Back on Cricket 19 when I ran a simmed tournament I did a deep dive on the stats. Comparing them with real life, the top order players just bat for longer and score a higher percentage of runs. So, if this is still the case it wouldn't surprise me. There were a few other odd quirks too. Can't remember them all, but pretty sure spinners dominated.
Just looking at the
results there was a good spread of results regardless of batting and plenty of wickets were lost.
Of course when I say 'simmed' in this context it's running the match as AI v AI. I'm assuming it produces fairly different results to just external simming. It was still predictable at times but we also had many great moments. Such as Pujarageddon at Mar-a-Lago when
@Wavelberry outgunned
@passwordistaco in possibly the greatest cricket match ever.