the xbox version is different to the pc game. they both suck badly, excect you can tweak the pc version to suck less (and you can save games whereas you can't save a single thing on xbox). the xbox is full of all of the bugs the original pc one was - i don't think any of the pc c2005 fanboys can honestly say the original was worth playing - but thatnks to patches it is ok. there's no consistency in c2005 on xbox - you simply can't get better at it - it's all luck. and whilst BL on xbox is more arcadey - you know when you've played a bad shot and you know when you've played a good shot, and the results reflect this. in c2005 you don't know what's going to happen because the batting and ai is so faulty.
having said that, the pc fanboys for c2005 are telling a few fibs. when they say it's more of a sim, that simply means you can't go out and hit 36 runs an over because you've mastered the game. the only reason for this is C2005 will randomly make you play a bad shot if you go the six button every time - thus you can't afford to do it everytime, thus you tend to play more 1s and 2s....this in my books does not make it a more realistic 'sim', it makes it a boring game.
having said that, the pc fanboys for c2005 are telling a few fibs. when they say it's more of a sim, that simply means you can't go out and hit 36 runs an over because you've mastered the game. the only reason for this is C2005 will randomly make you play a bad shot if you go the six button every time - thus you can't afford to do it everytime, thus you tend to play more 1s and 2s....this in my books does not make it a more realistic 'sim', it makes it a boring game.
