End Game Mafia returns

[Ashutosh.]

I was giving you a tip about how to participate more
If you had to give me a list of people, from the most suspicious to the least, what would it be?

RUDI
asprin
You
Yash
zwarrior
Me

 

[CerealKiller]

RUDI
asprin
You
Yash
zwarrior
Me

Any reasoning?

 

[Ashutosh.]

Any reasoning?

RUDI and asprin are good friends of Till Valhalla. So they are on the top.

You and Yash tried to trap me.

zwarrior is looking VT for me.

 

[CerealKiller]

RUDI and asprin are good friends of Till Valhalla. So they are on the top.

So, they’re good friends of Till Valhalla, who was killed, so they’re suspected of killing him, in your view?
(putting aside the fact that roles were randomly assigned)

 

[Ashutosh.]

So, they’re good friends of Till Valhalla, who was killed, so they’re suspected of killing him, in your view?
(putting aside the fact that roles were randomly assigned)

Yes and RUDI also agrees with my theory.

 

[CerealKiller]

Yes and RUDI also agrees with my theory.

Where?

 

[Ashutosh.]

Where?

Going on @Ashutosh. theory IRL @asprin must be one of the two that fatally wounded or killed Till Valhalla I mean, Till Valhalla always want to lynch asprin

 

[zwarrior]

Going on @Ashutosh. theory IRL @asprin must be one of the two that fatally wounded or killed Till Valhalla I mean, Till Valhalla always want to lynch asprin [DOUBLEPOST=1605282660,1605282275][/DOUBLEPOST]
Highly doubt this Talha, in just about any setup you never get a mafia team both with killing abilities.

Honestly think this:

1 x Mafia - night kill ability
1 x Assassin - night kill ability
1 x Town Cop - Investigate one player at night
3 x Vanilla townies

I don't think so. Because then mafia and assassin will both kill in the night and town may lose 2 people (assuming mafia wont kill assassin and viceversa). There will not be a chance for townie to win then. So, I doubt this theory.

I agree with this. Town must have a PR. Without a PR, there is no use of night 1.



I was watching the thread and was thinking what to post. I didn't want to post anything which will create problem for me in future.

Yup, there should be a cop.
You can post as well, no issue. You will learn only by posting Don't worry.

 

[Yash.]

Yes and RUDI also agrees with my theory.

His agreement looked more like a joke.

I'm finding Ashutosh. very fishy here, considering he isn't that inexperienced. He was elected to be the backup for CK, at the Mafia Championship this time.

 

[zwarrior]

RUDI and asprin are good friends of Till Valhalla. So they are on the top.

You and Yash tried to trap me.

zwarrior is looking VT for me.

I thought I was a friend of Jack too

Jokes aside, I think the roles were assigned randomly. Anyway, not denying your theory, just adding my opinion !

 

[RUDI]

I don't think so. Because then mafia and assassin will both kill in the night and town may lose 2 people (assuming mafia wont kill assassin and viceversa). There will not be a chance for townie to win then. So, I doubt this theory.

Trying to make sense of the write up. One person fatally wounded him and a second killed him.

Yes and RUDI also agrees with my theory.

Totally AK. Like I said earlier, I doubt Till Valhalla will use in real life (IRL) situations to be played out in a mafia game.

 

[Ashutosh.]

Day 1 has passed and it's Day 2 but we have achieved nothing. We all are playing very defensive. If one or two of us will get killed in the night then still we will have nothing to discuss. I can see clear victory of scum with this approach.

 

[Sherlock Holmes]

 

[Yash.]

FOS Ashutosh.

Just doesn't feel right. The moment I said that the inexperienced play looks like a hoax, he answers like an experienced guy. Overcompensating?

 

[CerealKiller]

FOS Ashutosh.

Just doesn't feel right. The moment I said that the inexperienced play looks like a hoax, he answers like an experienced guy. Overcompensating?

I think it would be too obvious that he’s Mafia. I wouldn’t go down that path.
My vote stays on asprin for now, at least till he replies.