We don't have enough players that can apply themselves. Clarke until this test was also in that boat. Hussey has the ability but he seems to make a 50 before he is unable to keep a good ball out. Marsh looks to be another but injury is his problem.

Hughes has been really poor in the first innings in his test match career and that is when 1) the pitch is most challenging for the batsmen as regards seam/swing and 2) you have the best chance to set the game up for a win. It's not sensible to leave him opening.

But the next match will probably have a much flatter track and he'll score runs. And all will be well.

Till the next tough track.
 
Hughes has been really poor in the first innings in his test match career and that is when 1) the pitch is most challenging for the batsmen as regards seam/swing and 2) you have the best chance to set the game up for a win. It's not sensible to leave him opening.

But the next match will probably have a much flatter track and he'll score runs. And all will be well.

Till the next tough track.

Wouldn't surprise me, far too many of our batsmen have done just this.

----------

I'm backing harris again. Siddle and Johnson are now useless. Copeland would of loved the pitch.

What is most annoying with this is we don't know if Copeland is up to this level or not. This was the perfect wicket to see if he was, he was killing it last season on similar tracks so if he did likewise here then we finally have a bowler that is threatening in these conditions and won't leak the runs.
 
Can I also just point out that the umpiring was utter CRAP. Especially on watson, how many times were the umpires wrong for Watson?? THREE TIMES or more.
 
Last edited:
It really was some of the worst umpiring I've ever seen, but thankfully DRS righted most of the wrongs. Are we definitely not using it for the home series against India? Pretty friggin' gutless if we're bending over for those crybabies.
 
Apparently you need both parties to agree to use it. Aka any series with India won't use it. If they don't want use it then fine but we should be allowed to.
 
Damn, I was hoping it was only India at home that wouldn't use it. I'd love to see their reaction if we were allowed to use it and they weren't.

As much as I enjoy winning fairly, I'd love to see them get a bunch of obvious rough decisions.
 
What else people expect to see when Silly Doctrove is umpiring. He is utter crap but ICC will persevere with him for a decade more before realizing this. I hope DRS does not mean that cricket can afford to have bad umpires since technology is there to rectify their horrendous and crappy decisions.
Coming to the match, wtf happened. The pitch was a bit tricky but it was not a 96 or 47 all out kind of pitch. South African bowlers bowled really well but Australian batsmen just seemed to think that a 230 odd would be a good enough target to defend anyways. While all deliveries that dismissed them were good but you would expect Aussie batsmen to cope with this sort of stuff. Also Saffers were pretty lame getting dismissed on 96 in their first inning. This Australian bowling attack should not have had troubled them this much. They seem to have picked up their game after their bowlers brought them back into the game. Amla is playing beautifully. Australian bowlers are looking mediocre. They should have opened with Watson as he is the only swinger in their team and bowled well in the first inning. Saffers should win this match but you can never be sure with this pitch. If Aussies can get Amla and Kallis early in the morning, and cat will be set among pigeons.
 
The key for me was the pace. You see a lot of batsmen survive seam, swing and turn when the pitch takes pace off the ball, but you see fast turnarounds when the wicket gains a bit of bite. At the end of day 1, I remarked that it was a pretty easy pace aside from the seam movement. Day 2 brought a welcome brightness to the pitch. It was no shock that Morne Morkel, whose back of a length area was frustrated by dull bounce on day 1, turned rather unplayable on the second day, even with the old ball in the first innings.

While several players acquired similar dismissals in both innings, the change in fortune for Clarke was most telling. In the first innings, while he was not comfortable from the get-go, he was rarely impeded in hitting more than two thirds of the balls he faced. In the second he only managed to hit one ball.

Pretty much every batsman failed the test of the conditions and on a wicket that isn't exactly unsafe, that is far too many, but I would offer that a pitch that both seams and zips is the grail for fast bowlers. It's not a matter of hitting a length and hoping the ball stays low or something, but applying the skills. To face elite fast bowling on such a wicket is a supreme test, not only of technique and talent, but also of the mind, of fighting the mental pressure and believing that you can survive without throwing in an awful hoick. The most common score in cricket is zero and it would be a very different game if that were not true.

Looking to day 2 I felt there was a hope for Australia with 250 on the board, but the game has now lurched forward 3 days in a heartbeat. I think South Africa will have the innings we expected from them yesterday and chase the meagre target like the pitch never bore a single threat.
 
Just wondering, how often has the number 11 has been the top scorer in a innings of a test match?

Lets hope Saffers wont do anything funny at super nelson. 111/1 on 11/11/11 :p
 
Couldn't ask for a worse start. Amla dropped for a second time on an absolute sitter and a wasted review.
 
Ok what has Harris done in the sheds only reason I can see for these drop catches. I missed it but it sounds like it was Haddin's take.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Top