End Game COMEBACK MAFIA! - Rudi, Cerealkiller, El Loco and Ashutosh Town WINS!

[Ashutosh.]

Your take on asprin?

I saw his all posts but can't say anything about him.

 

[AliB]

Please define "analysis". I don't go about accusing anyone of anything unless I have something to back my point of view. Doesn't necessarily mean I'm anti-town. Are you saying those who don't post much are scum?

In this case I'd say activity. You've been in and out but haven't really posted much unless there's an FOS on you. Please don't bring the 'certain circumstances' thing in. If you prove my theory wrong I'll unlynch,vI want the town to win so if you're town aligned, give something concrete.[DOUBLEPOST=1585639992][/DOUBLEPOST]

So by your own analysis, you have tagged 2 members as inactive and yet go ahead and target me. And do you have anything other than "style of play" argument to indicate I'm anti-town?

Not sure about them but you're one of the very best players and I know you can play really good mind games. As I said above, prove me wrong and get an unlynch.

 

[asprin]

You've been in and out but haven't really posted much unless there's an FOS on you

And like I said before (twice if my memory serves me right) I don't really have substantial reads on anyone at the moment. Even with you I don't have a leaning - could be town or anti-town.

The one thing I'm doing currently is observing posts from others. Whoever the SK is is doing a good job of hiding it. I do, however, still think Ashutosh (Life Warrior) has a PR but alignment is a mystery. His "waiting for night" simply can't be overlooked.

Not sure about them but you're one of the very best players and I know you can play really good mind games.

Looks like PE has managed to instill the same thought in you as well. Clearly, there are more better players out there and I mean that in every sense. It would be real shame if people start lynching based on that.

 

[CerealKiller]

Unlynch
Will post something concrete in an hour or so

 

[AliB]

And like I said before (twice if my memory serves me right) I don't really have substantial reads on anyone at the moment. Even with you I don't have a leaning - could be town or anti-town.

The one thing I'm doing currently is observing posts from others. Whoever the SK is is doing a good job of hiding it. I do, however, still think Ashutosh (Life Warrior) has a PR but alignment is a mystery. His "waiting for night" simply can't be overlooked.


Looks like PE has managed to instill the same thought in you as well. Clearly, there are more better players out there and I mean that in every sense. It would be real shame if people start lynching based on that.

I never concluded something on you, the style of your play has got me in this. After observing this much, how couldn't you have a read on someone? I might be wrong with my reads but not really in a state of confusion. If you're claiming to be town-aligned, what's your role, not forcing to role claim but if my reads are right, only 1 vt is left, unless and until, @deleted member & @Ashutosh. speak up, it's kinda a mystery.

Lynch stays.

 

[asprin]

After observing this much, how couldn't you have a read on someone?

Perhaps due to no one, apart from Life Warrior, slipping up? Is it absolutely necessary to know something by day 2? We haven't even gone through 2 nights for crying out loud. Having a read and just throwing random accusations based on "being dangerous" or "style of play" are two different things. It can negatively affect the town.

Role claiming isn't my cup of tea (unless absolutely necessary). I can easily take the easy route and claim to be VT. But that's not how I play my game.

It's fine by me if your lynch stays. I'm satisfied with my response as far as you are concerned.

 

[RUDI]

Role claiming isn't my cup of tea (unless absolutely necessary). I can easily take the easy route and claim to be VT. But that's not how I play my game.

So you are happy to sit back and wait for night 2 then?
Your experience in the mafia games forum have been discussed already, that's what is so frustrating with your play style here in this game.
Why are you not publicly actively trying to use your experience as a player to find the SK?[DOUBLEPOST=1585659275,1585659251][/DOUBLEPOST]

Unlynch
Will post something concrete in an hour or so

Ready yet Talha?

 

[asprin]

Why are you not publicly actively trying to use your experience as a player to find the SK?

That's where you're mistaken. Might not be publicly but it's definitely a WIP. I don't know why is it so hard to understand that I've no concrete reads at the moment. I'm starting to think people are overestimating my abilities (and by that, no, I don't mean the PR in this game)[DOUBLEPOST=1585664034][/DOUBLEPOST]

So you are happy to sit back and wait for night 2 then?

Classic example of taking thing out of context. Nope, that was not what I was meant - rather I was pointing towards how far along we have reached in the game. D1 and N1 is all we have got.

 

[Samarth27.09]

Well, to be really very honest. These conversations and accusation on people based on their style of playing has, yet, done us no good.

 

[CerealKiller]

Spoiler: AliB ISO

Thanking that post is nothing to do with the in-game stuff.

The thing is you jumping on people at the very first place is kinda suspicious...

There's no clue tbh, so I preferred to just notify him that I've read the post, nothing else.

Certainly, your sounding suspicious here, @CerealKiller You jumping straight away and then just trying to answer everyone, while not really making enough sense.

I can see another angle, here - Bates jumping on CK with the backing of Rudi doesn't really go well. Any of the cases - its too early to be judgemental but its getting interesting.

Certainly not what I meant here, the suffix mattered more. You jumping on people on day 1, early morning then trying to back it up with crap is something feels suspicious. I won't conclude here at this point though. @asprin & @PresidentEvil are some of the experienced players who are yet to post.

Tbfh, this wasn't needed, its a general phenomena that people wait and analyze before jumping on people - that's crap I was referring to.

Yes, but I wasn’t asking why he didn’t jump on anyone, i was asking why he didn’t post something, anything normal, to break the ice. You’re misrepresenting what i asked.

I simply asked people why they thanked the opening post by the mod, and didn’t post, and he felt the need to go after me for that, calling my reasoned argument crap. And, didn’t acknowledge the last post i made regarding this argument.
If he is SK : could be looking to start a bandwagon, although very risky strategy on Day 1, based on flimsy grounds.
If he isn’t SK : trying to catch on to something to get the game going. Likelier option.

I feel User is suspicious but Life Warrior reverse Lyncing CK is something to laugh at, can't risk the town initially in the game otherwise it would've been a straight lynch on User.

No lynch for day 1.

Bolded part : would’ve straight lynched User. Care to explain that? He was aggressive against PE, granted, but he hit the nail on the head, and given the chance of a triple night kill, i think it was reasonable to aggressively look for scum. Seems like an effort to blend in, jump on the No Lynch wagon, which tends to prevail on Day 1.

Barring the loss of user, it was a great night - hopefully the game is in our hand now.

Just a question to User, why were you so agressive in your approach, literally read mafia on you.


Nonetheless, let's get the SK now!

Same as above.

If your theory is to be looked at, you're a Vig - agreed. Since, you're a vig, you killed Bates, the question is why? Why not User or Sod who sounded more suspicious to you initially. With not a fair amount of contribution fro Loco, you're sure he's town? Why not a newbie can be a SK?

What if I say you're diverting people's attention by fake role claim? I'd rather say you're the SK and you killed User.

Lynch: RUDI

Is it allowed to spy on the activity of people? If that's the case, staff has an edge over others.

uhm.. Your reverse lynch increases my suspicion on you.

Missed this point completely, unlynch.

I could assure myself that you're the vig and we've gotto be sure that the real SK gets lynched otherwise it will be your last day.

A bit of a red flag, lynching the guy who claimed Town PR in an open setup, saying that MB was too much of an inexperienced player to target, but immediately reversed himself after a good explanation by Rudi, perhaps thinking he made a big mistake? Because if he had a reasonable explanation to lynch Rudi, he would’ve stuck to it for a bit, asking more questions. But he didn’t.

@deleted member Your analysis? You just can't quote a dead mafia and run away.

I was the first one to say that Rudi is fake claiming but a bit of study of the game and I'm sure he isn't fake claiming. The analysis and the execution clears that he has done some great job overnight. If he'd been the SK then he would've targetted someone more experienced than Bates.


I did mention that but dunno why the Bates thing makes me believe him. And his check on your activity which is unfair clears you town. Your initial posts gave me a hint of you being a vanilla too, I interpreted something of a vanilla role pm.

So if we assume the above to be correct, this could be the real role list:


Rudi - Vig
Ali - VT
Loco - VT
CK - sounding town of late but not sure.
DM - @deleted member got to speak more.
LW - Not enough activity.
asprin - The style of play he is approaching might just be the SK. No analysis until someone suspects him then goes back in the shell - as of now sounds to be the best player but the one with the anti town role.

Lynch: asprin

Your take on asprin?

In this case I'd say activity. You've been in and out but haven't really posted much unless there's an FOS on you. Please don't bring the 'certain circumstances' thing in. If you prove my theory wrong I'll unlynch,vI want the town to win so if you're town aligned, give something concrete.[DOUBLEPOST=1585639992][/DOUBLEPOST]
Not sure about them but you're one of the very best players and I know you can play really good mind games. As I said above, prove me wrong and get an unlynch.

I never concluded something on you, the style of your play has got me in this. After observing this much, how couldn't you have a read on someone? I might be wrong with my reads but not really in a state of confusion. If you're claiming to be town-aligned, what's your role, not forcing to role claim but if my reads are right, only 1 vt is left, unless and until, @deleted member & @Ashutosh. speak up, it's kinda a mystery.

Lynch stays.

So he thinks @asprin ’s patchy activity and vague posting make him a prime candidate for SK, but at the same time, has nothing to say about DM and LW’s (replaced by @Ashutosh. ) inactivity and patchy posting. Can look like he is trying to lynch a good player, immediately following Rudi’s lynch on him.
So here’s a theory. He said that User looked Mafia to him because of his aggressiveness. So he could’ve killed PE, thinking to frame User on Day 2, if PE flipped Town and User was still alive. But PE flipped scum, and User was killed too, so he went to the next biggest danger he saw, asprin.

Lynch : AliB

 

[CerealKiller]

Ready yet Talha?

Check above

 

[RUDI]

Check above

Thanks Talha

Unlynch
Lynch: AliB

Like Talha's reasoning here and would like to see Ali's response to his questions.

 

[CerealKiller]

@deleted member again thanking but not posting your thoughts

 

[Yash.]

Lynch Count

Asprin- AliB
AliB - Cerealkiller, RUDI

With 7 alive, it takes 4 for a lynch.

 

[AliB]

Guys, stuck between something, I've read and have my thoughts but will need some time, I request people to wait for my response before eventually killing me.