End Game Mafia returns

[Ashutosh.]

"You are survivor
You get one bulletproof vest to use at night.
You win when you are the last one left."

Tough winning conditions I know let me help you guys get rid of the scum.

I don't believe your story

 

[Ashutosh.]

I have done my work. Now @asprin will decide what to do next.

 

[Till Valhalla]

No thanking of player posts as it might give a wrong impression.

 

[asprin]

Okay, some huge revelations. Too bad @Yash. ended up being one of the targets. We are 1 person down.

The results confirm that there were 2 attempts made, so we can safely asssume at least 2 killing PRs. The good thing is that town also seems to have a role blocker and he was successful last night.

You win when you are the last one left

Do you realize by reveling this, you just signed your own death certificate? By definition, you are a threat to town since you need everyone dead in order to win which also includes town. And the fact that you've a bullet proof vest to use at night would mean you ought to be lynched during day. Anything to counter the above Rudi?

To @Ashutosh. , I have one question. If you got Rudi as "not town" on night 1 itself, then why are you choosing it to reveal it on now and not later (maybe day4)

I'm inclined to believe Ashutosh here as his result of "not town" checks out with Rudi's claim of being a survivor, i.e. not mafia.

I'll wait for thoughts from the other townie whoever that is before taking a stand.

Realistically speaking, if Ashutosh is saying the truth, then this is in Town's bag and the roleblocker will just have to save him tonight.

 

[RUDI]

Anything to counter the above Rudi

My win condition is what it is unfortunately. All I can do is plea with the remaining townies to drag me along to assist finding the other two night kill abilities. You guys can always off me on day 5 with the bulk of town still intact and the scum and SK lynched.
Lynching me now will only make the game harder on town tbh. Like I said, I am willing to help find the other two and vote with what AK and asprin wants to go with.

 

[asprin]

All I can do is plea with the remaining townies to drag me along to assist finding the other two night kill abilities

What good does that do to you if you know you can't win from here.

Another thing I feel is that there is something odd about your reveal. If you do not have kill ability and Yash is no longer alive, then this means both @zwarrior and @CerealKiller have kill abilities since there were two attempts made yesterday.

So that means the first person we should be lynching is one of zwarrior or CK today, let the other attempt another kill during night 3 (and hope the blocker is successful again) and then finally take care of him on Day 4.

And there's one more thing that just struck me. If AK and me are the only townies left alive and he is a cop then who performed the role block? Something is not aligning right here.[DOUBLEPOST=1605521532][/DOUBLEPOST]@Ashutosh. I would say you retract your lynch for now on Rudi. Let CK and zwarrior see what they have to say in their defense and then we will take it forward.

One thing for sure is that you're telling the truth as Rudi is not denying your outcome.

 

[Ashutosh.]

Unlynch

 

[RUDI]

What good does that do to you if you know you can't win from here.

Live to die another day

One thing for sure is that you're telling the truth as Rudi is not denying your outcome.

How can I, AK is telling the truth![DOUBLEPOST=1605522511,1605522304][/DOUBLEPOST]Lynch: @CerealKiller

Maybe you'll talk now. Why did you kill Yash?

 

[CerealKiller]

I am the town cop. I investigated RUDI in the first night and the result was "Not town".
Last night, I investigated asprin and the result was "town".

Game changer. I tend to believe your claim, unless anyone comes forward.

Hold your horses here AK. I am a Survivor. A neutral player. I win when all threat to town is eliminated. Not sure why Till Valhalla choose this role. but it's my role non the less. --- Double Post Merged, Today at 9:24 AM, Original Post Date: Today at 9:23 AM --- I have one bulletproof vest that I can use at night time. Say the word and I'll use it tonight.

Do you realise that if someone claims Survivor, they have signed their death sentence? Your winning condition is to be the last one standing, so you’re not useful to the Town if kept alive. And if you do have a bulletproof vest, that means you have to be lynched, as @asprin said, because the Town doesn’t have any killing roles at Night.
So keeping that in mind, i find your claim very suspicious, and i'm leaning towards not believing it. I think you’re scum, or third-party SK, and making a desperate ploy, because you’re confirmed Anti-Town.
Lynch : Rudi

Lynch: @CerealKiller

Maybe you'll talk now. Why did you kill Yash?

Trying to deflect attention?

 

[zwarrior]

The guy was worried with the death of the mayor, could not stop thinking what to do, He ventured out for a walk to calm his nerves but he didn't knew they were waiting for him to come out. The moment he stepped out he was shot dead.

Spoiler

@Yash. is dead. he was a Townie

While the news of the new death travelled faster, he though he could be of help and started to wards the location but when his back was turned a knife went straight in his chest.
Thankfully he found some aid nearby which saved his life.
@Yash. @asprin @Ashutosh. @CerealKiller @RUDI @zwarrior
Day 3 begins
5 alive, 3 for hammer.​

This means one guy died and another guy survived the night thanks to doctor. So, 2 night killing role.

View attachment 240112

I am the town cop. I investigated RUDI in the first night and the result was "Not town".
Last night, I investigated asprin and the result was "town".

So either CK or zwarrior is the other scum.

Lynch - RUDI

Hey Doctor, I know you are reading this. Please save me in this night. I'll investigate either CK or zwarrior in this night.

@asprin , Please support me and request other members to lynch RUDI.

Just FYI, whoever the doctor is, they should not come out now. Although Ashu coming out has helped !

"You are survivor
You get one bulletproof vest to use at night.
You win when you are the last one left."

Tough winning conditions I know let me help you guys get rid of the scum.

How is that possible ? At any point of time, there has to be two person alive always right ? How an there be only one person alive in the end ? This is my reason not to believe you are survivor but a serial killer. Read my comments below for further analysis on this.

Okay, some huge revelations. Too bad @Yash. ended up being one of the targets. We are 1 person down.

The results confirm that there were 2 attempts made, so we can safely asssume at least 2 killing PRs. The good thing is that town also seems to have a role blocker and he was successful last night.


Do you realize by reveling this, you just signed your own death certificate? By definition, you are a threat to town since you need everyone dead in order to win which also includes town. And the fact that you've a bullet proof vest to use at night would mean you ought to be lynched during day. Anything to counter the above Rudi?

To @Ashutosh. , I have one question. If you got Rudi as "not town" on night 1 itself, then why are you choosing it to reveal it on now and not later (maybe day4)

I'm inclined to believe Ashutosh here as his result of "not town" checks out with Rudi's claim of being a survivor, i.e. not mafia.

I'll wait for thoughts from the other townie whoever that is before taking a stand.

Realistically speaking, if Ashutosh is saying the truth, then this is in Town's bag and the roleblocker will just have to save him tonight.

I really think Ashu is telling the truth. Otherwise Rudi would not have come out and said he is not a townie. It surely can't be a co-incidence that Ashu just guessed Rudi to be non-townie and it so happens like that. So, I am 100% sure that Ashu is a cop.

What good does that do to you if you know you can't win from here.

Another thing I feel is that there is something odd about your reveal. If you do not have kill ability and Yash is no longer alive, then this means both @zwarrior and @CerealKiller have kill abilities since there were two attempts made yesterday.

So that means the first person we should be lynching is one of zwarrior or CK today, let the other attempt another kill during night 3 (and hope the blocker is successful again) and then finally take care of him on Day 4.

And there's one more thing that just struck me. If AK and me are the only townies left alive and he is a cop then who performed the role block? Something is not aligning right here.[DOUBLEPOST=1605521532][/DOUBLEPOST]@Ashutosh. I would say you retract your lynch for now on Rudi. Let CK and zwarrior see what they have to say in their defense and then we will take it forward.

One thing for sure is that you're telling the truth as Rudi is not denying your outcome.

I can talk on my behalf and say I don't have a kill ability. My reason -

- One death is from mafia/serial killer (which we have been discussing since the start of game regarding how the game setup might be).
- Another attempted murder was stopped by doctor. According to you, if both of us have a night kill ability, then there are 3 non-townies (mafia, serial killer and survivor). I really find it hard to believe that we have 3 non-townies in this small setup.
-We know there is a serial killer because there were two attempts to kill people in the night and if there is 2 mafias, obviously both of them won't have the night kill ability. So, I am inclined to believe that Rudi is a serial killer who can kill in night and he tried to kill someone and was saved by the doctor. And since he is not mafia, results came as non-townie, which is true.
- Also see my point above to Rudi's reply on 2nd reason why I think Rudi is a serial killer.
-So I can say for sure I am townie and Rudi is serial killer (my analysis). Obviously this is the only proof or theory I have to show that I am a townie. If I survive today, Ashu can confirm as well in the night.

 

[Ashutosh.]

To @Ashutosh. , I have one question. If you got Rudi as "not town" on night 1 itself, then why are you choosing it to reveal it on now and not later (maybe day4)

I did not revealed on day 2 because I did not want to get killed on night 2. But when I knew there was a doctor who could save me at night, I revealed my role. The doctor should not come out now. He has to save me in the night and I will find the other scum.

 

[zwarrior]

"You are survivor
You get one bulletproof vest to use at night.
You win when you are the last one left."

Tough winning conditions I know let me help you guys get rid of the scum.

And another reason you can't be the last one left because since "as per your comments" you dont have a night kill ability, in the end even if someone gets lynched in the day, there will be two people left and if mafia/seriall killer kills in the night, there will be two person left.

So, you(serial killer) and mafia killed one person. And when another person was about to die, doc helped him. So, one of your kills failed(mafia or serial killer).

 

[RUDI]

Who killed Yash? zwarrior or CerealKiller? That is what you all should be asking. I know I am doomed going forward, it okay with me. Rather allow me to assist in finding Yash's killer and then lynch me.
Lynching me now takes you all nowhere forward. You all still have to find the other two.

Lynch me now. No worries to me. But its not going to answer the question on who killed Yash, because I didn't.

 

[CerealKiller]

Who killed Yash? zwarrior or CerealKiller? That is what you all should be asking. I know I am doomed going forward, it okay with me. Rather allow me to assist in finding Yash's killer and then lynch me.
Lynching me now takes you all nowhere forward. You all still have to find the other two.

Lynch me now. No worries to me. But its not going to answer the question on who killed Yash, because I didn't.

Not answering the questions posed to you.
The point of lynching you is not to find who killed Yash (although i believe you did, whether you are Mafia or Serial Killer), but the point is that you are the only confirmed Anti-Town.

 

[asprin]

At any point of time, there has to be two person alive always right ? How an there be only one person alive in the end ?

This is what I was waiting for. It's a bit strange that CK missed it. I didn't bring that up because I wanted to see if anyone spots it or not.

What do you have to say about the above @RUDI ? How can you be the sole person alive?

There's another thing which I'm surprised no one is talking about - part of the reason why I didn't lynch CK immediately as I thought a townie would notice it. But zwarrior didn't pay heed to it too, so I'm not sure what to make of it.