Lord of the Rings Mafia - Town wins

[CG123]

There's not a lot more for me to analysis in terms of the write-up. Like others have said the respective paragraphs seem to have gone roleblock, poison, and kill. It's not great to lose someone like ARay early, although it's good that more than likely our power roles are still intact.

BKB's seemed to made quite a lot of sense out of the first paragraph, I still find bus drivers confusing though. Anyway he seems to be giving off pro-town vibes.

I'm not really sure where to go from here. Like Spoobir eluded to before Culli has been rather quite, so I might just go ahead and lynch him for the time being.

Lynch: Culli

On the subject of bus drivers have a think about the two people we expected to be targeted and the two people who were targeted. Why would the mafia ignore Sam and Frodo?

It is quite interesting how neither of them got killed. Normally in the first day or so mafia do look to get rid of the stronger players though, so it's not really surprising at the same time.

 

[barmyarmy]

Normally in the first day or so mafia do look to get rid of the stronger players though, so it's not really surprising at the same time.

I'm honoured
FOS: highlander999

 

[Deleted member 13648]

Looks like we're in another period of stalemate for the time-being. Not gonna join in with this 'pressure lynching' until everyone's reacted. Seems a little premature.

 

[CG123]

Yudi's really got to increase his activity here as well.

@ Yudi - What do you think of barmyarmy now, considering you lynched him on day one?

 

[Varun]

I am not that experienced enough to analyse those write ups, as much as I tried to I couldn't find anything except someone being poisoned

This 'I'm not experienced enough' again and again gives me a scummy feeling about you.

Lynch : Zohaib

 

[CG123]

Yeah, excuses like that are pretty poor Zohaib. You've played more games than the likes of Colin.

 

[Varun]

Also, hedger has been surprisingly inactive than his usual self.

 

[Sachinfan98]

Can somebody tell me what the hell is Culli doing?
Not posting anything, other than I will not do this I will not do that.That is so annoying.I think it is better to lynch off an inactive person rather than take the risk to lose a power town role(well, if we hit the jack pot we might get mafia as well)
Lynch:Culli
Not helping in discussion in any manner.
---
It seems to me that barmy is hinting that he is poisoned in various ways. Cmon doc, heal him tonight.

 

[hedger_14]

I actually didn't realise the Night had been posted until now even though I spend a fair bit of time in this forum and I wasn't really that quiet compared to normal on day 1. Why is it always ARay that gets killed first or second? It's very annoying.

Well I hate bus drivers as they confuse the ████ out of me so I won't bother doing much with the writeup as it's been pretty much analysed already and treva and his edited posts make it more annoying to know what I should be noting.

Well Culli just posted and neglected the pressure on him and just posted about the stale-mate we're in. Zohaib is also acting very suspicious. Have a feeling both could be mafia with Culli not wanted to lynch Zohaib cause he's his teammate and trying to make it sound like it's not too suspicious. So for the time being.

FOS: Culli, Zohaib

Lynch: Zohaib

----------

And people are asking why Sam or Frodo weren't attacked last night. Well the mafia aren't likely going to take a risk and have a shot at someone who is likely going to be protected. It also keeps the townies who were suspicion at the start of the game in, and can be used to their advantage later in the game, so I don't really find it surprising that ARay has been lynched off. Normally those that look townie are the targets early in the game.

 

[treva]

Not enjoying this blame for the confusion (Although it has made things interesting). PSquared is to blame!

 

[Bevab]

Just returned from school, will anaylze the posts and the write-ups, although it'll be quite useless now.

 

[Chewie]

I don't see the need for people to make posts like the one above to be honest...

 

[barmyarmy]

Well it reminds us that he's still at school!

 

[Deleted member 13648]

All this hostility towards me for not responding to a panic-lynch? I think it's suspicious that both Spoobir & Sachin have very similar reasons to lynch me; much more consistent to that of a 'team' than I've been accused of. The fact that I'm not jumping to lynch anybody shows that I'm not in a team & nor am I plotting. I suggest you strongly consider your lynches on me as I could prove very useful to the town.

 

[Manly]

What I am saying is. Gandalf knows identity of Merry/Pippin and Merry/Pippin knows the identity of the other one. And all of these are townies.

I think BKB's post is pretty insightful into analysing the writeup. Bus drivers are so annoying Treva's edits don't help though. The original post seemed like Gandalf was targeting Pippin though and then a bus driver interfered?

I also agree with Tom that it's likely that Bilbo wouldn't have had a major role if any; he's rather powerless in the books.

The poisoning will likely have been by Saruman, though it could feasibly the nazgul, though I doubt it.

It's so annoying how it's always someone like ARay or Abhas who goes on the first day though.

Zohaib's posts after the writeup are pretty weird I feel. Doesn't really add anything apart from being annoyed that we lost a townie, yet it would be pretty strange if we hadn't. Lynch: Zohaib

This 'I'm not experienced enough' again and again gives me a scummy feeling about you.

Lynch : Zohaib

This makes me think that Varun and Chewie may well be Merry and Pip, and given how good mates they are in the films, wouldn't surprise me to have a curve-ball individual team thrown into the game.

How's that for a stir? Haha

----------

I mean it seems Varun's jumped straight onto the back of Chewie's thoughts, without adding anything of his own that's of substance. Seems like he's just trying to generate a bit of a bandwagon, but with Sachinfan's seeming vendetta against Cull, it's gonna be hard for any of these three to get their plans going.