Can say the same for Johnson! The fielding restrictions would be the main reason.
An article about how close Smith was to making it
Smith almost got the nod - Australia - Fox Sports
Probably making something out of nothing as he was no chance as Hughes was obviously brought over as backup opener not for a free holiday.
Hmmm. He's riding on the irresistable combination of young talent and ZOMG HE"S A LEGGIE.
I dunno, for him to make my XI you've gotta ask:
1. Is he a better spinner than Hauritz?
2. Is he a better all-rounder than Watson?
3. Is he a better straight out batsman than all but one of Hussey, North, Hughes, White, Bailey, Klinger, Khawaja, Jaques, D.Hussey, Cowan, Rogers, Marsh bros. (whoever else you want to put in there)? I'm assuming Katich, Ponting and Clarke are immovable objects and 3 of your 5 batsmen.
I can't answer yes to any of those questions so I wouldn't pick him. To me you need a guy who does at least one discipline really well. Right now he can't. His batting is better, but I wouldn't bet my house on him making a 2nd XI right now if he couldn't bowl. I don't like when talk like 'he can bat in the top 6' comes out. Sure he CAN, but do you WANT him to bat in the top 6? I think he needs another year of cricket for NSW.