The thing is that we are so starved of bowlers one good performance has us chuffed, and suddenly I can't not think of Bumrah has the solution to our bowling issues. I think Bhuvi doesn't belong at the Int;l stage anymore. Umesh Yadav bowls one brilliant spell (final test vs SA), and then is back to bowling rubbish very quickly, for too long. I think he too needs some serious work. I like Rishi Dhawan, and while he was expensive today, but he has been in the 5 rpo region in the previous two games, and thats very acceptable. I felt he was unlucky today, he wasn't bowling bad ball. Edges went for 4s and Wade played scoop shots etc, to hit him for boundaries. At int'l level one can have such days, the improtant thing was that he still bowled to his field, and the batsmen had to invent shots, like hoiking over midwicket a ball that was well outside off stump. Its better than Umesh, who bowls on both sides, and with the off side field will slide one on the leg which is an easy boundary. Ishant has looked okay but after 7 years of Int'l cricket, okay is just not good enough. Ishant has rarely if ever crossed into the good territory for performance. His range varies from Okay to poor or apalling, which is not good enough.
Some would say even Aus bowlers have gone for runs. Well first of all this is probably Australia's 4th string bowling line up, and even they have been better than India's 1st choice line up. Have given away fewer runs in every single game. I am not sure any Intl side should compare its frontline attack to the 4th choice attack of any other side, and try to find some consolation in the stats. Secondly when was the last time seamers did well. Remember the last ODI vs SA where 438 runs where given away. Whenever India have done well, its mostly been down to spinners. So what use are these seamers.
If we take Umesh, Bhuvi and Ishant out, who else are there. Bumrah okay he is looking good. Sran, sure he obviously needs more chances. Rishi Dhawan, I am not sure he is a frontline bowler. He can do a job as the 4th bowler, and keep things tight, but I am not sure he is a frontline bowler though. Varun Aaron, okay he has pace, but he like Umesh can be a liability with regard to control, and he really does bowl both sides a lot. There is Shami, who I think has suddenly risen in value by virtue of not playing here. However okay he is an option. Who else? Thats all I can think of. There is Irfan who has shown some resugence in domestic cricket, but thats about it.
I really think we start playing these alternatives, and for now close the chapter on Ishant, Bhuvi and Umesh. Umesh needs work, but Ishant has not delivered for far too long and Bhuvi is just not Int'l level material any longer.
Bumrah, Sran, Shami, Rishi Dhawan and Irfan (if he really has shown real improvement), and Varun, these are the bowlers to use in the rotational cycle from now on. India play 18 tests starting June, and most of them (barring perhaps a tour to WI), are in India. Its the perfect time to start putting these youngster into the side, where they are not going to bear a lot of the workload, cos spinners will do most of the bowling. Bumrah should be in there ASAP.