Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows

[blackleopard92]

I'm not gay....

If ritwik says,shower love on Hermione ...
Ahh , how many ppl will queue up ?

there is many other forms of love.

As for hermione, If ritwik says, he will do it.

 

[sachin]

Btw,whats POV ?

Point Of View.

 

[icyman]

Anways here's my theory
R.A.B=Snape

Read the 6th book carefully and you'll find that Trelawney says that she was interrupted by snape.
This means snape heard the entire prophecy.had he not heard it,how come would trelawny have known that it was snape ?
however,snape told voldie only about the first part of the prophecy.

Snape alone knows that Harry is voldemorts match.

It is highly possible that snape,an excellent dark wizard himself,knew about the existence of horcruxes.he then went to the lake and stole it.Thats why dumbledore might have asked for snape upon return to hogwarts.

Also,the letter says:
To the dark lord
only his death eaters call him by that name.
I may be long dead before you read this
Snape is not sure whether he'll live or die.Thats is,whether voldie would spare his life.Remember book 4 when voldie says-one who has left me forever,he would be killed ofcourse.this refers to snape.

In the letter its also mentioned that voldie would meet his match.So,there are only 4 ppl who know the full contents of the prophecy
Dumbledore
Harry
Snape
Aberforth[barman of hog's head]-this has been confirmed by rowling in an interview.

So,its either snape or aberforth.i think aberforth=rab is pretty unlikely though there is a strong chance of snape=r.a.b

Also come to think of it,when has the obvious ever happened in a harry potter book ?
Sorcerer's stone-quirell is the enemy when we are all expecting snape

Book 3-who would have known the truth
behind sirius black ?

Book 4-who would have guessed mad-eye moody = barty crouch jr ?

Similarly,R.A.B won't be that easy a guess.Even though ppl are saying Regulus Arcrutus Black and Regulus Alphard Black,i dont think it would be that straight forward.

Regd the locket in Grimmauld Place,i can't say anything of it.But i think
Snape=R.A.B

Your opinions on this please.

 

[Ritwik]

Read the 6th book carefully and you'll find that Trelawney says that she was interrupted by snape.
This means snape heard the entire prophecy.had he not heard it,how come would trelawny have known that it was snape ?
however,snape told voldie only about the first part of the prophecy.

Trelawny does say she was interrupted by Snape, but in the order of the pheonix, Dumbledore says that the eavesdropper was caught half-way through the prophesy, so unless you are saying that Snape was in fact not the eavesdropper (which can't be true, since Dumbledore confirms in the Half Blood Prince that Snape is responsible for the Potters' death, which makes him the eavesdropper) it can't be said that he heard the full prophesy, unless he used a time-turner to go back to half of it, when he was detected. (which, now that I come to think of it, would be a brilliant twist in the tale!)

Snape alone knows that Harry is voldemorts match.

Very far-fetched. Snape was surprised when Harry used Parseltounge in the second year, which shows that he never guessed that Voldemort might have transferred his powers to Harry. In any case, such a scenario would be very inconsistent with the development of Snape's character, since although he is very good and all, he lets his personal hatred cloud his judgement, and hence he underestimates his enemies.

It is highly possible that snape,an excellent dark wizard himself,knew about the existence of horcruxes.he then went to the lake and stole it.Thats why dumbledore might have asked for snape upon return to hogwarts.

Possible, only if there is a credible explanation as to how did Snape come to know about Voldemorts horcruxes, and more pertinently, about where they are hidden.

To the dark lord
only his death eaters call him by that name.
I may be long dead before you read this
Snape is not sure whether he'll live or die.Thats is,whether voldie would spare his life.Remember book 4 when voldie says-one who has left me forever,he would be killed ofcourse.this refers to snape.

Regulas Black was also a death eater.

Aberforth[barman of hog's head]-this has been confirmed by rowling in an interview.

Which interview is this ?

I agree with you that it is very unlikely that RAB is Regulas Black, because of the reasons you've mentioned about the unpredictability of the series' plot, however it is even more unlikely for RAB to be Snape.

 

[ronny_kingsley]

I know its too much far fetched but my theory is unique in itself.

It might just be that Snape remained with Dumbledore and still stayed loyal to Voldemort for the simple reason of (maybe) getting to the biggest wizard of all.

He would doublecross both of them eventually (he has Dumbledore).

This stems from the fact that SNape is actually very good for he made atleast one of Voldemort or Dumbledore an idiot for his loyalty towards them.

I know quite ideotic but considering the nature of the books it might just happen.


Also intresting to hear that now JK will kill two unplanned characters and will let one, preplanned charecter who was to die, live.

Also she had writeen the first chapter of the 7th book way back in 1990.
Wicked isnt it ?

 

[blackleopard92]

very intresting indeed.
However, I believe there would be more twist than these.
the previous experience has shown me that JKR produces more twists and turns than what we can think of.

 

[sachin]

Yes i watched that particular interview between JK and Richard&Judy.I just hoep that she keeps the main four intact;Harry,Ginny,Ron,Hermione.I think that the biggest target for death would be Ginny,she may have got a repreave though.And i also think Lupin,Hagrid and Mcgonagall are also in the firing line.It's good to know she's written the last chapter already,this mean she won't be influenced in any way to change the ending,thats important.
And as i said earlier in this thread i'm quite sure Regulus Black has been confirmed as RAB.

 

[hassan]

hey sachin can u find me that post or site that confirms that RAB = Regulus black

 

[blackleopard92]

I thought, and even the local newspaper, that JKR hinted that harry might die in the 7th edition

 

[A_Whitey]

Possible, only if there is a credible explanation as to how did Snape come to know about Voldemorts horcruxes, and more pertinently, about where they are hidden.

Regulas Black was also a death eater.

Which interview is this ?

I agree with you that it is very unlikely that RAB is Regulas Black, because of the reasons you've mentioned about the unpredictability of the series' plot, however it is even more unlikely for RAB to be Snape.

I think it is most likely to be Regulas Black (RAB). He could easily have taken the Horcrux back to the Black house and have died before destroying it. Mundungnus Fletcher also stole many things from the house, and some were sold to Abeforth Dumbledore, who hid after buying from him (the real locket). This is why Abeforth was mentioned more in HBP, and I think he posesses a Horcrux.

I doubt that Snape knows where any Horcruxes are, Voldemort wouldn't trust him with that knowledge, especially as he was under Dumbledores nose day and night and could have used a truth potion to divulge the information. I don't know how Regulas Black found out, but I think that it was him.

 

[Ritwik]

Abeforth was mentioned more in HBP, and I think he posesses a Horcrux.

And he hasn't told Dumbledore about it ? It has been well established that Aberforth is usually not reticent to pass info on to Dumbledore (For Eg: In the chapter "Lord Voldemort's Request" in the HBP, Dumbledore has detailed knowledge about who Voldemort is travelling with; info which could've come only from the Hog's Head, ie, Aberforth).

 

[sachin]

Yes i think Aberforth would be a major weak link in the story.All Jk has said is that she wouldn't consider killing Harry until the final book.

 

[icyman]

She would kill him off.
She mentioned that she would nt want anyone to bring the character back to life.

I think Hagrid has hit the can in Book 7.

 

[sachin]

She said thats what The creator of Sherlock Holmes did,you goose(j/k)!She might,but as i've said to you before now,it is very unlikely.

 

[blackleopard92]

actually HP shares too many powers with voldy.And this could only happen if HP is a horcrux.
There is one fact to support this.(which is thought of)
in the end of goblet of fire, voldy had total control over harry.However, then harry thinks of sirus, and love fills him.This love torments the piece of soul of voldy encased in HP's scar, and causes voldy immense pain.The pain is so great that he is forced to break the link between him and his soul encased in Harry.

What do u think?