Gaurav_7
Executive member
- Joined
- Jan 3, 2010
- Profile Flag
- India
He might well be..
Mini Mafia - Town wins!
- Thread starter Gaurav_7
- Start date
puddleduck
Chairman of Selectors
Stop it now User. After spot the ball and now this closed mafia game, you've messed with my head enough lately haha
Sedition
Panel of Selectors
And one last thing before I fall into bed, I do find it odd as Sim mentioned that Hedger was trying to soft-claim cop and draw the kill if he was actually the cop.
If he was 90% sure that he was getting me lynched for being scum, I might have some company as I hit the scumhunt training grounds
If he was 90% sure that he was getting me lynched for being scum, I might have some company as I hit the scumhunt training grounds
Gaurav_7
Executive member
- Joined
- Jan 3, 2010
- Profile Flag
- India
Last pic was so easy!
Vote count
Sedition (1) - Manly
Manly (1) - Colin
4 needed for a lynch
puddleduck
Chairman of Selectors
Without trying to explain it for him, I suppose the only real way of looking at that is that he attempted to claim cop initially, but is quite sensibly trying to push away from it now that he hasn't got a result and feasibly can't be protected again?
----------
* only real way of looking at it from his side would*
----------
Manly lynch of Sedition is very dodgy, I'm changing my mind.
Lynch: Manly
----------
* only real way of looking at it from his side would*
----------
Manly lynch of Sedition is very dodgy, I'm changing my mind.
Lynch: Manly
I honestly can't be bothered to defend my position any further; if I get lynched tonight then so be it, you'll be making a mistake in lynching off a townie, but I'm vanilla, so other than a slight numerical disadvantage you won't be losing too much.
I've always played my cards on the table, (other than the post restriction thing) so you'll have to trust me.
My lynch stands until the end.
I've always played my cards on the table, (other than the post restriction thing) so you'll have to trust me.
My lynch stands until the end.
puddleduck
Chairman of Selectors
Damn you Manly. I'm so torn between you and Sedition, but Sedition could well be a very useful town power player, so I'd quite like to leave him alive (if only because the mafia might try to kill him tonight, or at least he might provide a target to further confuse the mafia). I can't help but feel if we're wrong about you, then at least it's not costly as you yourself have said, but if Sedition is indeed what he has claimed, we will feasibly miss him.
Still basically waiting for Hedger to get involved again after he's had some sleep, and I think a lot has happened since Adi posted. I think I'm leaving my lynch down, but I'm doing so thinking that if you are hammered out, whoever does so might well be mafia in the long run. A good cop investigation could help lots as well. Providing there even is one in this crazy game
Still basically waiting for Hedger to get involved again after he's had some sleep, and I think a lot has happened since Adi posted. I think I'm leaving my lynch down, but I'm doing so thinking that if you are hammered out, whoever does so might well be mafia in the long run. A good cop investigation could help lots as well. Providing there even is one in this crazy game
hedger_14
ICC Chairman
Yes, there is. And it's now what I'm leaning towards. Maf probably killed me and Sedition jailkept me so I had protected from the kill. And would also refer to the being popular bit while unsuccessful roles since cop, if they investigated me would get no result (because I was jailkept).
And sorry, I'm going to reread the last 3 pages in a minute.
----------
I'm vanilla. If I was mafia, I would have claimed cop ages at the start of the day or at least when I suggested cop should definitely out.
And the mafia kill was probably blocked because I was killed and jailkept at the same time.
----------
And also, now a HUGE FOS: Manly
I had assumed he was cop with those posts but it's not very vanilla like to post nothing day 1 and just say he has a shitty role.
----------
And really, trying to reread everything that's gone on is annoying. Cause I've forgotten half the stuff that's been said since I left already :/
Sedition
Panel of Selectors
I figured out a flaw in my plan of telling everyone who I'm blocking.. The mafia can just target that person, get the blocked result and frame them. There's still scenarios where announcing it could be helpful though I think.
If we mislynch today and there's still 2 mafia left, then my powers are reduced, so we kinda need to get it right.
I don't think jailkeeping someone stops them from being investigated and if Hedger isn't the cop, he can only be mafia or a 3rd party I guess. I'm back to my assumption though that the cop got a town result on him because he's the GF role that shows as such.
Lynch: Hedger_14
If we mislynch today and there's still 2 mafia left, then my powers are reduced, so we kinda need to get it right.
I don't think jailkeeping someone stops them from being investigated and if Hedger isn't the cop, he can only be mafia or a 3rd party I guess. I'm back to my assumption though that the cop got a town result on him because he's the GF role that shows as such.
Lynch: Hedger_14
hedger_14
ICC Chairman
Sedition, if you are town, you fail big time. Cause town will lose once they lynch you for being retarded tomorrow and gg mafia.
And I love how today, there was meant to be two clears and you're actually wanting to lynch the person who's meant to be clear (saved from night kill) and the cop isn't outting so yeah.
But really, why the fearsome tweak would I not claim cop in this situation if I was mafia. Even if I was and got cc'd, I'm sure I could have got you lynched, then mafia kill real cop at night (assuming there is a jailkeeper but no doc) and you's lynch me tomorrow but at least I would have put my mafia partner in a better position, with likely no clears at lylo, or one inno and then it's just down to scum-hunting.
And oh, you might not but your role should tell you anyway.
"Some Jailkeepers not only protect their target from all kills, but also render its target untargetable by all other actions during that Night."
----------
Also, if you are town, you really shouldn't be only focused on me. Because you don't have a heap of evidence that differentiates it from either being a doc save on me or blocking me. You just seem solely focused on getting me lynched, like a scum would.
But I know what it's like from your position, you think I'm mafia and you don't want to change it cause you think you're right, no matter what evidence is available to think otherwise and you don't think of how stupid you're going to look when you're wrong.
This is why I'm finding it hard to determine whether you're poor town or poor scum, cause even if you are scum, you aren't really playing this well and you're only likely to end up getting yourself lynched.
Anyway, I've had enough of listening to your ---- that you keep coming up with so it's there for others can decide. IMO, I think Manly is definitely mafia and a lynch on him would be much better used. Otherwise, we can nl again, you can block me, mafia nk to try and frame me but at least the cop has another report. And if somebody dies, then I'm obviously not the godfather.
In fact, I'm pretty sure it's been you that has continuously mentioned a godfather, like you actually know there is one cause you or your mafia partner is one, and you just want to make it look like I'm the godfather instead.
And I love how today, there was meant to be two clears and you're actually wanting to lynch the person who's meant to be clear (saved from night kill) and the cop isn't outting so yeah.
But really, why the fearsome tweak would I not claim cop in this situation if I was mafia. Even if I was and got cc'd, I'm sure I could have got you lynched, then mafia kill real cop at night (assuming there is a jailkeeper but no doc) and you's lynch me tomorrow but at least I would have put my mafia partner in a better position, with likely no clears at lylo, or one inno and then it's just down to scum-hunting.
And oh, you might not but your role should tell you anyway.
"Some Jailkeepers not only protect their target from all kills, but also render its target untargetable by all other actions during that Night."
----------
Also, if you are town, you really shouldn't be only focused on me. Because you don't have a heap of evidence that differentiates it from either being a doc save on me or blocking me. You just seem solely focused on getting me lynched, like a scum would.
But I know what it's like from your position, you think I'm mafia and you don't want to change it cause you think you're right, no matter what evidence is available to think otherwise and you don't think of how stupid you're going to look when you're wrong.
This is why I'm finding it hard to determine whether you're poor town or poor scum, cause even if you are scum, you aren't really playing this well and you're only likely to end up getting yourself lynched.
Anyway, I've had enough of listening to your ---- that you keep coming up with so it's there for others can decide. IMO, I think Manly is definitely mafia and a lynch on him would be much better used. Otherwise, we can nl again, you can block me, mafia nk to try and frame me but at least the cop has another report. And if somebody dies, then I'm obviously not the godfather.
In fact, I'm pretty sure it's been you that has continuously mentioned a godfather, like you actually know there is one cause you or your mafia partner is one, and you just want to make it look like I'm the godfather instead.
Sedition
Panel of Selectors
Seriously, still with the retarded bs? You must have developed an inferiority complex from being surrounded by Australians all day and not being one yourself.
If you're vanilla townie, then so be it. Cop didn't claim when he probably should have and given the results of the actions and only one gave the correct result, it's a high likelihood that in your position you're mafia.
If you're vanilla townie, then so be it. Cop didn't claim when he probably should have and given the results of the actions and only one gave the correct result, it's a high likelihood that in your position you're mafia.
simsanta123
Club Cricketer
Weren't you the one saying cop shouldn't claim?
----------
Manly has been acting weird tbh. He hasn't even defended the lynches upon him. I hope he is not some sort of a fool or something. In a short game like this, I guess it is possibility, but then again I dont think this role has ever been used here in PC. (Or it might have been, I don't know)
Out of Sedition/Hedger, I am more inclined to believe Hedger, mainly due to Sedition's last post in which he pressed for a Hedger lynch. We all know there is a possibility of both of them being town, and why not test that possibility tonight (cop/jailkeeper). IMO it is better to lynch the person acting scummy right now, which is Manly, though he lack of defence makes me a bit uneasy. Could that be that he is so uninterested in the game that he won't defend himself even though he might be a vanilla townie?
Still, based on what all has happened,
I would FOS: Manly, won't lynch him till everybody has decided to do so.
----------
Oh sorry. I skipped that post by mistake. So Manly did acknowledge the lynches upon him, but no real defence.
puddleduck
Chairman of Selectors
I'm all for Sedition protecting me tonight 
If we do lynch off a mafia today and I can't be killed tonight, we win this I'm sure (unless someone goes inactive I get bored )
If we do lynch off a mafia today and I can't be killed tonight, we win this I'm sure (unless someone goes inactive I get bored )
hedger_14
ICC Chairman
Why do we win if we lynch maf and you can't be killed tonight? Or have I missed something, lol.
Anyway, I'm fairly certain Manly is the mafia now. Really, he isn't playing like a vanilla townie, which was why I thought he was a power role. So:
Lynch: Manly
Because I'm not entirely sure we should lynch between me and Sedition, since I'm leaning town on Sedition about 60%.
puddleduck
Chairman of Selectors
Mostly because with my soft claiming I think I could be a mafia target and despite his scummyness all game I think his claim is genuine hence why I won't lynch Sedition. He could be vital to us winning this. The only problem I have is, even though I'm only soft claiming doc to make things tricky for the maf, if Sedition does block me, he can't be saved and the mafia could kill him? That is of course if I'm the Doc, which I'm not. So the doc would need to save Sedition tonight and if Sedition saves me.. And the mafia targets one of us two, they fail to night kill again and we are surely in a really strong position?
Similar threads
